
...

By Shane Croucher
Senior Editor
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
Along southern English coastlines, and plonked across fields inland, are “pillboxes,” the nickname for aging little concrete bunkers with machine-gun slits.
Today, you’re likely to find curious children or, in less salubrious areas, drunken vagrants poking about these largely forgotten structures. But more than eight decades ago, they were the last line of defense against the dreaded fate of “speaking German.”
Fortunately, it didn’t come to that. There was no Nazi invasion of mainland Britain, the Germans largely deterred by the Royal Air Force and Royal Navy in the vital summer and fall of 1940. Those pillboxes stayed empty and silent.
Read More on Analysis
Someone who has become empty, though certainly not silent, is Tucker Carlson.
In an episode of his show released October 2, the conservative commentator-turned-provocateur put an astonishing question to Sir Jacob Rees-Mogg: How is Britain better off for having fought, and helped defeat, Adolf Hitler and the Nazis?
“Well, otherwise we'd be speaking German,” replied Rees-Mogg, the former British Conservative lawmaker, whose quasi-aristocratic style is about a century too late.
“Who cares?” Carlson glibly retorted. “There are a lot of people in Britain who can't speak English. So it would be nice to have, like, at least a European language spoken in your country.”
Coming from an American, that shrug turns a familiar taunt on its head—and it makes sense only if you forget what “speaking German” really meant.
Good Versus Evil
Carlson’s point, such as it was: “If a war is fought with the children of your citizens, which it is, then that war should benefit those citizens.”
The core of Carlson’s argument is that both the loss of the empire and Britain’s grim modern decline are consequences of fighting the war against Hitler, and that the war therefore wasn’t worth it.
There are many holes into which this argument falls and dies.
As Rees-Mogg put it, the war was “classic good versus evil.” Hitler posed an existential threat to Britain itself, and to most nations across the European continent. War was unavoidable.
Related Story

Is This Putin’s Chernobyl Crisis?
Moreover, Britain, problems aplenty, is not in quite as bad a state as many Americans tend to believe.
Nor is it an Islamic emirate, or a caliphate, or some other variation of this strange belief—one JD Vance, now vice president, aired in 2024 when he joked that Labour-run Britain might be the first “truly Islamist” country to get a nuclear weapon.
And contrary to Carlson’s claim, fewer than 2 percent of residents of England and Wales told the 2021 census they couldn’t speak English well or at all.
You'd All Be Speaking German
But let’s return to Carlson’s indifference to the notion that Britain would be “speaking German” if it hadn’t defeated Hitler alongside the Allies. Because it inverts the usual pattern.
Traditionally, Americans have deployed the “speaking German” line as an insult to ungrateful Europeans. Were it not for the belated entry of the U.S. into the war, the Nazis would still rule Europe, goes the thinking.
Of course, the economic and military might of the U.S. played a huge and pivotal role in the outcome of the war.
But so did the Soviet Union, for the sheer, brutal scale of the Red Army’s sacrifice against the Nazis on the frozen Eastern Front.
And little old Britain, too, with the help of its vast, decaying empire. For a year after the fall of France, Britain and its empire, helped by exiled Polish and Czech pilots, were the only major power still fighting Hitler's Nazi menace.
These facts often get lost in the all-American myth. Back in January, President Donald Trump reached for the more familiar version, as he had done before, when addressing the World Economic Forum in Davos.
Related Story

Putin’s Russia Needs a Carrot as Big as the Stick
Trump said of World War II that “we won it big,” the “we” referring to the U.S. rather than the collective Allied effort, adding: “Without us, right now, you'd all be speaking German and a little Japanese, perhaps.”
He was only saying what many Americans feel. And it’s not a new sentiment.
Nearly 40 years before Trump, Otto West delivered the memorable line to Wendy, an Englishwoman, in A Fish Called Wanda: “If it wasn't for us, you'd all be speaking German!” A movie, funnily enough, written by a British comic.
In September 2003, six months after the invasion of Iraq, President George W. Bush's former White House economic adviser, Larry Lindsey, took aim at France and Germany for freeloading on the cost of deposing Saddam Hussein and rebuilding Iraq.
“Without America, the French would be speaking German and the Germans would be speaking Russian,” Lindsey wrote. “Europeans never have repaid us for our efforts on their behalf during the 20th century.”
He conceded, though, that America’s involvement had served its own interests.
One can’t help but hear the echo in Trump’s berating of European NATO allies for declining to help in the Iran war.
Taken seriously, Carlson’s shrug tears up the moral (and, to be true, financial) bill America keeps presenting to Europe over WWII.
Hitler's Plans for Britain
If “speaking German” would have been no great hardship, then America saved Europe from nothing much, and Europe owes it nothing. His indifference diminishes America’s victory as much as Britain’s and the other Allies.
But the thing about every such use of “speaking German” is that it was based on a shared understanding of the euphemism, and an agreement that it was, indeed, the worst outcome possible.
This is shorthand, and it has nothing to do with language. The subtext is, of course, the horrors of Nazi rule. And boy, did Hitler have plans for occupied Britain.
Related Story

Germany’s Weimar Lights Are Flashing
The Einsatzgruppen, Hitler's SS death squads, were primed to sweep through Britain with a list of more than 2,300 people marked for immediate arrest—politicians, Jews, leftists, intellectuals, writers, and anyone else deemed undesirable or hostile to the Nazis.
Massacres were inevitable. In Poland the year before, Einsatzgruppen and their accomplices had shot thousands of Jews and tens of thousands of members of the Polish elite.
And when Nazi officials met at Wannsee in January 1942 to coordinate the “Final Solution,” their tally of Jews to be targeted included 330,000 in England.
British men, too, were to be sent en masse—every able-bodied male aged 17 to 45—into slave labor on the continent, as their homeland became yet another playground for Nazi elites.
We Already Do
A tyrannical puppet state. That’s what “speaking German” would have meant.
Is that, and all that would unfold in the decades after—a permanent Nazi dystopia, a civil war, God knows what else—preferable to where modern Britain has arrived today? For all Britain’s travails and shortcomings, it’s perverse to even ask.
Britons still speak English, which may surprise Carlson, thanks in no small part to the defeat of Hitler, itself thanks in no small part to American sacrifice.
But let him be reassured, at least, by a simple linguistic truth: that’s kind of speaking German too.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines