0.cached.png

0.cached.png

David A. Kaplan

By David A. Kaplan

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


To law-enforcement officials, it is an H-bomb in the war on drugs. To civil libertarians, it's an outrageous abuse of police power. To Gary and Kathy Bergman, who stand to lose a $100,000 home over the indiscretions of a fishing buddy, an obscure provision of federal law known as "civil forfeiture" is just plain government thievery. The one thing everyone agrees on is that it makes crime pay-for the government.

The Bergmans' nightmare began this past summer, when Perry Swenson visited their lakefront home in South Dakota for walleye season; he arrived with 39 marijuana seedlings. The Bergmans, who were casual pot smokers themselves, figured it was no big deal. Big mistake. On his way home Swenson was stopped at a game check and his plants were discovered. Swenson told the authorities that he grew the marijuana himself, but they nonetheless checked out the Bergman home. After a three-hour search, they allegedly found a trace of pot as well as a marijuana butt in a car outside belonging to the Bergmans' daughter.

That was enough for the Feds to seize the whole house as the presumed tainted property of a drug ring-even though neither Bergman was charged with a federal crime. (Gary pleaded no contest to a state misdemeanor charge of possession.) The government's not-so-secret weapon? Forfeiture laws. The Bergmans continue to live there under an "occupancy" agreement; their front and back doors are adorned with NO TRESPASSING BY ORDER OF U.S. MARSHAL signs. "This is a license to steal my property," says Kathy. "If you're a hit-and-run driver, they don't even take away the vehicle you used to kill somebody." Maybe officials assumed this fancy home could only have been built with drug money. Maybe they didn't know the Bergmans financed it with insurance proceeds Gary received from an injury he sustained as an ironworker in California. The government isn't saying. "I can't make any public statements," says U.S. Attorney Kevin Schieffer.

Read More on News

On paper, forfeiture programs make sense as a dramatic way for both the federal and state prosecutors to show they mean business. Forfeiture goes beyond a jail sentence for the miscreants involved. It takes the profit out of crime by seizing any property remotely associated with alleged criminal activity. Then the loot can be sold off and applied to fight the drug war. Since 1985, the federal government has harvested $2.6 billion this way; it made 35,295 seizures in 1991, up 18 times in six years. It has confiscated planes, boats, a Mr. Coffee and even a pair of baby shoes belonging to a man accused of impersonating a psychiatrist. "Because forfeiture law views inanimate objects as sentient creatures capable of being bad actors," writes Terrance Reed in a report by the Cato Institute, "the constitutional protections normally afforded the property's owner are not available." In fact, only about one half of all people who forfeit property are charged with a crime.

As a result, the device has increasingly prompted cries of abuse that go beyond the reflexive carping of the criminal-defense bar. Most forfeiture victims aren't exactly model citizens, but the penalty they suffer often far exceeds the alleged misdeed. Under a New Jersey forfeiture law, Jacqueline Savarino lost her '87 Oldsmobile because police said her son drove it to a local Sears, where he allegedly shoplifted a pair of pants and ran into a security guard. (The son is contesting the charges.) In another case, Kathy Schrama, who says she suffers from kleptomania and steals UPS packages from neighbors' doorsteps, saw authorities take away her home, two cars and a van full of furniture. (She eventually pleaded guilty to theft and agreed to pay $5,000; she has recovered many of her possessions, but is suing authorities for $75 million.) Forfeiture laws "set every principle of justice on its head," says Eric Sterling, president of the Criminal Justice Policy Foundation.

In recent months, judges, legislators and citizens' groups have all called for reform and some congressional action appears certain in the next session. The U.S. Supreme Court is expected to rule by June on the reach of federal forfeiture provisions; several lower courts have already expressed their disgust with the laws. In the high-court appeal, the Bush administration argues that it can seize the home of an innocent person-if she bought it with money that was a gift from her boyfriend, an alleged drug dealer. The bizarre nature of the case is reflected in its name: U.S. v. 92 Buena Vista Ave.

Forfeiture laws have existed in this country since the 1700s, when they were used against pirates and smugglers. Yet it was not until the mid-1980s that the federal government expanded them. The Justice Department realized that the big tunas in the drug trade, if they weren't getting away entirely, were just seeing time in the pokey as a way of doing business. So the government figured: go after the money. "If we are successful," says Robert Bonner, head of the Drug Enforcement Administration, "the drug-trafficking organizations will wither and die." Unlike criminal-forfeiture laws, the new civil sanctions permitted seizure without a conviction or even a charge. The laws are invoked most prominently in drug cases, but also where racketeering, obscenity and money laundering are suspected.

State and local law-enforcement agencies, too, have forfeiture programs. And they get to share in the federal take. That can disturb the normal relationship between state and federal agents. In those few states where the law is harsher than U.S. statutes, officials may not want to work with the Feds for fear the Feds will get some of the seized property. But where state law is not as tough, the local officials may seek U.S. intervention where it otherwise would not be called for. A federal court in New Orleans has labeled such decisions "a scam or a shell game."

While most forfeiture booty is sold, some is kept by law-enforcement agencies-and it is the occasional resulting corruption for which critics reserve their harshest fire. In theory the contraband can be of use to the agencies, but this hardly seems to justify the New Jersey prosecutor who tooled around in a seized yellow Corvette or the Denver police who've appropriated the weight-lifting equipment from a healthclub bust. Forfeiture laws can create fiscal incentives that distort law enforcement. Florida drug agents working the I-95 cocaine corridor reportedly try to stop suspected drug buyers on their way south, while they still have forfeitable cash; on the northern route, the crooks simply have drugs, which are worthless to the narcs. Cary Copeland, director of the Justice Department's Office for Asset Forfeiture, acknowledges problems, but lauds the program as a revenue raiser. "This is the goose that lays the golden egg."

That is why the law-enforcement lobby will fight any reform efforts. Advocates of civil forfeiture like to point out that 80 percent of those who have property taken don't contest the seizures. "In the bulk of our cases, the circumstances are so incriminating that nobody wants to challenge us," Copeland says. "With all that crime out there, we don't have to run around and take property from innocent people." Gary and Kathy Bergman think otherwise.

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines