Apple Music

...

Thomas Westerholm

By Thomas Westerholm

Life & Trends Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


Apple’s latest attempt to integrate artificial intelligence into Apple Music has drawn sharp criticism from users for inconsistent and sometimes nonsensical results.

The feature, known as “Playlist Playground,” is designed to let users generate playlists using natural language prompts.

Apple has positioned it as a creative tool that can build mixes based on moods, themes or specific requests.

Read More on Life

However, early testing suggests the tool struggles with even basic instructions.

Apple Music

...

Why It Matters

Apple, like many of its competitors, is incorporating AI into consumer products, particularly in media and entertainment.

Music streaming platforms are increasingly experimenting with recommendation engines powered by generative AI, which could reshape how users discover songs.

Many users find music using playlists, discovering new artists and new songs, which in turn can help shape an individual's musical preferences.

What To Know

Playlist Playground allows users to type prompts such as “songs for a rainy day” or “upbeat workout mix,” and Apple Music generates a playlist in response.

The feature is intended to “generate playlists using Apple Intelligence” and can be refined with additional prompts to tweak results.

Despite that promise, reports indicate the tool often misinterprets requests.

A review by The Verge found that the system frequently included songs that did not match the requested genre, mood or even language. Terrence O'Brien wrote that the feature “is bad at music."

Other users reported that the tool can't handle basic requests. The AI struggled to interpret straightforward instructions, such as genre-specific or era-based playlists.

What People Are Saying

Commenters on Reddit's r/apple forum were unsurprised that the feature is struggling, with one writing, "Apple’s AI is bad; we’ve known this.

"Seems like people inside Apple are just shipping AI features without much testing or maintenance."

"They seem very dedicated to making most AI local, which this also is," another user replied.

"And there’s just a world of difference between a flagship model and anything you can run on your phone, we’re talking probably like a 1000x size difference.

"I think that’s why it has been so laughably bad."

One commenter noted, "Several times and ways I've asked it for a high bpm electronic playlist and it shoves in the slowest bpm s*** it can find.

"Including random no-name 'Royalty Free Electro #26' by FreeEDM DJ songs. It's actually a joke."

Finally, one user pointed out that making playlists manually is a fun experience.

"The thought that goes into it, the tweaking to get the feel right, the joy of coming up with prompts for yourself and trying to find the perfect songs that fit," they wrote.

"Why do we keep trying to automate everything that makes life worth living?

What's Next

The company has not publicly detailed how frequently the feature will be updated, but ongoing adjustments are likely as Apple competes with other platforms investing heavily in AI-driven personalization.

Newsweek has reached out to Apple for comment via email.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines