Frustrated, girl and night in home with phone notification and bored online with social media or chat. Reading, news and woman scroll smartphone with insomnia, stress and late search on internet

...

Darlin Tillery

By Darlin Tillery

Life & Trends Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


A 24-year-old woman said she felt she had experienced the “best date” of her life after meeting a 25-year-old man on Hinge, only for the connection to unravel days later when his communication dropped off almost entirely.

In a post shared on Reddit, the woman and original poster (OP), user definitelynopickles, described a marathon first date on March 20 that lasted from 8 p.m. until 5 a.m.

The pair discussed topics ranging from religion to mental health and future goals. She said he joked about future dates and paid for the evening, which ended with the two having sex.

Read More on Life

She was optimistic about what might come next. Her optimism, however, proved to be short-lived.

Stock image: A woman staring at her phone in a dark room.

...

"I texted him about a second date and received no response," the OP wrote. "Would go 3+ days without answering me.

“I finally had enough and realized he’s just not that into me,” she added, describing the experience as “whiplash.”

Screenshots shared alongside the post show friendly exchanges early on, followed by delayed replies and logistical communication about returning her clothing.

After collecting the top from his porch, she sent a final message confirming it had been retrieved and she had also left his shirt.

She then blocked his number and unmatched him on Hinge

Reddit Reacts

Responses to her post were blunt, with one Reddit user writing, “Nor, but it sounds like he only wanted sex, and was willing to do and say whatever needed to be done to get it.”

Another added, “Can’t BELIEVE he wouldn’t hand the shirt to you or have a 5 min chat when you’re literally at his place. Left it in a bag like a dog s***.

They urged, "Never speak to him again and feel warned for the same man appearing in different forms on dating apps in the future.”

aio for blocking him due to lack of communication
r/AmIOverreacting

View this post on Reddit

Relationship experts say these kinds of patterns can sometimes be identified early.

“There are several red flags to look for when on a first date that can indicate problems or even toxic behavior further down the line,” Tammy Nelson told Newsweek in a report on dating warning signs.

Nelson added, “Love bombing usually starts before you even meet in person, so watch for signs in your pre-date communication,” describing overly intense early attention as a potential indicator of future inconsistency.

Communication Breakdown

Guidance on dating behavior also points to communication gaps as a concern.

According to advice outlined in WikiHow, “If you have trouble getting a hold of your boyfriend… or he might leave you on read for hours (or days),” it may suggest a lack of genuine interest beyond physical interaction.

The OP's experience, including long gaps between replies and the change after the pair had sex, aligns with several of those warning signs.

While she questioned whether blocking him was an overreaction, many commenters argued it was a reasonable response to inconsistent communication and mixed signals.

As one Redditor put it: "You did the right thing if you’re looking for a healthy relationship."

Newsweek has reached out to definitelynopickles for comment via Reddit. We could not verify the details of the case.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines