10

Loading video...

Rich Percival

By Rich Percival

Associate News Editor

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


President Donald Trump's ambassador to Canada is facing renewed demands for his expulsion after more than 285,000 Canadians signed a petition accusing him of political interference and undermining the country's sovereignty.

The petition, sponsored by former Green Party leader Elizabeth May, closed on November 18 and urges Prime Minister Mark Carney's government to declare Pete Hoekstra persona non grata over his comments about Canada becoming America's 51st state and alleged U.S. contacts with Alberta separatists.

May told Newsweek that she considered Hoekstra unfit for his diplomatic role and suggested he may be deliberately damaging relations between the two countries.

Read More on News

"My experience of this US Ambassador is that he is unfit for the mandate he holds, which is to be the best possible bridge builder between the President he serves and the country where he is placed," the Canadian lawmaker for Saanich-Gulf Islands in British Columbia said.

"Sadly, I think he may be doing the job the current President wants him to do - to be rude to his hosts and blow up bridges."

However, an MP sponsoring the petition does not mean she supported its demand to expel Hoekstra.

Sponsor Doesn't Mean Support

Under Canada's parliamentary petition tradition, MPs act as intermediaries for petitioners and can sponsor petitions without endorsing their contents. Parliamentary rules also prevent MPs from debating a petition's merits when presenting it in the House of Commons.

Speaking in August on Montreal Now, she explained that she was not "behind the petition" and could not say whether she supported or opposed it. She described her role as giving Canadians a parliamentary voice, regardless of her personal position.

But continuing to Newsweek, she said: "Generally speaking, Canadians love our neighbours to the South. That 285,580 Canadians think Pete Hoekstra should be sent packing does send a message."

May contrasted Hoekstra with David Wilkins, who served as President George W. Bush's ambassador to Canada from 2005 to 2009.

Former Green Party Leader Elizabeth May has sponsored the petition, which has almost 300,000 signatures.

...

"Like Mr Trump, former President George W Bush was not popular with most Canadians, but his Ambassador, South Carolinian Republican David Wilkins was so charming and disarming that he won accolades everywhere he went in Canada," she said.

"We look forward to the day a US Ambassador can be cheered for saying 'bonjour y'all' once again!"

But Carney has previously rejected calls to remove the ambassador, saying Canada must maintain diplomatic relations with Washington despite tensions over Trump's tariffs and annexation rhetoric.

Asked in June whether Hoekstra should be expelled after sharing another Trump post referring to Canada as the 51st state, Carney replied: "The short answer is no, to the second part of your question."

"It's an administration that we have to work with," he said, citing the countries' extensive trade and security ties. "We take the administration as it is."

The petition, launched in July by Calgary resident Leanne Walker, accuses Hoekstra of describing Canada's 2025 federal election as "anti-American" and calling Trump's 51st-state remarks a "term of endearment."

It also raises concerns about a Michigan-based voter identification application reportedly used by Alberta separatists and three meetings between members of the Alberta Prosperity Project and U.S. State Department officials from April 2025 to January 2026.

Hoekstra has denied knowing about the application's use or the meetings, according to the petition. The allegations have not been established as diplomatic misconduct.

Breakdown of Support

The campaign attracted more than 123,000 signatures from Ontario, 57,000 from British Columbia and 31,000 from Alberta, where separatist activists have been campaigning for independence from Canada.

Hoekstra, a former Republican congressman from Michigan who previously served as Trump's ambassador to the Netherlands, has dismissed previous demands for his removal.

"As long as the president of the United States thinks I'm doing a good job, I'll be here," he said in August, when the petition had attracted more than 225,000 signatures.

Addressing criticism of his connections to Republican operatives reportedly involved with Alberta separatists, Hoekstra said some had previously worked on his political campaigns.

"We're all conservatives, but you know, in Canada, that is now a cause why someone cannot represent a foreign country," he said.

He also defended sharing Trump's social media posts, saying his responsibility was to explain the president's thinking to Canadians.

Pete Hoekstra has served as U.S. ambassador to Canada since last year.

...

"I'm trying to tell Canadians and give them an insight into exactly what the president of the United States thinks," he said.

Newsweek has approached the U.S. State Department and Global Affairs Canada for comment following the petition's closure.

Despite attracting more than a quarter of a million signatures, the petition cannot force Hoekstra's removal or require an investigation into the allegations.

Under Canada's parliamentary rules, May can formally present it to the House of Commons. Once presented, the Canadian government must provide a written response within 45 calendar days, subject to parliamentary procedures.

The Canadian government is not obliged to accept its demands.

Who Decides About Persona Non Grata?

Canada can declare a foreign ambassador persona non grata under the Vienna Convention on Diplomatic Relations without having to explain its decision.

Washington would then be required to recall Hoekstra or terminate his diplomatic functions.

Canada has previously taken such action against diplomats accused of interference.

In May 2023, Ottawa expelled Chinese diplomat Zhao Wei following allegations that he had targeted Conservative lawmaker Michael Chong and his family.

In October 2024, Canada ordered six Indian diplomats and consular officials to leave after police alleged links between agents of the Indian government and a campaign of violence targeting people in Canada.

Then-Canadian Foreign Minister Mélanie Joly said the decision followed evidence gathered by the Royal Canadian Mounted Police. India rejected Canada's allegations.

Meanwhile, expelling Hoekstra could risk a significant diplomatic confrontation while Carney attempts to negotiate a trade agreement with Washington.

The Canadian Prime Minister has previously said Canada would not respond to every provocative statement from Trump, whose social media activity has repeatedly complicated relations between the two countries.

"We're not going to respond or react to everything," Carney said in June.

Newsweek’s reporters and editors used Martyn, our AI assistant, to produce this story. Learn more about Martyn here. Contact Newsweek editors on this story: Edward T. Cummins

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines