Coworkers fight over baby name

...

Taylor McCloud

By Taylor McCloud

Staff Writer

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


Commenters were quick to defend one expecting mother who explained why she called her coworker a hypocrite in a popular internet forum.

In a viral Reddit post published on r/AmITheA**hole, Redditor u/Creative_Chance_5077 (otherwise referred to as the original poster, or OP) said that she and her husband have considered naming their daughter after a Harry Potter character—something one of her coworkers vehemently disagreed with.

Titled, "AITA for calling my coworker a hypocrite for giving her baby a 'nerdy' name," the viral post has received more than 8,000 votes and 1,500 comments in the last day.

Read More

Resurfaced Photo of 20-Year-Old Nancy Pelosi With JFK Stuns the Internet3 min read

Resurfaced Photo of 20-Year-Old Nancy Pelosi With JFK Stuns the Internet

Internet Backs Woman Who Called Sibling a ‘Mama’s Boy’: ‘Truth Hurts’5 min read

Internet Backs Woman Who Called Sibling a ‘Mama’s Boy’: ‘Truth Hurts’

Quitting Employee Exposing Employer’s ‘Weird Mind Games’ Backed by Internet4 min read

Quitting Employee Exposing Employer’s ‘Weird Mind Games’ Backed by Internet

Writing that the couple has yet to "lock in" a name for their baby just yet, the original poster said they are leaning towards Minerva, after Professor Minerva McGonagall from the fictional Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry.

However, after discussing the potential baby name at work, the original poster recounted the criticism she received from a coworker, referred to as Gwen.

"My coworkers and I were talking about my upcoming maternity leave when it got to names. I said we hadn't decided but like Minerva," she wrote. "It should be noted that it is a well known fact in my office that I am a huge Harry Potter fan."

"Gwen started interrupting me and telling me that I shouldn't 'force my fandom' on my baby by giving her a Harry Potter name," she continued. "I get what she means, but then I said this: 'Okay, but you named your daughter after Harley Quinn, right? Isn't that the same thing?'"

Explaining that Harley Quinn is a character within the DC Comics Universe, the original poster questioned why naming a baby after one fictional character is acceptable, while naming a baby after a character from a separate fictional universe is not.

"I don't know what [Gwen] is like at home, but naming your baby after a comics character is not better than if it's from another fandom?" she wrote.

Coworkers fight over baby name

...

Naming children after fictional characters is not a new phenomenon, and is not limited to Harry Potter and DC Comics.

For years, parents have bestowed the names of beloved kings, queens, mermaids, witches, wizards, Jedis and so many other major figures featured in television series, movies and books.

Two years ago, Buzzfeed published a list of the 16 most popular names derived from fictional characters.

Included on the list were Elsa (from Disney's Frozen), Anakin (from Star Wars), Ariel (from Disney's The Little Mermaid), Katniss (from The Hunger Games) and Khaleesi (from Game of Thrones), among others.

In the case of Khaleesi, also known as Daenerys, Vulture reported in 2019 that hundreds of babies were born with both monikers, and that Khaleesi, specifically, had become one of the 1,000 most popular baby names during the year prior.

Through the first seven seasons of Game of Thrones, Khaleesi would have seemed like a valiant name. But after the final season of HBO's thrilling series saw the character turn into the bloodthirsty "Mad Queen," the connotations associated with the name transformed entirely.

In her viral Reddit post, the original poster remained adamant that name choices are parents' to make, and that they should be respected, regardless of the fictional universes they come from.

"If you name your baby after a fictional character, then you shouldn't criticize others for doing the same thing," she wrote. "Even if you hate the other fandom."

Redditors responding to the viral post echoed that sentiment.

"You're [not the a**hole]," Redditor u/Fritemare assured the original poster, in a comment that has received nearly 4,000 votes.

"[Minerva] is an actual name. It was a name before Harry Potter came along," they continued. "It's also super hypocritical for them to call you out when they literally named their kids after their fandoms."

Redditor u/TahiniInMyVeins, whose comment has received nearly 2,000 votes, responded directly to the viral post's title, and said that the original poster was justified to call out her coworker.

"You didn't criticize Gwen for naming her kid a 'nerdy' name," they wrote. "You criticized Gwen for being a hypocrite."

In the post's top comment, which has received more than more than 15,000 votes, Redditor u/waywardjynx relayed a similar message.

"[Not the a**hole]," they commented. "She embarrassed herself."

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines