
...

By Matthew Robinson
News Editor
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
New York Mayor Zohran Mamdani's approval rating is underwater in Staten Island as he prepares to mark his first 100 days in office this week, according to a new poll.
The Marist Poll survey, conducted between March 26 and 31, showed that 27 percent of respondents in Staten Island approved of Mamdani's performance, while 57 percent disapproved and 16 percent were unsure.
The poll was conducted among 1,454 adults and had a margin of error of plus or minus 3.3 percentage points.
Read More on News

...
Other New York Boroughs' Approval Rating for Mamdani
The findings in Staten Island were sharply different from New York's other boroughs, where Mamdani's approval rating was significantly higher.
In the Bronx, 45 percent approved of the mayor's performance, while 19 percent disapproved; in Brooklyn, 54 percent approved, while 26 percent disapproved; in Manhattan, 55 percent approved, while 29 percent disapproved; and in Queens, 42 percent approved, while 34 percent disapproved.
Overall, 48 percent of respondents approved of Mamdani's performance, while 30 percent disapproved, resulting in a net positive approval rating of 18 percentage points.
A Familiar Political Divide
The borough‑level gap mirrors long-standing political and ideological divisions in the city. Staten Island is the most conservative of the five boroughs and the only one that has consistently supported Republican presidential candidates in recent elections.
Mamdani, a self‑described Democratic Socialist who took office on January 1, runs—and governs—on an agenda centered on wealth redistribution, expanded public services and progressive criminal justice reforms. These are positions that polling and past election results suggest resonate less strongly with Staten Island voters.
Party identification appears to be a major factor. The Marist poll showed that 63 percent of Republicans citywide disapproved of Mamdani's performance, while 25 percent approved. By contrast, 63 percent of Democrats approved of his leadership, while 20 percent disapproved—highlighting the deep partisanship shaping perceptions of his administration.
Performance Ratings on Key Issues
Staten Island residents also diverge more sharply from the rest of the city on specific governance questions. While 65 percent of citywide respondents approved of Mamdani's handling of winter snowstorms, approval on Staten Island dropped to 30 percent, the lowest of any borough. Majorities in Manhattan, Brooklyn, Queens and the Bronx all backed the mayor's storm response.
Despite weak borough‑level support, Mamdani has seen broader improvements in how New Yorkers view the city's overall direction. The Marist poll found that 56 percent of residents said New York City was moving in the right direction, up sharply from 31 percent in October.
Implications Going Forward
While Staten Island accounts for a smaller share of the city's electorate, its resistance highlights the limits of Mamdani's early coalition and the challenges he faces as he heads into budget negotiations and legislative fights later this year.
For now, the polling suggests Mamdani is consolidating support in the city's liberal strongholds while struggling to gain traction in its most conservative borough—a dynamic likely to shape both his policy strategy and political messaging as his first year continues.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines