10
Loading video...
By Ellie Cook
Senior Defense Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
The Pentagon has altered how it tallies U.S. service members killed and injured in the Middle East, intensifying scrutiny over the Department of Defense's handling of communications regarding casualties in the ongoing conflict with Iran.
The Defense Casualty Analysis System (DCAS), which the Pentagon states is "regularly" updated with the latest statistics on wounded and slain American personnel, sets the official death toll in the Middle East since February when the Iran war began at 18, with 624 others sustaining injuries of varying severity.
However, the database now divides casualties from the war into two distinct categories: those recorded during months of fighting between February and June, and those killed or injured since July 7. That date coincides with the breakdown of a ceasefire announced by President Donald Trump in June, after which the U.S. resumed airstrikes against Iran following Tehran's targeting of several merchant vessels off the coast of Oman, triggering nearly two weeks of consecutive nighttime attacks.
Read More on World
The Pentagon, meanwhile, has said the "errors" on the DCAS were down to "temporary data disruption."
Related Story
Videos Show US and Iran’s Strikes As Ceasefire Collapses: ‘Retribution’
The administration faces mounting scrutiny over the conflict, pressured by Iran's continued control of the vital Strait of Hormuz, rising fuel prices, and accusations that Washington lacks a coherent strategy to exit the war.
Some lawmakers and observers argue the database modification is an attempt to circumvent the need for congressional approval to continue military operations and minimize the perceived toll on U.S. forces in the region.
Last month, Congress voted to limit Trump's war-making authority regarding Iran—marking a shift as Republicans formerly aligned with the White House increasingly broke with the administration over the conflict. While largely symbolic and non-binding, the Senate vote indicated that political appetite for the months-long war is fading even among the president's staunchest supporters.
Newsweek has reached out to the Pentagon for comment via email.
Related Story
Five Republicans Rebel Against Trump’s Iran War as Conflict Explodes: List
Former Pentagon official Jim Townsend told Newsweek that the administration is "playing games" by dividing the casualty counts.
The database adjustment effectively treats the three weeks following the collapse of the ceasefire as a new conflict rather than a continuation of the war, originally codenamed Operation Epic Fury, launched by the U.S. and Israel on February 28. The newly added category in the Pentagon's official records is marked as "Overseas Operations," separating the July fighting from earlier operations that resulted in 14 U.S. deaths and 417 injuries.
Iranian attacks since July 7 have largely targeted U.S. military bases in the region, including a strike on an installation in Jordan that killed three U.S. service members. Another U.S. soldier was killed at a base in Iraq during what the Pentagon described as the "controlled detonation" of a drone.
Those four fatalities now appear under the "Overseas Operations" casualty count. The fallen service members were identified as 1st Lieutenant Tyler James Feehan, Private Isabella Gonzales, Sergeant Angel Rampersad, and Sergeant Michael Emmanuel Swinton. Another 207 personnel have been wounded in action in the Middle East since July 7.
Related Story
The Faces of US Service Members Killed in Iran War
...
What's Behind the Change?
Representative Thomas Massie, one of the few Republicans who has condemned the war, criticized the creation of the new casualty category as an "absurd ruse."
"The Pentagon is pretending there have been two Iran wars separated by a brief cease-fire," he wrote on X on Thursday, accusing Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth of breaking the law by not seeking sign-off for the war from Congress.
Under U.S. law, the president is required to halt military operations within 60 days unless Congress approves an extension. When the 60-day limit approached at the beginning of May, Trump argued that the conflict with Iran had been "terminated." The application of the 1973 War Powers Act has long been a subject of intense debate among legal experts and lawmakers.
On Thursday, The New York Times reported the Pentagon had changed the number of casualties listed on the public records from 18 to 14. Three military officials, who described sensitive internal discussions on the condition of anonymity,
told the newspaper the decision was made in part because the four servicemembers killed in July lost their lives after a ceasefire deal was announced in April.
"These site anomalies are currently being resolved in coordination with the Military Services. The Department attempted to explain the anomalies to the New York Times ahead of publication, but given their lack of knowledge in this area, they proceeded to write a non-story that will be fixed imminently. We remain committed to ensuring the utmost accuracy of all casualty reporting," acting Pentagon press secretary Joel Valdez said in a statement.
Contact Newsweek editors for this story: John Fitzpatrick and Anthony Murray.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines