Kayleigh Bush, who was crowned Miss North Florida in September 2024, says she was stripped of her title after refusing to sign a revised contract from Miss America. (Photo from Liberty Counsel)

...

Khaleda Rahman

By Khaleda Rahman

National Correspondent

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


Miss America has denied a beauty pageant winner's claim that she lost her crown after she refused to sign a contract with the organization that she says was against her beliefs.

Kayleigh Bush was crowned Miss North Florida in September 2024. She told TMZ that she was stripped of her title after refusing to sign a revised contract from the organization.

"I was unwilling to agree that little boys can become girls and I took a stand against the Miss America organization and lost my crown as a result of that," she told the outlet in an interview published on Wednesday.

Read More on News

A spokesperson for Miss America denied Bush’s claim, telling Newsweek that Bush retained her crown, title and scholarships. The spokesperson also said that the contract did not require Bush to "accept any particular position regarding those permitted to compete" but "merely to agree that she, herself, would follow the rules and regulations."

The spokesperson added that Bush "did not lose the opportunity to advance in the competition because of the inclusion of language addressing eligibility."

Newsweek has contacted Bush for comment via Liberty Counsel, a conservative legal organization.

Kayleigh Bush, who was crowned Miss North Florida in September 2024, refused to sign a contract that she said was against her beliefs.

...

Why It Matters

The dispute highlights ongoing tensions in pageant organizations over eligibility standards and nondiscrimination rules.

According to Miss America’s updated rules, contestants must be "a female," aged 18 to 28, unmarried, with no children and a citizen of the United States. The rules state that a "female" includes "a born female or an individual who has fully completed Sex Reassignment Surgery."

What To Know

Bush told TMZ that she took a stand after Miss America changed the rules after she won the Miss North Florida title.

"I was asked to sign a contract that was different than the first one that I had agreed to, because they had changed it four weeks after I rightly won," she said. "And so I didn’t lose my crown because I broke a rule, I lost the crown because I was unwilling to rewrite the truth."

She said she and her mother had immediately raised their concerns about the new contract.

"We got on a conference call immediately with one of the directors for the Miss America organization," she said. "And weeks and weeks and weeks of pleading with them, sending videos, sending letters, emails, demand letters through Liberty Counsel because they picked up my case and they just said ‘no, no, no,’ and they doubled down."

The Miss America spokesperson told Newsweek that to move forward, Bush was required to sign a contract that every contestant has signed since February 2023.

The spokesperson said Bush "sought to modify the standard contestant agreement in a manner that would exclude certain individuals who otherwise meet the organization's eligibility criteria," adding that the organization "does not negotiate indidualized terms."

The spokesperson said the eligibility language is "narrowly tailored" to recognize that "in extremely rare medical circumstances, individuals may be born with XX chromosomes, yet present with certain biological variations." They added that the policy "ensures that women who meet the organization's scientific and legal standards of eligibility are not excluded on the basis of such medical conditions."

Conservatives on social media rallied behind Bush, including former collegiate swimmer and conservative activist Riley Gaines.

What People Are Saying

Kayleigh Bush told TMZ: "It was disappointing because Miss America has been honoring women for over 100 years and now they can’t even define what a woman is."

A spokesperson for Miss America said in a statement to Newsweek: "Ms. Bush was awarded Ms. North Florida in 2024, for the January, 2025 competition. She retained her crown. She retained her sash. She retained her title. She retained her scholarships. None of that was forfeited."

The statement added: "Miss America's position is grounded in uniform application of its rules, fairness to all contestants and adherence to nondiscrimination principles. The contract does not compel Ms. Bush to compromise her personal beliefs; it requires only that all contestants compete under the same standards and refrain from discriminatory conduct towards others."

Liz Doyle, the founder and executive director of She Leads America, wrote on Facebook on Wednesday: "Last year, She Leads America crowned Kayleigh Bush as Miss She Leads America and honored her as our 2025 Young Christian Woman of Distinction. This week, she joined us in Washington, D.C. for the She Leads the Nations Summit—and we had the job of celebrating her 20th birthday together.

"After lunch, Kayleigh toured the Capitol. As she exited, she was unexpectedly approached by TMZ reporters. With grace, confidence, and clarity, she shared her perspective — representing her faith and convictions with poise well beyond her years."

The conservative Libs of TikTok account shared Bush’s interview with TMZ on X, adding: "MEN CANNOT BE WOMEN."

Conservative influencer Gunther Eagleman wrote on X: "I guess @MissAmerica wants to go the way of yesterday. Have fun going BANKRUPT."

Correction 2/13/26, 12:10 p.m. ET: This article and its headline have been updated to reflect Miss America's position that Kayleigh Bush did not lose her crown or benefits.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines