Sealed tapeed box

DenisProduction.com/Sealed tapeed box

Jennifer Bryant

By Jennifer Bryant

Vice President, Business Consulting Services, Unify Consulting

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


As leaders grow in their careers, they accumulate both breadth and depth of experience. People see them moving up the ladder and think "Oh... They must have done a lot of things!" "They must know the secret to success." They go to them for help, for answers, for advice, as a sounding board, etc. And many leaders are only too happy to oblige. The term "servant leader" has been glorified and is often incorrectly applied. We use this label incorrectly when referring to a leader who is willing to jump in and "get in the trenches" with their people. A direct report will come to them with a big, hairy problem and they come to the rescue to save them from sure destruction!

When Servant Leadership Becomes a Disservice

If you dig into the true definition of servant leadership, it is serving your team over managing for results to create an environment where people are empowered to grow and create value. Under the guise of service, many leaders instead become fixers who are actively hindering the growth of their people. The cycle perpetuates with team members becoming increasingly dependent on them for help and decision-making. The leader is then spending more time "fixing" and firefighting than focusing on high-value work. Harvard Business Review reports that over 50% of managers feel burned out. The "fixer" approach is unsustainable and in conflicting interests with both the leader and the team.

Read More on Experts

I know this cycle far too well. This was me! When I took on a new role, leading a team of directors, I fell into the role of a fixer, feeling a deep responsibility to support my team very directly. My team was stagnating as a result and I was getting burned from all of that firefighting. Fortunately, I stumbled across an amazing piece of thought leadership, "The Advice Trap" by Michael Bungay-Stanier, that opened my eyes to how I was failing (failing!) my team.

Why Advice Has Its Downsides

Giving advice to advice seekers in these scenarios, Bungay-Stanier posits does not work. You are often solving the wrong problem or giving a mediocre solution that is based on your experience and not the unique experience of the individual who is in the midst of the problem. The author further says that giving advice can demotivate the recipients of said advice, overwhelm the givers of said advice, and compromise the effectiveness and resilience of the team and organization.

How I Escaped the Advice Trap

Having been enlightened to the Advice Trap and desiring to make a change, I set on my own journey to shift my leadership approach from reactively giving advice and answers to coaching to success. Here are a few simple changes I put in place to break my own fixer cycle.

Take a breath. When looking to shake up an unhealthy cycle, the first step is to recognize your trigger. In this case, this typically looks like receiving a call for help and feeling an immediate desire to respond. Pause. When a team member comes to you in crisis, it can be natural to mirror their energy. Instead, take a moment. Truly, take a deep breath to create some space for you to swallow your advice and for them to have a moment of reflection on what they have shared.

Lead with curiosity. "You can tell whether a man is clever by his answers. You can tell whether a man is wise by his questions." —Naguib Mahfouz. Your team member may be looking for an answer but the best way you can serve them as their leader is to ask open-ended questions. Ask them broad questions around the "why" and the "how" and coach them toward their own solution. Remember, above all to NOT lead the witness by asking leading questions vs. curious questions.

Don't miss the debrief. You have sent your team member marching to solve the big hairy problem on their own. You may both be feeling vulnerable about this. You must accept that sometimes they will succeed and sometimes they will not. Regardless, it is important that you give them the space to stretch, learn, and grow. Furthermore, you want to follow up to hold them accountable for facing the issue head-on and to support them. The debrief is such an oft-missed opportunity! This is when you take the time to acknowledge their impact and build them up or to learn from what didn't work well.

I have found that by shifting my approach from giving advice to coaching to solutions, my team has become imminently more:

I would be remiss not to acknowledge that there are certainly times when getting directly involved as a leader to support your team member is the right call. Your team does need to see that you are willing to do the things that you ask of them and that you have their back. There is a delicate balance to strike, but I truly believe that the best way to serve our people as leaders is to take a step back in order to empower them to overcome their challenges and then pass that forward to their own people, creating not only a collaborative and accountable team, but a true culture of resilience.

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines