
...

By Jack Beresford
Senior Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
A Pennsylvania woman’s deep dive into her family’s past took her back to the Battle of Gettysburg and an unexpected love story.
Retiree Susan Alexander, 76, lives in Vermont but grew up on Philadelphia’s Main Line and has always felt a special connection to Gettysburg.
“My maternal grandfather, Grover Cleveland Thompson, was born and raised in Hunterstown, just five miles northeast of Gettysburg in Adams County. We grew up going there every chance we could,” Alexander told Newsweek.
Read More on Family & Parenting
“Gettysburg is a very special place. There's something in the atmosphere there that has nothing to do with the battle. When you're there, you breathe it; you feel it; it just surrounds you.”
Alexander first became interested in her family history after moving to Los Angeles in the 1970s, where she played drums in several local bands, attended college, and worked as a journalist.
“A good friend of mine was researching her family tree, and I caught the genealogy bug,” she said. “The Family History Center in West Los Angeles had an extensive genealogy collection of microfilm records and books. I did a lot of research there, starting with my four grandparents' names and birthplaces. I struck gold finding census records for all four, and I was off to the races finding their family records.”
Whenever she returned to visit her parents in the years that followed, they regularly visited the Adams County Historical Society in Gettysburg and the Pennsylvania State Library, where her research continued.
However, it was only years later, with the advent of the internet, that Alexander—who was then living in Vermont with her mother following her father’s death—gained access to a wealth of records through MyHeritage.
“I've met new relatives through the site, not to mention found so many more records,” she said. “I found archives of The Gettysburg Times and old articles in The Gettysburg Compiler.”
It was through decades of family research, National Archives records, civil records, pension files, vintage newspaper interviews, and other historical documents that Alexander learned about Bill Thompson.

...
Union Soldier and Gettysburg Nurse Fall in Love
Thompson was an English-born Union soldier who crossed the Atlantic to fight for his adopted country. He served with the Third New York Independent Battery and was wounded during the brutal fighting at Gettysburg in July 1863, when the small farming town was transformed into a vast network of makeshift hospitals.
That was where he met Margaret Slonaker. Slonaker lived near the Adams County Almshouse and was among the many local citizens called into nursing service as thousands of wounded soldiers filled homes, churches, and public buildings.
Slonaker cared for the wounded Thompson during this period and, as Alexander discovered, an unexpected romance blossomed between them.
“Out of such a horrible experience for both of them of death and destruction, they found each other and fell in love,” she said.
After recovering, Thompson went on to serve with the 17th Pennsylvania Cavalry, fighting through to Appomattox Court House in April 1865. That could easily have been the end of their story—but it wasn’t.
Civil War Sweethearts Reunited After the Fighting Ended
Alexander also has access to records including obituaries, later newspaper features, and a post-war photography. Through this she learned that when the Civil War ended, Thompson returned to Gettysburg and proposed to Slonaker.
“He carried her memory with him throughout the rest of the war, and after all was said and done and peace was finally gained,” Alexander said.
“He came back to Gettysburg to marry her and adopt her son, my great-grandfather, and make a family together.”
The couple married in 1866, raised a family in Pennsylvania, and Thompson later became one of Carlisle’s oldest and most celebrated citizens.
Alexander’s mother has since passed away, but her decades-long ancestry journey has continued. Along the way, she has uncovered relatives who played roles in some of the most significant events in early American history.

...
Genealogy Research Reveals Revolutionary War Connections
“I've found quite a few family members who fought in the American Revolution,” she said. “My fifth-great-grandfather, James Alexander, served in the Commissary Department of Washington's army at Valley Forge during the winter of 1777-78.
“His brother Hugh, while serving as a member of the Continental Congress, received a letter from his son John, who was with Washington fighting at Trenton, asking his father to send food.”
Yet it is the story of Thompson and Slonaker that has most profoundly changed the way she feels when she visits the places they once walked in Gettysburg and Hunterstown.
“My heart just swells when I'm there, or even when I think about it,” she said. “I can also visit their gravesites to pay my respects and silently thank them.”
Ultimately, Alexander’s ancestry journey has taught her two important lessons: family history can be endlessly fascinating, and, as corny as she admits it may sound, “love conquers all.”
MyHeritage is inviting people to explore how their family’s past fits into the larger story of America - via this link.
Contact Newsweek editors on this story: Rebecca Flood and Emma Lee-Sang.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines