10
Loading video...

By Giulia Carbonaro
Senior Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
With the victory of leftist former president Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva—known as Lula—in Sunday's election, Brazil is turning its back on four years of Bolsonaro's policies, which have had a devastating impact on the country's democratic institutions as well as the Amazon rainforest and the indigenous communities living within it.
Under 67-year-old Lula, a veteran of Brazil's politics, environmental and climate activists hope that the country will be able to put an end to the Amazon's deforestation and bring Brazil back on track to fight the climate crisis.
Lula has a promising track record of fighting deforestation during his first time in office between 2003 and 2010, and he has pledged to crack down on illegal mining and logging as well as trying to revive the Amazon Fund, a key project supporting the protection of the rainforest which had been shelved during Bolsonaro's presidency.
Read More
Steve Bannon Says Bolsonaro Can’t Concede As He Rails Against Biden and CIA3 min read

Trump Again Urges Brazil to Back Bolsonaro as Lula Holds Slim Polling Lead3 min read

When Will the World As We Know It End From Climate Change?5 min read


...
"The damage of Bolsonaro's Presidency is expansive—but it is not necessarily set in stone. Quick, wide-ranging action to slow rates of deforestation and return restore lands could help reverse this damage," Ed Atkins, environmental and energy policy specialist at the University of Bristol Cabot Institute for the Environment, told Newsweek.
A recent analysis by researchers at the University of Oxford, the International Institute for Applied System Analysis (IIASA) and the National Institute for Space Research (INPE) found that deforestation could fall by 89 percent by 2030 under Lula if the president reinstates the policies introduced during his first term in office, saving 28,957 square miles of the Amazon rainforest.
A 'Vote for the Amazon': What Is Lula Likely to Do for the Rainforest?
"We are lucky with Lula: We can gauge what he might do now from his track record," said Atkins.
"Lula's government has argued that it was his previous spell as president that saw a dramatic drop in deforestation in Brazil. Such a drop, of close to 80 percent compared to previous rates, is one of the primary drivers of Brazil's reputation as a leader in climate action. A reputation that Bolsonaro has trashed.
"Lula's campaign has pledged to repeat these achievements—enforcing the Forest code, tackling illegal deforestation, and investing in reforestation. If these pledges are kept, Lula's election will hopefully lead to a downward spiral for deforestation rates."
The Forest Code—neglected by Bolsonaro during his years in office—is a legislation that requires landowners to set aside and protect a certain proportion of forest and restore land that may have previously been deforested.
Rodrigo Medeiros, senior Brazil associate at NGO Re:wild, told Newsweek that Lula's victory "is certainly the best news that all of us who love and care about the Amazon and the planet could receive."
"President Lula promised that the government will immediately resume the monitoring and surveillance of the Amazon and combat any and all illegal activity, whether mining, logging or land-grabbing for cattle and cattle feed agriculture in the Amazon," Medeiros said.
"Lula was also emphatic in saying that he will promote the sustainable development of communities living in the Amazon region, proving once again that it is possible to generate wealth without destroying nature. We also expect that the new administration will work with individuals and organizations interested in seeing the Amazon protected, both for the planet and for those who live and depend on it to survive."
But while Atkins is also positive that a Lula government will lead to "a dramatic drop in deforestation," he thinks we should still look at the newly elected president with a critical eye.
"Whilst many have cast this election as a 'vote for the Amazon,' Lula's election is not necessarily the silver bullet that everybody might think it is," Atkins said.
"Whilst the governments of Lula and his successor Dilma Rousseff did reduce deforestation, they also enacted policies that damaged the environment: building mega-dams, expanding oil extraction, and supporting the expansion of the beef industry. All with environmental impacts."
Following up on all his campaign pledges might also be a struggle for Lula, as Brazil is in a much more difficult situation now than it was during the time he was first in power.
"Upon taking office, Lula faces numerous challenges and policy priorities. From expanding education to tackling dramatic inequality, there always remains a possibility that environmental action falls down the list of priorities," said Atkins.
"This cannot be allowed to happen. Campaigners and observers must hold Lula to his promises—and the global community must support him in fulfilling them."
Amazon Fund to Be Restored After Being Shelved by Bolsonaro
In 2008, the Amazon Fund was set up to help finance the protection of the Amazon rainforest and its biodiversity, with Norway as its biggest donor. Between 2008 and 2018, the Scandinavian country paid $1.2 billion into the fund, while Germany, another big donor, donated more than $68 million.
The fund was deemed as successful—until many countries including Norway and Germany stopped contributing in 2019 in protest of the surging deforestation in the rainforest. The project was then unilaterally halted by Bolsonaro, who said the fund had been suspended while he reviewed its governance structure.
Since then, there have been steps toward reviving the deal. On October 27, a majority of justices within Brazil's Supreme Court—seven out of 11—decided to demand the reactivation of the Amazon Fund within 60 days.
A final ruling on the case is expected on November 3, Reuters reported.
During his campaign, Lula said that he is open to working with other countries to increase the protection of Amazon, including by reviving of the Amazon Fund.
"The revival of this fund would allow other countries to donate and collaborate with Lula's Brazil on the protection of the Amazon. Norway has already stated that it would be happy to do so," Atkins said.
"Once revived, the Amazon Fund can provide a powerful tool for reversing the damage Bolsonaro has done to Brazil—and the ecosystems and biomes across it."
How Much of the Amazon Rainforest Was Destroyed Under Bolsonaro
During Jair Bolsonaro's presidency, his policies on deforestation and illegal logging have led to the loss of tens of thousands of square miles of Amazon rainforest.
"Since his election, Jair Bolsonaro and his government consistently sought to weaken environmental laws and protections and weaken the agencies that monitor and police deforestation," Atkins said.
"They have also, through their words and policies, legitimized environmental crimes. This has included government policies to legalize illegally occupied land and weaken the protection of Indigenous lands. This was part of a concerted policy to 'run the cattle' through Brazilian environmental protection to open lands for mining and agriculture."
According to data from Brazil's National Institute for Space Research (INPE), almost 16,000 square miles have been cleared out under Bolsonaro's presidency in the past four years.
"In the past four years, deforestation in the region increased by 70 percent. And to give you an idea of how big this is, every year we are losing an area of the Amazon rainforest that's the size of more than one million football pitches," Erika Berenguer, Senior Research Associate at the Ecosystems Lab in the University of Oxford, told Newsweek.
Wildfires, which have raised international concern and criticism in recent years, have burned 27,973 square miles of the rainforest in 2019, and 29,884 in 2020.
In 2021, deforestation in the Amazon reached a 15-year high under Bolsonaro, as devastating wildfires burned an estimated million hectares of rainforest and the former president refused millions in aid from the G7 countries claiming this would lead with them interfering with Brazil's sovereignty.
Thousands of fires occur in the region every year—and yet their numbers increased during Bolsonaro's presidency.
"Bolsonaro's presidency threw considerable support behind the Brazilian agribusiness sector. This emboldened many to set fires to burn the Amazon and use the land left behind for cattle or soy farming. The election of Bolsonaro gave space for many landowners, ranchers, and illegal, wildcat miners in the Brazilian Amazon region to expand operations, using fire to clear land for use or speculation," said Atkins.
Two billion trees—equal to 1,536 square miles of the Amazon, an area five times the size of New York City—have been either burned or cut down during the first six months of 2022 alone, according to INPE. It's the highest figure in at least six years—showing that while the process of deforestation had come to a significant halt in the years leading to Bolsonaro's presidency, it picked up again after the right-wing leader took power.
It is estimated that, in total, some 17 to 20 percent of the Amazon has been destroyed in the past fifty years. Taking action to stop this process is urgent, as the Amazon plays a crucial role in the climate regulation of our planet, producing between six and nine percent of the world's total oxygen and acting like a massive carbon sink for our global emissions.
"In the long term, this affects climate change, putting a lot of greenhouse gases in the atmosphere, and changing rainfall patterns across Brazil," said Berenguer. But it also affects Amazonian people. So it's a very serious impact that Bolsonaro had directly and indirectly in the Amazon."
The Amazon is expected to reach its tipping point—the moment when it's not able to generate enough moisture to keep itself functioning as a rainforest—when 20 percent of the Amazon is deforested.
"We don't know if that tipping point could be brought forward by climate change, and therefore we don't know what the percentage is," said Berenguer. "The more deforestation we have, the faster we are running through this dark tunnel towards this tipping point."
In his victory speech, Lula pledged to fight "for zero deforestation."
Update, 11/1/2022 5:15 a.m. ET: This article was updated to include comments from experts Erika Berenguer and Rodrigo Medeiros.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines