10
Loading video...

By Giulia Carbonaro
Senior Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
Donald Trump's idea to eliminate the federal income tax by creating an "all tariff policy" should he win the November election would likely further burden lower- and middle-income Americans, an expert told Newsweek, while favoring higher-income individuals.
The embattled former president and Republican presidential candidate reportedly floated the idea during a private meeting last week, sources told CNBC, which first reported on the story. Addressing Republican lawmakers at the Capitol Hill Club in Washington, D.C., on June 13, Trump talked about imposing an "all tariff policy" that would ultimately allow the country to eliminate the income tax entirely, while also suggesting using tariffs as leverage during negotiations with bad actors.
Assaf Harpaz, and assistant professor at the University of Georgia School of Law, told Newsweek that replacing the federal income tax with an "all tariff policy" as suggested by Trump is an idea that raises several practical and theoretical questions.
Read More on News

...
"In addition to the legislative task of overhauling the Internal Revenue Code, it is difficult to envision how tariffs could completely replace the revenue from federal income taxes," Harpaz told Newsweek.
"In 2023, the federal government collected over $2 trillion from individual income taxes, alone," he explained. "Moreover, foreign governments may levy punitive tariffs in response to the policy, and increased costs would presumably roll over to individual taxpayers."
That, for Harpaz, is the biggest issue.
"The policy, if implemented, is unlikely to benefit most Americans," he said. "The federal income tax is progressive by design, whereas an all-out tariff could create regressive outcomes—burdening lower and middle-income Americans while favoring higher-income individuals and corporations."
Newsweek contacted Trump's 2024 campaign for comment by email on Monday morning.
Others have spoken against the idea of eliminating the federal income tax in favor of a tariff. "Here's the thing: The income tax has its flaws. But, the bottom line is it raises ~$2.5 trillion per year in progressive fashion," wrote on X David Kamin, a professor at New York University School of Law.
"Broadly substituting tariffs for income tax is a sure way to hit hard low and middle income Americans and reward top," he continued, adding in another post that the idea is "so outlandish, it probably won't happen."
Trump has recently suggested tariffs as a solution to other problems, including migration. Earlier this month, during an event in Arizona, where immigration is a central issue for the swing state, the Republican candidate said that—should he return to the White House—he might impose tariffs on countries that do not curb the flow of undocumented migrants into the U.S., including China.
"We have tremendous economic power," he said. If reelected, he would "tariff the hell out of" a country not attempting to reduce migration.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines