
...

By Giulia Carbonaro
Senior Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
As rising home prices and stubbornly high mortgage rates continue to keep American homebuyers on the sidelines, the country's housing market is "beginning to look a lot like 2008," according to real estate analyst Nick Gerli—"at least for homebuilders."
In parts of the country that have been building the most new homes in recent years, especially Florida and Texas, homebuilders are struggling to offload their properties to cautious buyers biding their time for lower mortgage rates.
As supply begins to pile up in the market, many homebuilders are increasingly offering incentives to move their unsold inventory.
Read More on News
Why It Matters
For years now, the U.S. housing market has been in the midst of an affordability crisis that has kept millions of Americans off the property ladder.
Historically low inventory levels—a result of underbuilding in the aftermath of the 2008 subprime mortgage crisis—and pent-up demand have kept prices rising since the pandemic, even when the sudden surge of mortgage rates in 2022 further chipped away at Americans' purchasing power.
But in the parts of the country where inventory is growing, the situation is finally turning in favor of buyers, who are forcing sellers to meet them where they are and slash prices or boost incentives.
What To Know
Gerli, CEO of real estate data platform Reventure App, shared on X a photo he took outside of a home-building site some 45 minutes north of Tampa, Florida. A sign reads: "New homes, zero down."
According to the real estate analyst, the homebuilding company—LGI Homes—had "over 20 vacant spec houses completed for sale. And are advertising 0 percent down mortgages to try to move the inventory." Newsweek contacted LGI Homes for comment by email on Tuesday morning.
A screenshot of the homes on site listed for sale on Zillow shows about 12 new homes completed and move-in ready, with price tags ranging from a minimum of $286,000 to a maximum of $383,000.
"What's interesting is that the builder agent told me they were going to start converting these homes to for-rent," Gerli said. "I'm guessing it's because they want to start on the next phase or construction, and they simply can't do that with 20+ for sale," he added.
In addition to offering 0 percent down mortgages, LGI Homes is also offering rent-to-own for their newly constructed properties, Gerli said. "Both of these anecdotes are hugely reminiscent of what we saw near the peak of the last bubble in 2007," he said.

...
There is an advantage for homebuilders to turn the properties into for-rent homes, as the cost of buying a home is still rising while the cost of renting is essentially flat. In December, according to Redfin data, the median U.S. asking rent was $1,594—the lowest since March 2022—after falling 0.3 percent year–over-year.
The median sale price of a typical U.S. home, by comparison, has been rising year-over-year for 20 consecutive months as of February, when it was $424,647, up 3 percent compared to a year earlier.
How Is This Similar To The 2008 Crisis?
In the lead-up to the 2007 housing bubble that then burst into a crisis, homebuilders were so desperate to offload their properties that they offered big incentives to potential buyers.
The same is now happening, with large builders "reporting their biggest use of incentives in over a decade," Gerli said. According to John Burns Research & Consulting, homebuilder Lennar was offering 13 percent of revenue in sale incentives on home deliveries in the quarter leading up to February.
While the situation reminds Gerli of the 2008 crisis, builders now seem "intent on continuing to build," unlike in the years leading up to the housing crash, he said.
"Their lots are overflowing. Their margins are getting heavily compressed. And they're doing rent-to-own. But they're still putting stakes in the ground and building new phases in these communities," Gerli said.
"By this point in the last cycle the builders were starting to heavily cut back on single family starts. But today they're still at 1.1 million annualized. Which is below mid-2000s levels, but still above pre-pandemic," he added.

...
Something that has also changed is the distribution of homebuilders' activity across the country, Gerli said.
"Back in the mid-2000s there was a much more even distribution of [homebuilding] starts," he wrote on X. "Now the starts are almost exclusively in the South and certain Mountain States," he added.
What Gerli is describing is a regional phenomenon where some states—especially Florida and Texas—have been building much more than any other across the country, while others—especially in the Northeast—have built a lot less and are still in the midst of an inventory crisis.
"Between South and West, builders did about 1.1 million housing starts in Feb 2025," Gerli wrote. "In the Northeast and Midwest, they did only 270k."
Is This a Problem for the Entire Country—or Florida Alone?
The situation in Florida is different from that of the rest of the U.S. because the state has been building more than any other in the country and is facing some unique challenges—including rising homeowners association (HOA) fees, high home insurance premiums, the growing risk of natural disasters and the impact of a new building-safety law on aging condos.
The Sunshine State, which boomed during the pandemic thanks to an influx of out-of-state newcomers, now finds itself with a lot more homes to sell than it has interested buyers.
"Inventory is up 33.9 percent year-over-year in Florida as of February 2025, according to data available on Reventure App," Gerli told Newsweek. "New listings continue to rise due to surging insurance and HOA fees. Meanwhile, demand is down due to a slowdown in people moving to the state.
As a result of this slowdown in demand, home prices are dropping in most Florida counties, especially in once-overvalued markets like Punta Gorda. Home values in the city were down 8.3 percent year-over-year last month, compared to 1.8 percent statewide.
In Cape Coral, they were down 6.5 percent, in North Port/Sarasota 6.1 percent and Naples 5 percent, Gerli said. The real estate analyst expects home prices in Florida to fall by 5 percent year-over-year throughout 2025.
According to Gerli, in the South and Mountain West, "a legitimate 2007-08 situation is currently starting to occur in terms of inventory, incentives, and desperate tactics like 0 percent down mortgages."
But in the Northeast and Midwest, "that isn't really happening," he said. "There's very little builder inventory in these markets. Supply is still tight. And prices are still gaining at a healthy clip."
However, Gerli added, the situation in the South and Midwest should be a cause of concern for the U.S. market and the country's economy overall "to see the builders getting to this level of desperation. It suggests some major cracks are forming."
What's Next
There are other factors troubling homebuilders across the country, including the direction taken by the U.S. housing market this year.
Last month, the National Association of Home Builders' (NAHB) Housing Market Index, or HMI, reported that U.S. homebuilders' confidence was sinking amid fears surrounding the potential impact of the Trump administration's tariffs on the construction sector. It was down 5 points from January and 6 points from a year earlier, to 42—the lowest level in five months.
Trump's tariffs on countries like Canada—from which the U.S. imports a lot of softwood timber used in homebuilding—could increase the cost of constructing a new home and discourage homebuilders from starting new projects.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines