The US Department of Veterans Affairs building is seen in Washington, DC, on July 22, 2019.

...

Sam Stevenson

By Sam Stevenson

Associate News Editor

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


Backlash is growing over a new Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) rule tying disability ratings to how veterans function on medication, with critics warning it could force impossible choices between health care and benefits.

“This action will have no impact on any veteran’s current disability rating,” Peter Kasperowicz, VA press secretary, told Newsweek in an emailed statement.

Why It Matters

VA has moved swiftly to rewrite how disability ratings are calculated after court rulings limited its ability to consider the effects of medication.

Read More on News

Veterans groups say the change risks reducing compensation for those managing serious service‑connected conditions.

The US Department of Veterans Affairs building is seen in Washington, DC, on July 22, 2019.

...

What To Know

The VA on February 17 issued an interim final rule titled *“*Evaluative Rating: Impact of Medication,” which took effect immediately.

Under the change, VA examiners must rate disabilities based on how a veteran functions while taking prescribed medication, rather than estimating how severe the condition would be without treatment.

The VA stated in the notice: “If medication or other treatment lessens the functional impairment a disability causes and thereby improves a veteran’s earning capacity, that is the proper disability level for which the veteran should be compensated.”

VA officials argue the change merely clarifies long‑standing practice and avoids what they describe as speculative assessments of an unmedicated baseline.

But House Committee on Veterans Affairs ranking member Mark Takano has described it as a “harmful decision.”

“This rule change penalizes veterans for taking medications to address their conditions and symptoms, putting veterans in a place of deciding between managing their health and receiving their full benefits,” he said.

And Disabled American Veterans (DAV) national commander Coleman Nee said the advocacy group was “disappointed and alarmed” by the move, which he said “could potentially reduce disability compensation for millions of disabled veterans.”

The rule applies to new disability claims and to existing ratings that come up for reevaluation during medical exams.

Critics say the move reverses years of legal precedent.

In Jones vs. Shinseki (2012), the Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims ruled that the VA could not lower ratings based on medication unless the diagnostic code explicitly allowed it.

That principle was reinforced in Ingram vs. Collins (2025), which required examiners in some cases to determine a baseline severity without medication.

The VA said those rulings threatened to overwhelm the system by forcing readjudication of hundreds of thousands of claims across hundreds of diagnostic codes.

The agency cited that risk as justification for bypassing the usual delayed implementation and public input period.

While a public comment period is now open through April 20, veterans’ organizations say the rule was developed and issued too quickly, with little opportunity for meaningful consultation.

What People Are Saying

VA press secretary Peter Kasperowicz told Newsweek in an emailed statement: "This regulation simply formalizes VA’s long-standing practice of determining disability ratings based on veterans’ service-related disabilities and any medications they are taking to treat those disabilities.

"VA has been determining disability ratings this way since 1958. Further, this action will have no impact on any veteran’s current disability rating."

The VA notice says: "This amendment clarifies that veterans should be compensated for the actual level of functional impairment they experience and, therefore, that the ameliorative effects of medication should not be estimated or discounted when evaluating the severity of a veteran's disability at the time of the disability examination."

House Committee on Veterans Affairs ranking member Mark Takano said: “VA is once again leaving the veterans’ community out of a critical decision‑making process and ignoring judicial precedent as it takes steps to scale back veterans’ benefits. This rule change penalizes veterans for taking medications to address their conditions and symptoms, putting veterans in a place of deciding between managing their health and receiving their full benefits.

“Veterans earned their benefits through their invaluable service, and VA should never stand in the way of veterans receiving them.”

Veterans of Foreign Wars national commander Carol Whitmore said: “As a former Army nurse, it seems this rule change could have unforeseen and harmful downstream effects for veterans, which is why it demands serious public scrutiny and possible legislative clarification from Capitol Hill."

DAV national commander Coleman Nee said: “DAV is extremely disappointed and alarmed by VA’s decision to issue an Interim Final Rule today that could potentially reduce disability compensation for millions of disabled veterans. The new regulation would allow VA to reduce disability compensation ratings for veterans who take medications to control their conditions or reduce their symptoms…

“…It is unclear if and how VA is implementing this dramatic change and how it will impact the more than 6 million veterans currently receiving disability compensation, most of whom are taking at least one medication.”

Jason Cameron, a Marine Corps veteran, podcaster and retired veterans benefits service officer, told Stars and Stripes: “This is an erosion of benefits.”

Charles Garbarino, a retired Army colonel and physician who served three tours in Iraq, said:
“A lot of veterans prescribed medication for their service‑related medical problems will cut it off, rather than lose compensation.”

What Happens Next

The interim rule remains in effect as the VA collects public comments through April, even as veterans groups and lawmakers push for changes or reversal.

Congressional scrutiny is expected to intensify, with calls for hearings and possible legislative clarification already underway.

Update, 2/19/26, 6:12 a.m. ET. This article has been updated with a VA statement.

In a polarized era, the center is dismissed as bland. At Newsweek, ours is different: The Courageous Center—it's not "both sides," it's sharp, challenging and alive with ideas. We follow facts, not factions. If that sounds like the kind of journalism you want to see thrive, we need you.

When you become a Newsweek Member, you support a mission to keep the center strong and vibrant. Members enjoy: Ad-free browsing, exclusive content and editor conversations. Help keep the center courageous. Join today.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines