
...

By Tom O'Connor
Deputy Editor, National Security and Foreign Policy
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
Just weeks after the Islamic Republic was rocked by protests that were then violently crushed, Iranians are steeling themselves against the prospect of U.S. military intervention.
The unrest at the start of the year demonstrated huge dissent against the government, but triggered a rigid crackdown by the government as violence erupted nationwide. More than 3,000 people were killed according to the official death toll while foreign monitors estimate it much higher, in the tens of thousands.
President Donald Trump threatened to intervene in mid-January, telling Iranian protesters that help was on the way. In the past week U.S. warships and fighter jets have moved into the Gulf.
Read More on News
But many in Iran fear that a major escalation, or break-out of a large-scale war, would compound the woes of a nation still reeling from the protest deaths and struggling economically.
Iran is also still suffering from last summer's 12-Day War with Israel, which was aided by the US. That conflict in June saw unprecedented US strikes on three of Iran's nuclear sites. Hundreds were reportedly killed throughout those dozen days.
Many expect another U.S. attack would go even further. Iranian officials have warned that even a limited operation would spark a full-scale war with little expectations that it would resolve the underlying issues behind the demonstrations, which were triggered by a plunging local currency.
"The Iranian people are unhappy with the country's economic conditions, but they do not see a U.S. military attack as a solution to this situation," says Ali Bagheri Dolatabadi, professor from Yasouj University in the Iranian capital Tehran.
"They believe that such an attack would turn Iran into a situation similar to Afghanistan, Iraq, Syria and Yemen.They want the government to listen to the protesters and find a solution to their economic problems. Their request is to resolve the challenges with the United States through negotiation and diplomacy.
"At the same time, they do not want their independence, sovereignty and pride to be harmed. In their view, Trump is behaving like a bully," he told Newsweek.
In fact, rather than hoping for new strikes, many Iranians feel a sense of betrayal from the U.S. leader, he said.
"They are waiting for Trump to change his behavior and return to the negotiating table," Prof Dolotabadi said. "In their view, Trump is a liar. He invited the youth to protest and left them alone despite promising to help. He is responsible for their deaths, and his military operations will not change anything."

...
‘No One Wants War’
As U.S. warships gather off Iran's coast—what Trump has described as an "armada"—battles have already broken out over the narrative of the situation inside Iran and whether U.S. intervention is justified.
Critics of Iran's government based abroad, led by Iranian diaspora and exiles, have championed the idea of direct U.S. intervention.
Among them is Reza Pahlavi, the son of Iran's last shah who was overthrown in the 1979 Islamic Revolution led by Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini. Khomeini led for a decade before being succeeded upon his death by Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, 86, the current supreme leader.
Khamenei wields absolute authority in Iran, and despite the 2024 election of President Masoud Pezeshkian on a successful reformist platform, hard-line principlists remain deeply influential in the country.
Pezeshkian promised economic improvement for Iranians, but challenges on this front have been exacerbated by intensified conflict with Israel amid the war in Gaza, and hardened U.S. sanctions under Trump's second term.
One Iranian analyst described to Newsweek a complex mix of feelings among a certain strata of Iranian society; people who both seek lasting change in government but are averse to the kind of shocks that could usher in a much deeper crisis.
"My social bubble consists of intellectuals, entrepreneurs and a middle- to upper-middle-class, educated cohort who can still—albeit with increasing difficulty—keep their balance sheets afloat," he told Newsweek, requesting anonymity to speak freely.
"Their attitude toward the current situation is deeply contradictory. Most detest the state, and particularly the leader who has ruled for 37 years. They long for change, for a waft of fresh air that might return Iran to a path of prosperity.
"Yet they also crave stability. Disruption kills business, and the cumulative burden of uncertainty has become exhausting. This is compounded by the nature of the opposition: a far-right figure, the son of a former dictator, openly backed by Israel," he said, referring to Pahlavi.
The result is an impasse, one in which "people desire change and renewal, but they regard the available alternative with profound trepidation".
"Continuity, however undesirable, appears safer—because disruption, once again, kills business."
There are those in Iran who have braved the wrath of security forces to express open calls for the downfall of the government. Some even carried Pahlavi's picture and chanted his name amid the chaos of the recent protests.
Yet across the nation of 92 million people, the second-largest in the Middle East, many hope change can still come from within the system rather than through the work of outside actors.
"War is evil. I know too few people who genuinely see it as an option," the analyst said.
"Many recognize that the state remains adamant in the face of change, yet there is a belief in the air that we are almost there.
"The old Ayatollah will soon be gone, and his death is widely imagined as opening a narrow window of opportunity. But war would shut that window. It would impose a permanent police atmosphere: in wartime, the maneuvering space for civil movements collapses. No one wants war. The Iranian diaspora has been calling for it for years, but inside the country, among those with real skin in the game, war is deeply despised, regardless of whether Iran could repel an attack."
With Iranians still mourning a historic loss of life in recent weeks—some believe 30,000 people were killed—and now bracing for new instability, the prevailing atmosphere across the nation is one of "sadness".
"Melancholy is the air anywhere you go," says the analyst.

...
Iran Military Prepared for a Showdown
Others are rallying behind the government and its armed forces, including the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC). The force suffered a number of high-profile casualties in the opening moments of the 12-Day War and has since been tasked with leading preparations for a new confrontation.
The IRGC has also been in charge of maintaining internal security, particularly through its Basij paramilitary wing.
Iranian officials report that IRGC members were among between 500-600 security personnel killed during the recent violence which esclated from protests, which the government largely blamed on outside infiltrators aided by foreign actors, including Israel. Meanwhile, activists and opposition figures blame the brunt of the bloodshed on the military and law enforcement.
"The society is still in shock of the violence, but as for the preparations for countering the possible U.S. strikes, I think in this case, they trust the state, they trust their military forces and the IRGC," Fereshteh Sadeghi, a Tehran-based journalist and political commentator, told Newsweek.
She described the overall mood in Iran as one of anxious tranquility, but with lingering grievances that could fuel a new explosion of protests.
"The situation is calm, but my personal understanding is that it is like a burning fire beneath," she said.
"So, any moment, not in the immediate future, but months from now, or maybe after Nowruz [the Persian New Year], which is in March, protests may come to surface again because the points that the protest initially started were about economic instability and market turmoil."
When those first demonstrations began among shopkeepers and merchants in Tehran's Grand Bazaar on December 28, the dollar exchange rate had soared to a historic 1,400,000 rial.
Despite some gradual recovery, the rate has been thrown into volatility again in recent days as U.S. threats put Iran and its neighbors on high alert.
The military has sought to instill a sense of confidence, as Iranians have followed reports of the escalating tensions, on state media and increasingly, as an internet protest blackout is lifted, through online channels.
"The army, the IRGC, or in general, the Iranian Armed Forces, they don't explain, they don't want to create fear among people," Sadeghi said.
"But the media report President Trump's threats and rhetoric, and at the end of the day, we know that even after that 12-day exchange of fire between Iran and Israel, everybody knew that it had not been finished, and somewhere else it would start. We know that the United States had been trying to change the regime in Iran for more than four decades."
There are those who also feel that two previous rounds of Iranian retaliation to U.S. attacks—the strike on a U.S. base in Qatar in the 12-Day War last June and the strike on a U.S. base in Iraq in response to the 2020 killing of IRGC Quds Force chief Major General Qassem Soleimani —did not prove "very satisfactory to people," who "expected them to be harder and harsher."
This belief may also be fueling the rhetoric of Iranian officials such as Ali Shamkhani, a key adviser to Khamenei who was reportedly injured during the 12-Day War. He warned Tuesday that even a so-called "limited strike" from the U.S. "will be considered the "start of war, and its response will be immediate, all-out and unprecedented, targeting the heart of Tel Aviv and all those supporting the aggressor."
His warnings have been echoed by other top officials, including diplomats such as Foreign Minister Abbas Araghchi, who have urged that a diplomatic solution is preferable.
In a statement shared with Newsweek, the Iranian Mission to the United Nations recalled prior U.S. interventions, saying that the "last time the U.S. blundered into wars in Afghanistan and Iraq, it squandered over $7 trillion and lost more than 7,000 American lives."
"Iran stands ready for dialogue based on mutual respect and interests—BUT IF PUSHED, IT WILL DEFEND ITSELF AND RESPOND LIKE NEVER BEFORE!"
Newsweek has reached out to the U.S. State Department for comment.
'It Appears Trump Prefers War to Diplomacy'
The feeling that conflict might be inevitable has been compounded by the lack of progress on diplomatic fronts.
While Trump has continued to broadcast the prospect of reaching a new deal with Iran, his conditions run contrary to the government's bottom line, creating a situation where some have concluded that any nuclear talks are ultimately fabricated to fail.
Iranian officials have always denied seeking to produce nuclear weapons, insisting that the national program and uranium enrichment work is solely for peaceful purposes. They cite an Islamic ruling from Khamenei, who has forbid the proliferation of weapons of mass destruction.
But officials from the U.S. and other nations, particularly Israel, which has a nuclear arsenal of its own, remain skeptical of Tehran's intentions.
Demands such as the suspension of uranium enrichment, the handover of enriched uranium stockpiles, the shutdown of the nuclear program, limits on the range and number of ballistic missiles, and the cessation of Iran’s regional role are not terms Tehran considers acceptable, says Mostafa Najafi, a Tehran-based security analyst.
"Iranian officials view acceptance of these demands not only as unfair but fundamentally as a threat to the country’s national interests and security," he told Newsweek.
"From this standpoint, the divide between the two sides is not merely technical or resolvable through adjustments in details; it has taken on a strategic nature.
"Under such circumstances, the political space required for compromise appears more limited than in the past. There is a growing perception in Tehran that Washington’s approach—particularly given Donald Trump’s hardline posture—is focused less on achieving a sustainable agreement and more on increasing pressure to force Iran into submission and fundamental retreat."
Najafi expressed his personal view that, "given these conditions and Trump’s rigid approach, there is no promising opening for an agreement," and "it increasingly appears that the U.S. government prefers war to diplomacy."
This perception is reinforced, he argues, by the experience of the last substantial U.S.-Iran talks, which were set to enter a new round just days before Israel launched the opening strikes of what would become the 12-Day War. New negotiations now risk establishing a pretext for new intervention, he says, should they fail to progress.
Trump's overtures to Iranians protesters, urging them to take on the government and "take over your institutions", have also indicated that the White House is leaning toward intervention, Najafi says.
"What is seen in Tehran as Trump’s interventionist involvement in Iran’s internal unrest—including calls for protesters to seize government centers and even threats of leadership change—have strengthened the pessimistic outlook among Iranian officials regarding U.S. intentions," Najafi said.
"Under these conditions, diplomacy has little chance of success, and one should expect the trajectory to move toward war."
And with Trump warning that "the next attack will be far worse" if Iran does not "MAKE A DEAL," Iran's security apparatus is gearing up for what it deems to be a fight for the very survival of the Islamic Republic.
"Such an attack is viewed in Tehran as an existential threat," Najafi said.
He referred to the comments in recent days from Iranian officials, such as Shamkhani who vowed serious retaliation.
The military has deemed the cost of inaction to be higher than that of responding with force to a U.S. campaign seeking "to prolong a state of instability, maintain a persistent 'shadow of war'", Najafi said.
"On the basis of these two strategic considerations, Iran’s leadership appears to believe that the cost of any attack must be raised to such a level that Trump’s threats would cease.
"In this context, I anticipate that, in addition to U.S. bases in the region, American embassies and other U.S. assets in the region could become targets. Even U.S. regional allies may not remain immune."

...
'There Will Be No Regime Change'
Dolotabadi, for his part, also viewed Iran's military as being prepared for a decisive showdown, one that may emerge to be unprecedented in scope as Tehran eyes targeting the U.S. "armada" directly, in addition to bases and assets across the Middle East and beyond.
"This is the first time that Iran is preparing for a naval battle with the U.S. in the Sea of Oman," Dolotabadi said. "Iran has repeatedly practiced sinking U.S. ships at sea and has prepared itself for such conditions."
Beyond traditional military challenges however, Trump has demonstrated the capacity to directly target adversarial leadership, most dramatically shown in the U.S. Delta Force raid that seized Venezuelan President Nicolás Maduro and his wife from their home in Caracas earlier this month to face alleged "narco-terrorism" charges in the US.
The White House has begun referencing the Venezuela operation in its messaging toward Tehran.
Yet the situation in Iran may prove more complicated, not least given Khamenei's authority not only as supreme leader, but also leading religious authority. Many worry a decapitation would only empower an array of domestic armed factions, including ethnic-rooted partisans organizing among Arabs, Azeris, Balochi and Kurds, as well as fervent Islamist militants, such as the Islamic State (ISIS).
Even U.S. Secretary of State Marco Rubio appeared to acknowledge the uncertainties that would ensue if the US were to secure Khamenei's hypothetical downfall, telling lawmakers Wednesday that "no one knows what would take over" should the Islamic Republic collapse.
Dolotabadi said Iranian leadership would prove far more difficult to target than its old Axis of Resistance ally in Venezuela.
"The closest distance to the Maduro palace was 14 kilometers from the location of the U.S. forces," Dolotabadi said. "This distance is about 700 kilometers for the Iranian leader. The Iranian leader is protected in Tehran by a circle of the most loyal forces, and all measures have been prepared for any attack similar to the Israeli attack in June. No one in Iran has the idea that the U.S. is currently capable of assassinating the Iranian leadership with a bombing.
"Therefore, in the event of any military attack, Iran will be able to manage the situation and there will be no regime change or even internal unrest."
In a polarized era, the center is dismissed as bland. At Newsweek, ours is different: The Courageous Center—it's not "both sides," it's sharp, challenging and alive with ideas. We follow facts, not factions. If that sounds like the kind of journalism you want to see thrive, we need you.
When you become a Newsweek Member, you support a mission to keep the center strong and vibrant. Members enjoy: Ad-free browsing, exclusive content and editor conversations. Help keep the center courageous. Join today.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines

