10

Loading video...

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


Mariah Carey is as synonymous with Christmas as tinsel, but, this year, the queen of festivities has turned heads—and not for the right reasons.

The All I Want for Christmas Is You singer stars in Sephora’s new holiday ad, which many fans expected to be a glittering celebration of glam. Instead, the campaign has been met with criticism for what some viewers have called a "tone-deaf" message during a cost of living crisis.

Newsweek reached out to Mariah Carey's publicist and to Sephora's press office for comment.

Read More on Life

Inside the Ad: 'Halloween Slayed! But Now … It’s Ti—'

The commercial opens with chaos in the North Pole. Halloween is over, but, just as Mariah begins her signature "It’s time…," the mood shifts.

File photo: Mariah Carey performs at Yaamava' Resort & Casino at San Manuel on November 6, 2024 in Highland, California.

...

Then it is revealed that Christmas is canceled as the elves are fronting a strike and steal the Christmas gifts in rebellion.

"Christmas—it’s canceled. No bells, no cheer, no glam," it says.

Mariah protests—“You can’t cancel Christmas!”—before belting her iconic line: "IT’S TIME!!!" Her magic seemingly restores the holiday spirit.

'Corporate Gaslighting'

However, not everyone found the ad funny. TikTok user Raygina George (@raysrabbithole) posted a seven-part video dissecting the commercial, which has since racked up over 1.3 million views.

View on TikTok

View this video on TikTok

George told Newsweek: "We open on a table of luxury goods, YSL, maybe Jimmy Choo, in a holiday ad. Cute, right? Except we’re in an economy where people are choosing between food and insulin. So, when your centerpiece is designer glam, you’re not selling fantasy. You’re flaunting cruelty. This isn’t aspirational. It’s alienating."

In her breakdown, George added that the ad "isn’t just tone-deaf; it’s a master-class in corporate gaslighting." She noted that the elf, played by Billy Eichner, is immediately accused of stealing "with no evidence—just vibes," calling it a reflection of classism and "guilty until proven poor."

George added that the line "Elf Boy" carried uncomfortable undertones toward the LGBTQ+ community, particularly as the U.S. Supreme Court reviews same-sex marriage legislation.

According to George, lines like "The elves are striking this year" and "I’m pawning all this so I can afford elf therapy" mirror real-world struggles—from labor unrest to the cost of health care—at a time when Americans are "dragged through hell" financially. "You didn’t just miss the mark," she said. "You aimed at our wounds."

George added that phrases like "Christmas is canceled" mock grassroots boycott movements, while Mariah’s defiant "You can’t cancel Christmas" symbolizes corporate entitlement.

The ad’s ending, where the elf is turned into a snowman, George said, represents "forced labor in a snowman suit"—an allegory for overworked employees in a capitalist system dressed up as holiday cheer.

Expert Weighs In: 'Brands Need More Scrutiny at Every Stage'

Marketing expert Mike Kresch, VP of strategy at Moburst, told Newsweek that high-profile campaigns like Sephora’s need to undergo more intense scrutiny.

"In today’s era of heightened sensitivity, high-profile ad concepts with anticipated heavy media exposure need to undergo significantly more stress testing and scrutiny in the early stages of creative development," Kresch told Newsweek.

He said that brand leaders should be involved from the start—not just at the end as a "finishing touch." In today’s climate, he added, creatives may bristle at this level of oversight.

Kresch said: "It’s the unfortunate reality of the current marketing environment."

He also noted that celebrity partnerships require careful thought. Beyond aligning with the brand, Kresch said, "the endorser’s history must be considered," as modern consumers are quick to connect any past controversy—“fairly or unfairly"—to the brand itself.

Social Media Reacts

Many TikTok users echoed similar concerns, questioning how such an ad made it to air.

"I was a copywriter in advertising. The fact they are even talking about theft, health care, boycotts in THIS political climate, and in a holiday ad with Mariah Carey instead of just a fun Christmas ad is telling—it’s intentional. IDK [I don't know] how this got approved," said one commenter.

Another user, Joy, added, "I scrolled on this ad the moment I saw it bc [because] I saw Mariah Carey dressed as an angel, which has literally never ever at any point been a part of her queen of Christmas aesthetic, and I was immediately out. I had no idea the rest of this ad went so crazy."

And for some, the disconnect was personal. "Mariah Carey launching a new Christmas ad while the rest of us are debating groceries vs health care is a level of confidence I can’t even afford right now," said TikTok user Delia De Lyon.

However, others didn't find the ad too problematic.

"Please enlighten me. what’s wrong with the Mariah Carey Sephora commercial? I saw it but I think I’m missing it?" asked Shuntel Renay on Threads.

"Ok, unpopular opinion here maybe, but it has to be hard as hell to be a marketer for big name corporations while personally being tapped into the culture right now.

"For example, the Mariah Carey Sephora ad. On one hand I understand ppl [people] being sensitive about certain topics but then I put my marketer hat on and I’m like planning for that ad had to have taken at least 6-12 months. Like, I promise you there’s no way the agency that created that knew insurance premiums would be increasing, etc.," shared Yana.

Do you have any viral videos or pictures that you want to share? We want to see the best ones! Send them in to life@newsweek.com and they could appear on our site.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines