10
Loading video...


By Billal Rahman and Hollie Silverman
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
Labor unions, university faculty groups and immigrant advocates are suing the Trump administration over two immigration policies they say make it harder for some immigrants already living in the United States to obtain green cards without leaving the country.
The lawsuit, filed October 5 in the U.S. District Court for the District of Massachusetts, challenges policies the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) issued in May and August. They affect adjustment of status, the process that allows eligible immigrants in the United States to apply for permanent residence without leaving the country to obtain an immigrant visa at a U.S. consulate abroad.
In a statement emailed to Newsweek Wednesday, USCIS Spokesman Zach Kahler said, "This lawsuit is yet another frivolous attempt to disrupt the Trump administration’s commitment to enforce our country’s immigration laws as intended by Congress."
Read More on News
"USCIS will continue to faithfully apply long-standing immigration law and prior immigration court decisions to ensure aliens navigate our nation’s immigration system properly," Kahler added.
The challengers argue that the two policies work together to change the rules for people already seeking permanent residence, and that someone who filed prior to their implementation could now be judged under the new standard and potentially denied without first receiving an opportunity to provide additional evidence addressing it.

...
The May policy directs USCIS officers to consider whether an applicant chose to seek a green card from within the United States rather than through consular processing abroad. Meanwhile, the August policy gives USCIS officers greater authority to deny some applications without first asking applicants for additional evidence or notifying them of an intended denial. It applies to new applications as well as applications that were pending when the policy took effect.
The Trump administration has tightened parts of the legal immigration system as it pursues its mass deportation campaign, making a series of changes affecting how immigrants obtain permanent residence. Those include the repeal of a Biden-era public-charge regulation and new USCIS guidance on determining whether some green card applicants are likely to become dependent on government benefits. The administration says the public-charge changes are intended to promote self-sufficiency and enforce immigration law.
The American Association of University Professors and its Harvard Faculty and Boston University chapters; the Service Employees International Union and two affiliates, SEIU Local 509 and 32BJ SEIU; Americans for Immigrant Justice; and six individual green card applicants brought the lawsuit.
The organizations represent or serve academics, doctors, researchers, service workers and other immigrants seeking permanent residence, as well as people whose close relatives are seeking green cards.
What Are the Changes Being Challenged?
Adjustment of status allows certain eligible immigrants already in the United States to apply for permanent residence without leaving the country. Consular processing, the alternative at issue in the lawsuit, generally requires applicants to complete the immigrant visa process through a U.S. Embassy or consulate abroad.
USCIS's May 21 policy describes adjustment as an "extraordinary" form of discretionary relief. The policy does not require every adjustment applicant to leave the country, but the plaintiffs argue that it improperly makes some immigrants' decision to use a process authorized by Congress count against them.
Related Story

Trump Admin Proposes $70,000 Fee for Foreign Graduates to Work in US
Related Story

USCIS Hit With Lawsuit Over Green Card Changes
The August policy creates a separate issue for people with pending cases. The plaintiffs argue that someone who applied before the May change would have had no reason to submit evidence addressing the government's new approach, but could now face denial without first receiving an opportunity to provide that evidence.
The administration takes a different view. The May memorandum emphasizes that adjustment of status is discretionary and says Congress generally expected certain immigrants admitted temporarily or paroled into the country to leave after the purpose of their stay was completed if they wanted to pursue permanent residence.
The process accounts for a significant share of legal immigration. In fiscal year 2024, 782,800 of roughly 1.36 million people who became lawful permanent residents, or 57 percent, did so through adjustment of status, according to DHS figures cited in the complaint.
Why the Lawsuit Wants It Halted
The plaintiffs argue that USCIS lacks authority to penalize eligible immigrants for choosing adjustment of status instead of consular processing.
Congress created the adjustment process in 1952 and has amended it repeatedly. According to the complaint, lawmakers deliberately provided a route for eligible immigrants to become permanent residents without leaving the United States and never established a general requirement that they instead apply abroad.
The lawsuit contains six claims, alleging that the policies exceed USCIS's authority, improperly apply new standards to pending cases, are arbitrary and capricious, violate federal rulemaking requirements, conflict with existing immigration precedent, and violate due process. The court has not ruled on those claims.
The plaintiffs also point to possible practical consequences, including family separation and interruptions to employment and education if applicants must pursue their cases abroad.
One plaintiff, Maria Francisca Guardado, a Salvadoran woman who has lived in the United States since 1998, applied for adjustment of status in 2022. USCIS denied her application on September 2 despite finding her eligible for adjustment, according to the complaint.
USCIS denied the application as a matter of discretion, citing Guardado's immigration history, a 1999 arrest for which the charge was later dismissed, and alleged failures to disclose the arrest on earlier Temporary Protected Status applications. Guardado has asked USCIS to reopen or reconsider the decision.
Another plaintiff, Miriam Esther Moreno Coto, has lived in the United States for about 26 years and has three U.S. citizen children. The lawsuit says a USCIS officer repeatedly questioned Moreno Coto at a July interview about why she was seeking adjustment in the United States rather than applying through a consulate abroad. Her application remained pending when the lawsuit was filed.
The complaint says Moreno Coto's 15-year-old son has autism and requires ongoing treatment and homebound instruction, with Moreno Coto overseeing his daily care. The plaintiffs say having to pursue permanent residence abroad could separate the family and disrupt his care.
"Congress created a process that allows eligible people who are already living in the United States to pursue permanent residence without uprooting their lives and leaving the country. The executive branch cannot rewrite that system and then treat people's lawful actions as a reason to deny them said permanent residency," Skye Perryman, the president and CEO of Democracy Forward, said in a news release.
"These policies are changing the rules on families, workers, students, and others who have followed the legal process and built their lives here, putting them at risk of separation from their loved ones and communities. We are proud to represent our clients in challenging these unlawful policies and protecting the process Congress established," she continued.
"By weaponizing the green card process and threatening immigrant professors, researchers, and students with sudden deportation or forced family separation, this administration is sabotaging scientific innovation and turning our universities into hostile environments for the global talent that drives our country forward," Todd Wolfson, the president of the American Association of University Professors, said in a news release.
What Happens Next
The plaintiffs are asking the court to temporarily block the policies while the case proceeds and ultimately strike them down. They also want the court to order USCIS to adjudicate affected applications under controlling Board of Immigration Appeals precedent.
The court has not yet decided their claims that the policies violate federal immigration law, the Administrative Procedure Act or the Constitution.
Contact Newsweek editors on this story: Matthew Cannon, Shakeema Edwards, Gray R. Thomas.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines