10

Loading video...

Arick Wierson

By Arick Wierson

Six-Time Emmy Award-Winning Television Producer

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


If you're trying to make economic sense of President Donald Trump's latest threat to slap a 50 percent tariff on Brazilian imports, don't bother.

The math doesn't add up. No matter how you spin it, you can't shoehorn economic rationale into what is, at its core, a political favor—a desperate attempt to bail out an embattled ally.

By any traditional economic measure, the case for more tariffs on Brazil doesn't exist. In 2024, the U.S. ran a $7.4 billion trade surplus—exporting more than it imported. And this isn't a fluke: over the past 15 years, the U.S. has run a trade surplus with Brazil totaling $410 billion.

Read More on Opinion

But even Trump isn't really pretending this new wave of threats has anything to do with trade imbalances.

President Donald Trump

...

His justification instead centers on Brazil's treatment of former President Jair Bolsonaro, who is currently facing criminal charges for allegedly orchestrating a coup attempt and refusing to concede the 2022 election. In a letter to Brazilian President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva, Trump called the prosecution an "international disgrace," suggesting it infringed on "Free Elections" and even, quizzically, on the "Free Speech Rights of Americans."

This isn't foreign policy—it's personal politics. Bolsonaro has been one of Trump's most loyal international allies—and now he's cashing in. Trump isn't leveraging U.S. trade power to serve national interests; he's weaponizing it to shield a political partner facing charges that uncannily mirror his own.

Some on Brazil's far right are trying to cast Trump's move as part of a broader ideological struggle—a rallying cry for a transnational conservative movement under siege. But even that narrative rings hollow. By tethering Brazil's political future to Bolsonaro's legal fate, Trump isn't advancing the global conservative movement—he's holding it hostage. As long as the Brazilian right clings to the fantasy of Bolsonaro's return, it can't move forward or produce a viable successor in the nation's forthcoming 2026 elections.

There's one place in Brazil that paradoxically sits on both sides of this issue: the state of Roraima. It delivered nearly 70 percent of its vote to Bolsonaro in the first round of the 2022 presidential election—the strongest support of any state—and it's also the fastest-growing, thanks to a booming agricultural sector. That makes it both a Bolsonaro stronghold, and paradoxically, one of the most vulnerable to economic fallout from Trump's tariff threat.

I spoke with Governor Antonio ("Denarium") Oliverio García de Almeida, a staunch Bolsonaro ally who nonetheless warned of broader economic risks.

"Roraima is somewhat insulated," he told Newsweek, "but the impact on steel, meat, and other key exports will ripple throughout the entire Brazilian economy." He pointed to Embraer, Brazil's aerospace giant and one of its biggest exporters to the U.S. with roughly 60 percent of its revenue tied directly to North American sales. Denarium urged President Lula to pursue diplomacy, emphasizing, "Brazil and the U.S. are natural allies. ... Diplomatic channels are key to solving this."

There's also a hidden cost for U.S. supply chains. Many semi-finished goods—steel, aluminum, aerospace components—are processed in Brazil before returning to American factories. Geraldo Alckmin, Brazil's vice president and trade minister, warned this would "backfire on the U.S. economy."

It's clear that Brazil isn't going to quietly stand by. President Lula has pledged retaliation under Brazil's reciprocity law and reaffirmed the independence of the country's judicial system. Aside from the most ardent Bolsonaro loyalists, Brazilians—regardless of ideology—don't take kindly to foreign leaders telling them how to run their democracy.

If anything, Trump's move may end up having the opposite of its intended effect: rallying Brazilians around the flag—even those who usually oppose Lula—simply out of national pride. And if Lula can channel that moment, what started as a threat could turn into a political gift.

And if this were really about advancing a global conservative agenda, propping up a former president whose fate is all but sealed does little to help the cause. In fact, it does the opposite—stalling the emergence of viable right-wing leadership in Brazil and turning a broader movement into a personal crusade. Trump isn't furthering conservative values; he's settling scores. And in the end, it's not him or Bolsonaro who will pay the price—it's ordinary consumers on both sides of the border.

It's a political gesture disguised as trade policy—but the consequences are real. Perhaps it's time to call Trump's latest move by what it really is: a "Big Beautiful Breakfast Tax." Trump's tariff stunt may rile up the MAGA base and win cheers from Bolsonaro loyalists, but it's American consumers who will end up getting stuck with the bill. Brazil supplies 35 percent of U.S. unroasted coffee and more than half of all orange juice. So, while Trump plays global politics to defend a foreign ally, our morning routines are all about to get a lot more expensive—one breakfast at a time.

Arick Wierson is a six-time Emmy Award-winning television producer and served as a senior media and political adviser to former New York City Mayor Michael Bloomberg. He advises corporate clients on communications strategies in the United States, Africa, and Latin America.

The views expressed in this article are the writer's own.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines