10
Loading video...

By Carine Harb
Associate Editor, My Turn
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
On his first day in office, Jan. 20, 2025, President Donald Trump signed an executive order initiating the U.S. withdrawal from the World Health Organization (WHO), a decision that would formally take effect in January 2026.
The WHO operates through collaboration among its 194 member nations, which collectively determine global health priorities and coordinate responses to health crises, including the sharing of medical data, treatments, and vaccines.
The Trump administration, as part of its reassessment of America's role in international aid, justified the WHO withdrawal by citing the organization's alleged failures in handling the COVID-19 pandemic. The orders also argue that U.S. foreign assistance has contributed to global instability rather than peace.
Read More on U.S.
However, stepping away from the WHO and reducing international health aid could hinder efforts to address life-threatening diseases and outbreaks, particularly in lower-income nations that rely on external support for essential healthcare services. It would also shift decision-making power to other countries.
Newsweek reached out to public health experts for a further analysis of this decision, including its global impact.

...
From Professor Ilona Kickbusch: The U.S. Will Lose Influence Once It Leaves The World Health Organization
It's a radical approach to leave WHO and cut its funding, as well as halting foreign aid overnight. The Trump administration is endangering the lives of many of the poorest people around the globe.
Without health communities, we do not prosper socially and economically. Without health, the world is less secure as the rising number of outbreaks are clearly documented.
The World Bank has warned that without health investments many developing countries will face serious setbacks in human capital development, poverty reduction, and economic growth. Instability and radicalism will increase.
The weakening of the informal sector and the care economy dependent on women contributes significantly to such a breakdown, as programs to support women's health and rights are stopped.
The argument that the U.S. carries an unfair burden does not hold: the United States is the largest donor but a small contributor of aid relative to GNI—0.18 percent—the U.S. is not being exploited by the rest of the world—Germany for example pays 0.6 percent GNI.
As the U.S. reduces its contributions, it also loses influence in international organizations and in countries. A new global health order will emerge, with BRICS countries stepping up and reaping the economic benefits of their health investments in poorer countries. In doing so, they are also filling the political vacuum that the U.S. leaves and will set the global health agenda.
Ilona Kickbusch, Founder and Chair, Global Health Centre, Geneva Graduate Institute.
From Professor Suerie Moon: The U.S. World Health Organization Withdrawal Is Motivated By Ideological Spite
The Trump Administration decision to withdraw from WHO will put people's health at greater risk in the U.S. and worldwide. The WHO withdrawal appears to be motivated more by ideological spite than a bona fide concern about reforming the organization.
It also seems to be just the tip of the iceberg. In the past few days we've seen vicious and draconian orders to immediately halt U.S.-supported global health programs, such as interrupting treatment for HIV, which must often be taken every day to remain effective.
Ralph Waldo Emerson once said, "the first wealth is health"—without a minimum level of health, children can't learn, workers can't work, economic growth suffers. For the lowest-income countries that rely on foreign assistance for roughly one-third of their total health spending, the sudden nature of these funding cuts will be devastating.
A big chunk of U.S. funding to WHO is actually channeled to sub-Saharan Africa and the Middle East, it doesn't only go to headquarters in Geneva—cuts in these funds will curtail essential WHO support to countries that bear some of the heaviest burdens of disease worldwide. It is morally indefensible.
Suerie Moon, Co-Director, Global Health Centre, Professor of Practice, Interdisciplinary Programs and International Relations/Political Science, Geneva Graduate Institute.
From David P. Fidler: U.S. Exit Weakens WHO But Has Little Global Economic Impact
The U.S. withdrawal hurts WHO's ability to carry out its functions because the U.S. has been the largest source of its resources. However, in global economic terms, WHO's budget—$6.8 billion for 2024-2025—is insignificant.
The U.S. has spent much more on global health outside WHO—including through PEPFAR, the President's Malaria Initiative, the Global Fund, the Pandemic Fund, and climate change projects.
What the Trump administration does with such U.S. global health assistance is more important for global health funding and its economic impact. Further, core engines of global economic growth—the U.S., China, the EU, and G7 members—are not dependent on WHO funds or expertise.
Low-income countries that rely on WHO could experience some adverse economic and fiscal consequences from working with a weakened WHO—e.g., increasing domestic spending to make up for less from WHO. But, even there, low-income countries seeking economic growth are focused on infrastructure, trade, and other drivers of growth because WHO funding is not large enough to fuel economic expansion, particularly in countries with increasing populations.
David P. Fidler, Senior Fellow for Global Health, Council on Foreign Relations, Washington, DC.
From Professor Lawrence Gostin: Leaving The World Health Organization Will Hinder The U.S. Medically and Scientifically
President Trump's withdrawal from the WHO will have major repercussions throughout the world. It will harm public health even more in the United States. The U.S. currently provides about 20 percent of all WHO funding. The loss of that funding will affect all of WHO's major program areas including AIDS, TB and malaria, polio eradication, and responding to health emergencies.
Beyond funding, the U.S. has been the most influential member of WHO. It will impact major global norms such as the International Health Regulations and the Pandemic Agreement currently under negotiation in Geneva.
The White House has already said it was pulling out of both treaties, the IHR and Pandemic Agreement. The U.S. will also have reduced access to scientific information that is needed for outbreak control and developing effective vaccines and treatments.
Lawrence Gostin, Distinguished University Professor, Founding O'Neill Chair in Global Health Law, Co-Faculty Director, O'Neill Institute, Director, WHO Collaborating Center on Global Health Law, Georgetown Law.
From Professor David Heymann: U.S. WHO Exit Could Risk Health Security, Funding Gaps, and Loss of Global Influence
The U.S. provides technical and financial support to WHO programs like polio eradication and influenza, crucial for its own health security. Germany and the U.K. might fill the funding void, but gaps in global health intelligence and rapid risk assessment could arise.
U.S. government experts would lose influence in WHO governing bodies, though academic institutions may continue advisory roles. Over 75 WHO collaborating centers, mostly in academia, could face U.S. funding cuts.
WHO reform may focus more on regional offices like PAHO and Africa CDC. The Gates Foundation and NGOs may need to step up polio eradication funding. U.S. health networks outside WHO will become even more critical for global health security.
David Heymann, Professor of Infectious Disease Epidemiology at LSHTM, Distinguished Fellow, Centre of Universal Health, Chatham House, London.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines