Healthcare and medical concept. Medicine doctor with stethoscope in hand and Patients come to the hospital background.

...

Lawrence Rosenberg, MD, CM, MSc, PhD, MEng, FRCPSC, FACS, FCAHS

By Lawrence Rosenberg, MD, CM, MSc, PhD, MEng, FRCPSC, FACS, FCAHS

President & CEO, Integrated Health & Social Services University Network for West-Central Montreal

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


Over the first two articles in this series, we have reframed how health care systems behave. They are not machines to be optimized, but complex adaptive systems that evolve through countless interactions. When they are tightly controlled and overly standardized, they do not become more stable; they become fragile – drifting toward the kind of critical state where small disruptions can trigger system-wide crises.

If that is true, and the evidence increasingly suggests that it is, then a more uncomfortable question follows: Why, after decades of reform, do the same problems persist? Why do costs continue to rise, outcomes remain uneven and systems operate under constant strain, even as they are reorganized, digitized and consolidated?

The answer lies in something both simple and often overlooked: how the system is rewarded for behaving. In health care, every decision is shaped by signals that tell clinicians and organizations what matters, like what to do, when to do it and how often. These signals are often described as “incentives,” but at their core, they are simply the rules of the game and the way the system defines success in practice. And right now, in many systems, those rules quietly reward activity over outcomes, volume over value and short-term intervention over long-term health.

Read More on Community Forum

What those rules reward today is not difficult to see. In many health care systems, activity is still the primary currency. The more tests are ordered, the more procedures performed and the more visits scheduled, the more the system pays. This model – often referred to as fee-for-service – was designed to expand access and ensure that care was delivered. Over time, however, it has created a powerful and largely invisible distortion that rewards doing more, not necessarily achieving better outcomes.

The consequences are not abstract. Consider a patient with a chronic condition such as diabetes. Under an activity-based model, care becomes a series of disconnected encounters – appointments, tests, prescriptions – each compensated individually. Yet no single part of that process is directly accountable for whether the patient’s health actually improves over time. The system can be highly active, even technically excellent at each step, and still fails to deliver better outcomes. In fact, fragmentation, duplication and even unnecessary interventions can quietly increase because they are not penalized, and, in many cases, rewarded*.*

This is the central paradox of building a successful health care system: A system organized around activity can appear productive while becoming increasingly inefficient and misaligned with its ultimate purpose. It is not that clinicians are making the wrong decisions; it is that the environment in which they operate is continuously nudging those decisions in a particular direction. When the rules of the game reward volume, volume is what the system produces – even when the real goal is better health over time.

If the problem lies in the rules of the game, then the path forward becomes clearer. Change the rules and the system begins to behave differently; This is the main idea behind value-based care. Despite the name, it is often misunderstood as a payment reform or a cost-control strategy, but it is neither. At its core, value-based care is about aligning the system around a simple question: Are patients actually getting better, and staying better, over time?

In practical terms, this means shifting from paying for individual activities to taking responsibility for outcomes across the full continuum of care. Instead of rewarding each test, visit or procedure in isolation, the system begins to look at the results of care as a whole across time, across settings and across providers. What matters is not what happens during a single hospital stay or clinic visit, but what happens to the patient over time – whether their condition improves, whether complications are avoided, whether care is coordinated and whether they are able to return to a functional and meaningful life.

This shift from episodes to trajectories is fundamental. It connects parts of the system that were previously treated as separate and it makes visible what was previously hidden: how decisions made in one part of the system affect outcomes elsewhere. Care is no longer a series of isolated interventions. It becomes a continuous process with shared responsibility for results.

When the focus shifts in this way, behavior begins to change. Teams that once operated independently start to coordinate more closely, because outcomes now depend on how well the entire process works together. Unnecessary variation becomes visible, not because it violates a rule, but because it produces inconsistent results. Clinicians and organizations begin to ask different questions: Not “What more can we do?” but “What actually works best for patients, over time?”

Some health systems have demonstrated what this can look like in practice. Geisinger Health in Pennsylvania, for example, pioneered outcome-linked care models in which teams became accountable for patient results across the full episode of care, not just the individual encounter. By systematically tracking what happened to patients after discharge and feeding that information back into clinical decision-making, Geisinger was able to reduce complications, lower readmission rates and improve long-term outcomes in ways that activity-based models had not incentivized.

The key was not stricter control, but better information aligned with the right goals. Care became more consistent where it should be, more adaptable where it needed to be and steadily more effective overall; not through top-down mandate, but through the accumulation of local learning that spread across the system.

What begins to emerge from this shift is something more than better coordination; It is the foundation of a different kind of system. When outcomes are measured across the full continuum of care and fed back into decision-making, the system starts to learn. Clinicians and organizations are no longer operating in isolation; they are part of a continuous process of adjustment, where results inform future choices. Over time, this creates a loop: action leads to outcomes, outcomes generate insight and insight reshapes action.

This continuous learning is what allows a system to move beyond resilience. Fragile systems break under stress, resilient systems withstand stress and return to where they were, but learning systems can do something more: They use stress as information about what needs to change.

This is where the concept of antifragility becomes important. Antifragile systems do not simply survive variability and pressure; they improve because of it. They treat differences in outcomes, unexpected events and even small failures as signals that reveal where improvement is possible. Over time, this makes the system not only more stable but also more capable.

Value-based care creates the conditions for this kind of behavior. When the system is rewarded for outcomes rather than activity, variation goes from something to suppress to something to understand. Differences in results are signals that point to better or worse approaches. When those signals are captured, shared and acted upon, the system begins to evolve. What works spreads, what does not work is gradually abandoned and improvement is no longer episodic or externally imposed; it becomes continuous and internally driven.

This is why value-based care is so often misunderstood. It is not simply a different way of paying for care or a cost-control mechanism or an administrative reform, but rather the operating system that allows a complex health care system to learn, adapt and improve continuously over time without requiring external intervention to drive each cycle of change. No other reform currently on offer does this. It aligns millions of individual decisions from clinicians, patients and organizations around a common objective: better outcomes across the full trajectory of care.

But even with the right structure and the right signals, systems do not change on their own. They change through the actions of people. Clinicians must interpret and act on new information, patients must be engaged in their own care over time and organizations must be willing to adapt and learn.

In the end, health care is not transformed by design alone. It is transformed by agency and by the capacity of individuals to act, decide and participate meaningfully within the system. Understanding how that agency shapes outcomes, equity and sustainability is the next step in this story.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines