Greenhouse gases power plant

...

Jeff Young

By Jeff Young

Environment and Sustainability Editor

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


Andrew Dessler is a professor of atmospheric sciences at Texas A&M University with a respected record as an author and editor for scientific journals. His latest project coordinates scientists' response to a Trump administration report that claims that climate change is not really all that dangerous.

"It is very carefully constructed, I think, to give people the opposite view of what's actually happening," Dessler told Newsweek.

The report from the Department of Energy (DOE), which was not externally peer-reviewed, was co-authored by five scientists who were hand-selected by the administration. Dessler said those scientists "don't represent the mainstream view" of climate science.

Read More on News

"The only way you'd get this report is if you picked these exact scientists," Dessler said. "If you picked five random climate scientists, you would get a completely different report."

Greenhouse gases power plant

...

Dessler is just one of many leading climate scientists who voiced concerns about the DOE report, saying it is riddled with errors, shows signs of bias and misrepresents some research findings in order to downplay the threats from climate change.

After sifting through sections on heat waves, ice melt, agricultural impacts and other climate effects, Dessler said the final reply weighs in at a hefty 439 pages—about three times longer than the original report.

"This is related to Brandolini's law," Dessler said on the social media site Bluesky, referencing a popular maxim about misinformation. "The amount of energy needed to refute [B.S.] is an order of magnitude bigger than that needed to produce it."

Dessler and the dozens of scientists who contributed to the response were willing to do that extra work because of the high stakes involved. Far from just an arcane scientific dispute, the DOE report is part of a larger effort to roll back more than a decade of climate-related regulations.

The Trump administration is working to revoke a landmark 2009 government finding that climate change and the greenhouse gases causing it constitute a threat to public health and welfare. That ruling, known as the "endangerment" finding, provided the scientific and legal basis for the regulation of greenhouse gases.

Overturning it could begin to unravel more than a decade of rules on emissions from power plants, autos and other sources, a move that has massive implications for our environment and economy.

Environmental Protection Agency Administrator Lee Zeldin said at a press event in late July that he thought that rules limiting carbon pollution were a greater danger than climate change.

"Emissions standards themselves, not carbon dioxide which the finding never assessed independently, was the real threat to Americans' livelihoods," Zeldin said.

The administration's extraordinary action would remove a keystone of the country's climate regulation just as the world experiences unprecedented heat and climate-driven extreme weather disasters. Climate scientists have determined that the last two years have been the warmest on record and likely the hottest in thousands of years.

Clean energy leaders said that revoking the endangerment finding also puts businesses at risk.

"Policy uncertainty, especially on something as important as climate change, is going to be detrimental to investment," Lisa Jacobson, president of the Business Council for Sustainable Energy, told Newsweek. "It's going to disrupt business planning that's already been underway."

Jacobson's group has 65 member companies and trade associations focused on energy efficiency, natural gas, renewable energy, energy storage and sustainable transportation. She said energy businesses have been able to reduce emissions from the power sector as the economy grew.

"We don't have to choose between growing our economy, meeting new energy resource needs and addressing air quality and climate change," Jacobson said. "But what we need is a clear direction on policy to enable us to make these long-term investments."

A retreat from federal regulation could sow chaos, Jacobson said.

"It will make more of a patchwork of policies," she warned. "And I think a big concern to industry is the litigation risk."

Anne Kelly is vice president of government relations for Ceres, a nonprofit organization that works with businesses and investors to accelerate a clean energy transition. She said the legal landscape for companies could become far more difficult without the EPA regulating greenhouse gas emissions.

"As a baseline for stability and predictability, the law has served us well for 16 years," Kelly told Newsweek. "It kind of levels the playing field by having one clear, certain administrative remedy."

The Supreme Court determined in 2011 that climate-related legal claims against private entities were displaced by EPA's authority to regulate greenhouse gases. Removing that authority could open the courtroom doors to more lawsuits against businesses.

When President Trump first proposed revoking the endangerment finding during his first term in office, the Congressional Research Service cautioned that "climate change litigation may potentially increase."

Kelly said the administration's move to undo climate regulation on behalf of industry could end up exposing businesses to more liability.

"You take away the stability of the administrative rule, well, now you're into the Wild West of common law, nuisance, who knows?" she said. "It's almost like the more conservative position is to stick with what has worked up to this time."

The administration has extended its comment period on its proposal to revoke the endangerment finding to September 22. The comments the agencies receive will include the 400-plus page response from Andrew Dessler and other scientists.

"People are really mad," Dessler said. "When we see something like this, something that is really a mockery of science, it can't help but just infuriate you."

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines