
...

By Brenée Goforth Swanzy
The John Locke Foundation
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
A recent Harris poll for The Guardian made waves—even trending on X (formerly Twitter)—for reporting that 56 percent of Americans believe the United States is currently in a recession. A recession is often defined as two consecutive quarters of declining Gross Domestic Product (GDP); however, the U.S. has experienced a consistently growing GDP for at least a year and a half now. The question on everyone's minds was, "If this isn't true, why do so many Americans believe it?"
The answer is, among other things, that Americans are struggling financially, they saw the government and media's recession denialism following the pandemic, and "recession" has taken on a colloquial meaning separate from its economic definition.
If you asked folks on the street what a recession is, I'm doubtful that the majority would respond, "a period of temporary economic decline during which trade and industrial activity are reduced, generally identified by a fall in GDP in two successive quarters." Most of them would likely say something along the lines of "when times get hard," or "when the economy gets worse."
Read More
Step Aside, GDP. It’s Time for LIF (Lifestyle Improvement Factor) | Opinion7 min read

It’s Time To Confront Our Exploding National Debt | Opinion4 min read

Earth to Big Oil: China and the U.S. Inhabit the Same Warming Planet | Opinion5 min read

The question then is, "gets worse, compared to when?"

...
Americans' mental timelines are separated into two eras: pre-pandemic and post-pandemic. We compare our lives before the COVID-19 outbreak to our lives after. The reality is that grocery prices are higher, gas prices are higher, energy bills are higher, and rent is more expensive than before the pandemic. Interest rates are still up, buying a used car is far more expensive post-pandemic, and, if you can save up enough for a vacation, that plane ticket is going to cost you substantially more than before the pandemic. Life is less affordable post-pandemic, and while wage growth has recently outpaced inflation, for most Americans, that wage growth has not kept up with the cumulative increase in prices for household expenses.
One of the questions included in the poll was whether people think inflation is increasing or decreasing, and nearly three-fourths of respondents believed it was increasing. Many readers took this result to mean Americans are uneducated about inflation, but this is not a fair conclusion.
When you ask people if they think inflation is increasing or decreasing, they likely don't think you're asking if the rate of inflation is increasing or decreasing. They probably think you are asking whether prices are going up or down. People continue to see their grocery bills creep up, and so they are going to say inflation is increasing. While the rate of inflation is lower than its peak of 9.1 percent, a lower inflation rate does not equate to lower prices. The rate of inflation is how fast prices are rising or falling, not a straightforward measure of how much.
To be clear, prices are definitively increasing—higher than the generally looked for "healthy" 2 percent rate of inflation—just not as fast as they were earlier. Because inflation is cumulative, this month builds on top of inflation from last month. People don't care if the price of an item only went up three cents this month because that adds to the four cents it went up last month. All they care about is that the price of that item used to be a dollar, but now it's not. It's more expensive.
Some people blamed American's responses to this poll on the media for not covering the improvements in the economy enough. I do believe the media is part of the problem here, but I don't believe it is that they don't report on increasing GDP enough. The media lost a lot of trust over the pandemic, and they were giving airtime to a wide array of administration officials who lied about the economy. When the government released data in May 2022 showing six months of shrinking GDP, NBC's "Meet the Press" had Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen on the show. There, Yellen infamously stated, "This is not an economy that's in recession, but we're in a period of transition in which growth is slowing."
This led countless commentators to accuse the media and the administration of redefining "recession." Recently, Biden was under fire for repeating the lie that inflation "was at 9%" when he took office when it was really 1.4 percent. The administration's crying wolf (or crying "strongest economy in history") has led the public to distrust any good news about the economy—especially when their lived experience is tighter budgets and paychecks that don't go as far as they used to.
Until people start to feel meaningful relief from the financial stress of the pandemic and rapid inflation, they are going to feel pessimistic about our economy. The cost of living is their primary concern, so reducing those costs is what is going to make the most difference. This can be accomplished by reducing burdensome regulations that restrict the housing supply, focusing on reliable, low-emission, low-cost energy, and lowering taxes to keep more money in Americans' wallets.
Brenée Goforth Swanzy works at the John Locke Foundation, a free-market think tank based in Raleigh, North Carolina.
The views expressed in this article are the writer's own.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines