US President Donald Trump arrives to the White House in Washington, DC, following a trip to Palm Beach, Florida with a stop at a Washington Commanders football game on November 9, 2025.

...

Brendan ColeShane Croucher

By Brendan Cole and Shane Croucher

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


A Utah judge has chosen a congressional map that would make at least one of the state's four congressional seats—currently held by Republicans—more competitive for the Democrats.

Judge Dianna Gibson said in her ruling late Monday that a Republican-proposed redistricting map "fails to abide by and conform with the requirements of Proposition 4," a 2018 state rule that created an independent redistricting commission to deter gerrymandering.

Why It Matters

The battle in Utah is part of a broader redistricting war between Republicans and Democrats, fueled by U.S. President Donald Trump's desire to keep GOP control of the U.S. House of Representatives in the 2026 midterm elections that will shape the final two years of his second term.

Read More on Politics

Gibson’s ruling delivers Democrats a second win in the fight over redistricting across the U.S. ahead of the midterms, a week after California voters approved a ballot initiative that could net Democrats five more seats in that state.

What To Know

US President Donald Trump arrives at the White House in Washington, DC, following a trip to Palm Beach, Florida, with a stop at a Washington Commanders football game on November 9, 2025.

...

Gibson issued the ruling just before a midnight deadline Monday.

Her decision blocked the Republican-controlled Legislature’s map from being used in next year's elections because it failed to comply with Proposition 4— a 2018 voter-approved law for an independent redistricting process.

Gibson ordered that the plaintiffs’ submitted alternatives, known as Map 1, be implemented for Utah’s congressional elections. The plaintiffs in the case included the League of Women Voters Utah and Mormon Women for Ethical Government.

In August, Gibson voided Utah’s last congressional map that the Utah Legislature had set in 2021. She ruled it was the result of an unconstitutional process after lawmakers that year undid Proposition 4.

After Gibson’s ruling, Utah House and Senate Democratic lawmakers said in a statement, cited by local media, that they felt “a deep sense of hope and relief" and described it as a “win for every Utahn.”

Although he is yet to comment, former Democratic Congressman Ben McAdams is among the candidates tipped to be considering a run for Congress, Fox 13 reported.

Meanwhile, Rep. Matt MacPherson, R-West Valley City, posted on X he would look to impeach Judge Gibson "for gross abuse of power, violating the separation of powers and failing to uphold her oath of office to the Utah Constitution.”

What People Are Saying

Judge Dianna Gibson’s ruling: “The Court finds that Map C was drawn with the purpose to favor Republicans—a conclusion that follows from even S.B. 1011’s metric for partisan intent—and it unduly favors Republicans and disfavors Democrats. In short, Map C does not comply with Utah law.”

Utah House and Senate Democratic lawmakers in a statement: “This is a win for every Utahn...we took an oath to serve the people of Utah, and fair representation is the truest measure of that promise.”

What Happens Next

The ruling is expected to cause political ructions in the state and creates an obstacle to the GOP in a state they had expected to get a clean sweep. Across the U.S., Democrats need to win three U.S. House seats to wrest control of the chamber.

According to Deseret News, Utah’s Republican leaders had said they would fight Gibson’s rulings in court by appealing the case to the Utah Supreme Court, and if necessary the U.S. Supreme Court.

Update 11/10/25, 06:36 a.m. ET: This article has been updated with further information.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines