
...

By Sam Stevenson
Associate News Editor
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
Veterans’ groups and the Virginia attorney general are suing the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA), arguing that its education benefits rules defy a U.S. Supreme Court ruling and shortchange long‑serving veterans.
Newsweek contacted the VA and a representative for the plaintiffs via email on Tuesday morning for comment.
Why It Matters
The Supreme Court ruled last year that veterans who qualify for both major GI Bill programs—a federal benefit that helps pay for college or job training—can use all the education support they earned.
Read More on News
Plaintiffs say the VA is still enforcing a policy that undercuts that decision. According to the plaintiffs, the VA estimates that 1.2 million veterans are affected by the agency’s break‑in‑service rule.

...
What To Know
A coalition of veterans’ organizations, individual veterans and the Commonwealth of Virginia, filed a lawsuit challenging how VA administers education benefits under the GI Bill.
Petitioners filed their principal brief on March 5, asking the Federal Circuit to vacate VA rules they say unlawfully require a break in service to receive the full 48 months available across the Montgomery GI Bill and the Post‑9/11 GI Bill.
At the center of the dispute is a VA policy that plaintiffs argue has no basis in federal law and directly conflicts with the Supreme Court’s 2024 decision in Rudisill v. McDonough.
In Rudisill, the Court held that veterans who separately earn eligibility under both GI Bill programs are entitled to use both benefits, up to a combined 48‑month cap, regardless of whether their service was continuous. The ruling rejected the idea that veterans must give up one set of benefits to access the other.
Plaintiffs say the VA’s rules misinterpret the GI Bills and improperly implement the Supreme Court’s decision. Under the VA’s current framework, veterans must qualify for benefits under one GI Bill, experience a break in service, then qualify under the other program in order to receive the full 48 months of benefits—an approach the plaintiffs argue directly contradicts Rudisill.
The VA’s public guidance on the Rudisill ruling states that veterans who qualify under both GI Bill programs through separate periods of service may use benefits under both, up to a combined 48 months, and clarifies that reenlistments can count as separate periods with “no requirement for a break in service.”
That guidance provides examples showing how continuous service with multiple reenlistments may still qualify under both programs, notes that stop‑loss or other involuntary extensions do not create separate periods, and directs veterans to apply for a Rudisill review using VA Form 22‑1995.
Despite that guidance, the lawsuit argues that the VA continues to apply a break‑in‑service rule through its benefits administration manual, resulting in what plaintiffs describe as an uneven system.
According to the filing, a veteran with six years of service split across two enlistments could receive more education benefits than a veteran who served continuously for 20 or 30 years.
Plaintiffs argue that outcome penalizes longer service and undermines the purpose of the GI Bill.
Beyond the break‑in‑service requirement, the lawsuit challenges several other aspects of the VA’s approach.
Plaintiffs argue that the department has unlawfully failed to reimburse veterans who paid out of pocket for education after being wrongly denied benefits, extended deadlines for veterans and their spouses while excluding veterans’ children, and treated veterans differently based solely on when their service began.
According to the plaintiffs, the VA’s rules do not provide any meaningful mechanism for reimbursing veterans who covered education costs themselves after being denied benefits, despite the agency previously telling the Federal Circuit that reimbursement could be possible.
The challengers are asking the Federal Circuit to strike down the VA’s break‑in‑service rule, declare the department’s policies unlawful, and require the VA to bring its rules into line with the Supreme Court’s interpretation.
The plaintiffs say there are numerous related cases already moving through the courts and administrative system, including challenges brought by veterans involved in Perkins v. Collins, Rudisill v. Collins, Doran v. Collins and Yoon v. Collins, with many more appeals pending at the VA.
Plaintiffs include the Veterans of Foreign Wars, Iraq and Afghanistan Veterans of America, the Commonwealth of Virginia and several individual veterans and their family members who say they were directly affected by the policy.
What People Are Saying
Luke A. Schamel, an associate at Yetter Coleman LLP who is representing the Veterans of Foreign Wars on a pro bono basis: “The law is clear that veterans whose lengthy service qualifies them for benefits under both GI Bills are entitled to the full benefits they earned.
“More service shouldn’t mean fewer benefits. The VA should roll back this rule and make whole the veterans who were forced to pay out of pocket after the VA wrongfully denied their education benefits.”
What Happens Next
The Federal Circuit will review the merits of the challenge and determine whether the VA’s rules can stand under federal law and Supreme Court precedent.
Any ruling could have broad implications for how education benefits are administered for veterans nationwide and whether past denials must be revisited.
Update 3/10/26, 12:51 p.m. ET. This article has been updated with more information.
In a polarized era, the center is dismissed as bland. At Newsweek, ours is different: The Courageous Center—it's not "both sides," it's sharp, challenging and alive with ideas. We follow facts, not factions. If that sounds like the kind of journalism you want to see thrive, we need you.
When you become a Newsweek Member, you support a mission to keep the center strong and vibrant. Members enjoy: Ad-free browsing, exclusive content and editor conversations. Help keep the center courageous. Join today.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines

