Electoral College Map

...

Dan Perry

By Dan Perry

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


There is a particular kind of American exceptionalism that inspires admiration. And then there is the other kind—the kind that produces the Electoral College. Virginia has recently done America a huge service by joining the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact, which has taken aim at the Electoral College. A few more states joining would kill this scourge for good.

In covering elections worldwide for decades, from fragile post-Soviet states to mature European democracies and developing nations in Africa and Asia, I have seen corruption, intimidation, manipulation, and fraud. There are systems so crude that ballots were effectively suggestions. But never—not once—has a democracy been encountered that deliberately builds into its core machinery the strong possibility, as a feature and not a bug, that the candidate who gets fewer votes becomes president. That is not democracy with quirks—that's dysfunction masquerading as tradition.

And yet here we are. The Electoral College, this creaking artifact of 18th-century compromise, still governs the most powerful country on Earth. It was designed by men who distrusted voters, excluded women entirely, tolerated slavery, and conceived of the United States less as a nation than as a loose arrangement of semi-sovereign entities.

Read More on Opinion

Only in the United States is a system preserved in which votes are counted, then converted into points, then handed to individuals called “electors,” who may or may not respect those votes, and then aggregated through a formula that privileges some citizens over others based on where they happen to live. It would be funny if it weren’t so consequential—because the U.S. is still the most important country in the world, and its presidency is extraordinarily powerful.

Electoral College Map

...

Under the silly system, every state receives electors equal to its representation in Congress—two senators plus its House members. Since tiny states have the same two senators as huge ones, this immediately gives smaller states, the vast majority of which are conservative, disproportionate weight. Then comes winner-take-all, the accelerant of absurdity, in which a narrow victory yields a total sweep of a state’s electoral votes. The result is a system in which tens of millions of votes are effectively discarded, and a candidate can piece together a path to the presidency while losing the national popular vote. Two of the last four Republican presidential “victories” followed this path.

Here’s but one bizarre outcome: America’s most populous cities by far, New York, Los Angeles and Chicago, are all in safe Democratic states, so no candidate of any party needs to spend one second worrying about them. Imagine a French presidential candidate who could completely ignore Paris, Lyon, and Marseille. It would never happen.

If this were happening in a country I was covering as a journalist, I would not hesitate to call it what it is: a system that systematically advantages one political camp. And American officials would be expected to issue stern statements about democratic norms.

Instead, Americans defend the Electoral College. Or rather, some Americans defend it—usually those who benefit most from it. The argument is rarely honest. It is dressed up in reverence for “the rules,” for “the founders,” for “the federal system.” But strip away the rhetoric, and what remains is simple: a preference for a system that can deliver victory without majority support.

There is also a deeper problem, one less discussed but more alarming. The Electoral College is not merely unfair but dangerously vulnerable.

Because presidential elections are effectively 51 separate contests stitched together (the states plus D.C.), the system creates multiple points where outcomes can be challenged, delayed, or distorted. A preview of this was seen in 2020, when allies of Donald Trump attempted to submit alternate slates of electors and pressure officials to overturn certified results.

But the vulnerabilities go further.

Faithless electors can, in theory, ignore voters entirely. State legislatures have murky authority that could be exploited in a crisis. Congress can object to electoral votes under loosely defined standards. And in the ultimate constitutional absurdity, if no candidate reaches 270, the decision on who becomes president goes to the House of Representatives, where each state delegation gets one vote—meaning Wyoming counts as much as California.

If a system were designed for maximum confusion and potential abuse, it could look something like this.

The remarkable thing is not that Americans have tolerated it for so long, but that there is a way out—and it does not require the near-impossible task of amending the Constitution. The National Popular Vote Interstate Compact is, in its way, a piece of political jujitsu. It uses the Constitution’s own rules against the Electoral College’s distortions.

Here's how: States already have the authority to decide how to allocate electors. Under the compact, participating states agree that once enough of them join to reach 270 electoral votes, the threshold for victory in the Electoral College, they will award their electors to the winner of the national popular vote, regardless of their own state-level result. In effect, the Electoral College would remain in place—but it would stop mattering.

Virginia has just joined the effort, becoming the 18th state in the compact and bringing the total to 222 electoral votes. That leaves 48 electoral votes to be allocated to reach 270. This is no longer a theoretical reform; it is now within reach.

Might that gap be bridged? Yes, because the compact doesn’t need “red states” to agree; it needs to assemble a critical mass of Democratic states and just enough competitive ones to tip the balance. Blue states, understanding that the Electoral College works against them, are naturally inclined to join. That is the compact’s quiet strategy: build momentum where it is politically easy, then make the reform feel inevitable enough that a handful of swing states cross over. If that happens, the Electoral College would not be abolished—it would simply become irrelevant.

There are, in fact, a few swing or formerly competitive states already inside the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact—most notably Colorado and Nevada, with Virginia itself a recent graduate from battleground status. But none are the decisive, knife-edge states that typically determine presidential elections. That is precisely the point: the compact has advanced where it is politically easiest, among states that lean Democratic or have trended that way, while the true battlegrounds remain outside.

And that brings us to Pennsylvania, my home state.

Pennsylvania is not just another state. It is one of the few that, being competitive, decides American elections. It enjoys a privileged position under the current system, showered with attention every four years while most of the country is ignored. It is, in the language of the trade, a “swing state”—a polite way of saying that its voters matter more than others.

I know my fellows there to be decent, fair people who believe they are Americans, not citizens of the country of Pennsylvania. The state went to Trump in 2016 and 2024 and Biden in 2020, and has a Democratic governor. Its largest city, Philadelphia, was once the capital of the United States and was the site of the Declaration of Independence—nicely symbolic. It has 19 electoral votes, which would leave just 29 to go for the compact to reach 270. Add Michigan, Wisconsin and Arizona, and it would be game over for a debilitating problem in the democratic world.

Dan Perry is the former Cairo-based Middle East editor and London-based Europe/Africa editor of the Associated Press, the former chairman of the Foreign Press Association in Jerusalem, and the author of two books. Follow him at danperry.substack.com.

The views expressed in this article are the writer's own.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines