
...

By Anders Anglesey
U.S. News Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
Christmas is meant to be a time when people come together and celebrate, but an unusual dilemma could tear one family apart this holiday season.
In a viral post uploaded to the Am I The ******* page on Reddit, user prudentmom explained that she and her husband are in the process of adopting five-year-old Spencer and that the process should be finalized after Christmas.
The December 11 post, which attracted more than 6,700 upvotes and can be seen here, then explained that Spencer is her husband's half-brother from his father's second marriage. Spencer's father died shortly after he was born.
Read More
Teen Waving at Elderly Woman Every Day Gets Sweetest Surprise—’I’m Sobbing’4 min read

Woman Billing Boyfriend $1,000 After Staying at Her House Backed3 min read

Wife’s Heartwarming Reaction to Partner’s New Hair After ‘Identity Crisis’3 min read

She added that her husband's brothers, Charlie and Mike, both in their 30s, had been supportive, but that recently Charlie appeared to take issue with the relationship.

...
"When Spencer began calling us mama and daddy, Charlie found it odd," the Reddit user said. "He said that we weren't his parents. I said legally, yes we are. I said he doesn't have to be 'Uncle Charlie' if he doesn't want to be, but we are raising him. Charlie says that we're basically erasing their dad from Spencer's life. I said no, we talk about him and Spencer's bio (biological) mom often. This won't be a secret."
The issue festered further when Charlie talked to Spencer. He referred to her and her husband by their first names and said things such as: "Ask your brother," or "Go show your sister-in-law."
"We were trying to let it go but then one day, Charlie corrected Spencer when he called me 'mama' and said 'no, that's Kate,'" the Reddit user said.
"Spencer got confused and said 'No, that's mama.' Charlie told him that I'm not his mother. This only upset Spencer further.
"I've had enough, frankly. Spencer is our son. We have him in therapy and have also asked Charlie and Mike to attend family therapy with us. Only Mike has agreed. I told my husband that I don't want Charlie at Christmas (we're hosting) if he's just going to upset Spencer and undermine our place as his parents.
"My husband said it's completely up to me. So, I told Charlie either he stops correcting Spencer or he can't come."
But the decision did not go down well with Charlie, who said he believed the Reddit user wanted to keep the brothers apart at Christmas.
Charlie then called the poster dramatic after she said he could attend if he stopped "undermining my place."
Expert's View
Dr. Traci Williams, a psychologist at the Atlanta-based Poui Consulting, told Newsweek there are multiple ways the family could manage the situation.
"Parents' top priority is the care and protection of their children. For little Spencer, the poster and her husband are his parents and he appears attached to them as parent figures. It is understandable for the poster, his mother figure, to be upset," she said.
"Uncle Charlie's comments are likely to be confusing to Spencer since he would not have strong recollections of his biological parents. These comments can also be devaluing to Spencer and his parents. By disinviting uncle Charlie, the poster is drawing a boundary around her child and her family, making it clear that uncle Charlie's reactions are not okay. To protect their children, it's parents' responsibility and right to implement boundaries with others.
"It is important for us to consider all sides in this. Uncle Charlie may be hurting and grieving from the losses this family has experienced," Williams continued.
"Having his brother adopted might feel dismissive of the biological parents' roles in his life. Uncle Charlie also may not have prior experience with adoption and child development.
"All kids need healthy attachment to caregivers in order to thrive, and this is especially important for kids who have experienced the loss of their biological parents. If Uncle Charlie understood this, perhaps his perspective would shift."
Online Reaction
Newsweek found the majority of people who commented on the post were supportive of the Reddit user.
YouthNAsia63, whose comment was upvoted more than 8,300 times, said: "If you are hosting, OP (original poster) then you can make the guest list and ignore any comments from the peanut gallery. If MIL (mother-in-law) wants to spend time with Charlie, she may certainly do so, but she may do it elsewhere.
"Charlie needs to learn to keep his mouth shut. What your little boy calls you is not up to him and it's none of his business. If Charlie doesn't behave, Charlie can't come to the party. It's that simple."
Ceecee_soup added: "I've been practicing holding people to the same standards of respect that I hold myself. If I can put myself in that person's shoes and still say honestly that I would never act that way, it makes it easier to stop making excuses for people."
No-Abies-1232 commented: "Don't back down. Your options are not about you and your feelings. You need to put your foot down to protect your son."
Have you had a Christmas dilemma? Let us know via life@newsweek.com. We can ask experts for advice on relationships, family, friends, money, and work, and your story could be featured on Newsweek's "What Should I Do? section.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines