
...

By Alice Gibbs
Senior Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
A millennial woman has been backed after refusing to make her sister-in-law's lavish wedding cake completely free of charge.
In a post on Reddit's popular r/AITAH (Am I the A******) subreddit, user silweddingcake asked if she was wrong for refusing to bake her family member's cake as a gift.
The post, titled "AITAH for refusing to make my SIL's wedding cake for free?", was shared by the 29-year-old baker who detailed a fallout with her sister-in-law after she declined to provide a multi-tiered wedding cake—complete with custom flavors and décor—at no charge.
Read More on Family & Parenting
The baker, who has spent five years building her baking business, said she was initially happy to make the cake. But after quoting a discounted rate, her sister-in-law, 33, responded with surprise, assuming the cake would be a free wedding gift.
"I told her that I don't typically do wedding cakes as gifts because of how much time and work they take," the baker wrote in the post, adding that she offered to buy a gift from the couple's registry instead or still make the cake at the discounted price.
The response? Her SIL accused her of "trying to profit off her happiness" and hung up.
New York wedding planner and founder of The Main Event by Kelly, Kelly Jeanmaire, told Newsweek: "It's totally fair for a family member to ask, but not to expect a professional service for free. Just because someone is in the family doesn't mean their time and expertise suddenly have no value.

...
"Custom wedding cakes can be really expensive. I've seen couples spend anywhere from $500 to $2,000 depending on the size, style, and bakery. And it's not just about the cake itself, it's the delivery, setup, tastings, insurance, passing on other business for that day, and everything in between," Jeanmaire said. "So when someone offers a discount or another gift instead, that's more than reasonable."
The post quickly went viral, earning over 8,700 upvotes and more than 1,700 comments in just a few days, with the vast majority of Redditors backing the original poster.
"I'm impressed you didn't send her a YouTube link so she could learn to do it herself," one commenter quipped.
Another wrote: "NTA your SIL is being an entitled cheapskate."
"At this point, do NOT do this cake even if she offers to pay. She is TROUBLE," advised another commenter.
Many in the thread, especially fellow bakers and small business owners, rallied around the poster, noting how often creative or "domestic" skills are undervalued—particularly when offered by women in family contexts.
"I am a baker. Do not undervalue your work," said one commenter. "For very close friends and family, I will consider cakes a gift, but there's only one more on my list and then they'll all be charged."
According to wedding planning site Zola's First Look Report, the average cost of a wedding cake in the U.S. in 2025 is $600–$900, with "large and elaborate" designs reaching well over $1,000.
The cake described in the post, a four-tier chocolate sponge with raspberry filling, floral piping, and cascading real flowers, would likely fall into that higher range, not to mention personal delivery on the day of the event, as requested by the bride.
The baker explained that her family have asked her to re-think her stance, with her mother-in-law reportedly begging her to reconsider "just to keep the peace," and while her wife is supportive, she admitted she wished the whole thing had been handled more quietly to avoid family drama.
"Fallouts over weddings happen all the time. Weddings bring out big emotions, big expectations, and sometimes unrealistic assumptions," Jeanmaire said. "The best way to avoid this is to communicate clearly early on. If you're asking a loved one for a service, be upfront: are you asking as a paying client or hoping they'll gift it? And if you're the one being asked, it's okay to set boundaries and explain your reasons without guilt."
But online, people urged her not to change her mind. As one commenter put it: "If you wouldn't normally gift her something as expensive as a cake, then don't gift her the cake."
Newsweek reached out to silweddingcake via Reddit for comment. We were not able to verify the details of this case.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines