...
By Lydia Patrick
Life & Trends Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
A woman who spent half a year receiving unexplained deliveries of cat food at her front door has gone viral after revealing the unlikely—and very close‑to‑home—reason behind the mystery.
Threads user Isabel Marsh, posting under the handle @marshisabel, shared her story in a post that has garnered more than 200,000 views, detailing how boxes of Fancy Feast cat food began arriving at her home without warning—and without any explanation she could find.
“Story time,” Marsh wrote. “So for the past six months, I've been receiving random boxes of Fancy Feast at my door. Two boxes a month, like clockwork. I did not order these. I have no subscription. I don't even remember the last time I manually bought cat food. But this is the food my cats eat.”
Read More on Life
Confused and increasingly alarmed, Marsh said she went “full detective mode,” checking every credit card and bank statement she had, along with her Amazon order history. According to her post, there was no record anywhere of a recurring charge or subscription linked to the deliveries.
“I am losing my mind,” she added.
Marsh said she even contacted Amazon support directly, sharing photos of the boxes and shipping labels. Despite the company’s famously detailed tracking of user activity, the support team was unable to pinpoint the source of the recurring shipments.
“Amazon, the company that tracks what you glanced at for 0.3 seconds in 2019, cannot explain why I keep receiving this cat food,” she wrote.
At one point, Marsh said she took the drastic step of canceling her cards one by one, hoping to cut off any “phantom subscription” responsible for the deliveries. That, too, failed.
“New debit card from my bank. Fresh start. Surely this stops the Fancy Feast,” Marsh wrote. “Reader, it did not stop the Fancy Feast.”
The mystery became so persistent that Marsh said she began questioning her own memory, wondering whether she might have unknowingly set up the order herself—or even done so while intoxicated. She checked other retailers, including Chewy, just in case there was an old account routing deliveries through Amazon.
Eventually, she said, she gave up searching for answers.
...
“I just… accepted my fate,” Marsh wrote. “The universe has decided I receive Fancy Feast. My cats are thriving. They've never been happier. Maybe this is just my life now.”
The truth, she explained, only emerged six months later during a casual dinner conversation with her brother.
“He goes, completely off the cuff: ‘Oh hey, I meant to tell you you've been getting our cat food delivered to your place,’” Marsh wrote. “I set my fork down. I stared at him.”
The culprit, it turned out, was her own brother, who had accidentally shipped his household’s Amazon cat food subscription to the wrong saved address—hers—and then failed to mention it for half a year.
“My brother shipped to the wrong address saved on his Amazon account. For six months,” Marsh wrote. “I canceled every card I own. I interrogated Amazon support. I genuinely questioned my own sobriety. And my brother just… forgot to mention it.”
She added: “My cats have been fed by their uncle this whole time and nobody told me. I have all new cards now. The cats don't care.”
The post sparked thousands of amused reactions from fellow Threads users, many of whom joked about the accidental generosity.
“Your cats had a sugar uncle,” wrote one user.
Another added: “Your brother is now officially responsible to feed your cats. Tell him if the delivery stops you are calling CPS about cat support.”
Others said they would have happily accepted the unexplained deliveries. “If I was getting random boxes of Fancy Feast dropped at my door each month and didn’t see any money coming out of my bank account… I would consider it a gift from the cat gods,” one commenter wrote.
For Marsh, the mystery has been solved—albeit at the cost of unnecessary stress, canceled cards, and hours spent chasing a problem that turned out to be entirely familial.
Newsweek reached out to @marshisabel, for comment via Instagram. We could not verify the details of the case.
Do you have funny and adorable videos or pictures of your pet you want to share? Send them to life@newsweek.com with some details about your best friend and they could appear in our Pet of the Week lineup.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines