...
By Lydia Patrick
Life & Trends Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
A woman turned to internet users for fashion advice—and sparked a major debate—after asking whether a floor-length floral dress was appropriate to wear to a wedding.
Anna Baumeister (@burgerinyourbirkin) shared a video showcasing the gown, expressing her love for it while raising concerns over whether it might be "too white" for the occasion. The post, which garnered more than 950,000 views and over 48,600 likes, quickly became a flashpoint for differing opinions on wedding guest attire.
"I have a wedding in May. I'm OBSESSED with this dress but I can't tell if it's too white for a wedding," Baumeister wrote. The dress in question features a maxi A-line cut and a yellow floral design. While many TikTok users encouraged Baumeister to wear the "gorgeous" outfit, others urged caution.
Read More on Life
Etiquette experts weighed in on the debate with Newsweek, offering guidance for wedding guests walking the fine line between stylish and inappropriate.
Nick Leighton, host of the etiquette podcast Were You Raised by Wolves?, said that the No. 1 priority for any guest should be to celebrate the couple—not draw attention away from them.
"When in doubt, always err on the side of caution," Leighton said. "If you have to ask, 'Is this dress OK?' that can sometimes be your clue that it might not be."
Leighton added that it is especially important for plus-ones to check in with the person who invited them, particularly if they don't know the couple getting married. "It's a good idea to ask the invitee for guidance as to what wardrobe would be appropriate for the occasion," he said.
Still, in Baumeister's case, Leighton said he didn't think the dress crossed any lines.
"This particular dress is lovely, and I don't think anyone is going to confuse her for the bride," he said. "Assuming it's appropriate for the season, time of day, and formality of the event, I say, 'Go for it.'"
Australian etiquette expert Jo Hayes was even more emphatic in her response, saying she was amazed the dress had caused controversy.
...
Hayes told Newsweek: "It's the perfect guest dress. In fact, I'd say it's rather on the casual side for a wedding. Yes, it's floor-length, but it could not be classified a 'gown' in anyone's language. The cotton floaty-summery-dressy vibe, paired with the summer wedges, makes it's super-casual wedding outfit, and not at all on par with the formality of a wedding gown. The bride need not fear. No upstaging will be done here.
"Further, it's not anywhere near 'white', and it's an obvious floral print. Again, zero controversy here," Hayes added.
Hayes also said that the key to avoiding any outfit faux pas is a clear dress code from the couple. If one isn't provided, then she recommends leaning toward a more-polished look.
When guests are left guessing, Hayes said, it is better to dress up than down: "What's the worst thing that can happen? You'll be the best-dressed guest?"
Meanwhile, TikTok commenters were split. "Don't wear that to someone's wedding," wrote one user named Rachel.
"Ppl [people] have lost their minds, that's a yellow floral dress. Totally appropriate," commented another.
"My opinion is if you're questioning it don't wear it," posted Brooke.
Alyssa shared a cautionary tale: "I once wore a baby blue dress that was very obviously baby blue to a wedding. The photographer's editing style washed it out and made it basically white and I was mortified."
"Idk [I don't know] maybe because I'm normal but that looks nothing like a wedding dress LOL [laugh out loud]," wrote one commenter.
Another user added: "It's not too white but it is fairly bridal—my rule of thumb is if you are worried what the bride/people will think and ask if it's okay to wear to a wedding then don't wear it to the wedding."
Baumeister later shared an update on what she decided. She ultimately chose not to wear the dress, saying that she didn't know the bride and wasn't sure about her preferences.
While Baumeister said that the dress was more of a "light yellow beige" than white, she added that it could come off as bridal in certain lighting.
Newsweek reached out to @burgerinyourbirkin for comment via TikTok. We could not verify the details of the case.
Has a wedding come between your relationship with a loved one? Let us know via life@newsweek.com. We can ask experts for advice, and your story could be featured on Newsweek.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines