How Student Loans Could Change Under Trump

...

Aliss Higham

By Aliss Higham

Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


Higher education experts have warned that President Donald Trump's plans to reduce student loan repayment options from borrowers could thwart "ambition and innovation."

In an effort to streamline student loan repayment, the Trump administration is considering a sweeping overhaul of its federal student loan programs, cutting back multiple income-driven repayment (IDR) options to just two. The plans were put forward in the GOP's One Big Beautiful Bill Act, which was passed by the House of Representatives on Thursday.

Currently, the federal student loan system offers several IDR plans that adjust monthly payments based on income and family size, which can offer relief for low-income borrowers, freelancers, and those in unpredictable job sectors. Under the proposed budget plan passed by the House, these options would be reduced to just two repayment structures: a standard 10-year plan and a "Repayment Assistance Plan."

Read More on News

Higher education experts and borrower advocates warn that the move may increase repayment costs, sacrifice flexibility and put vulnerable borrowers at greater risk.

"Consolidating repayment options into two streamlined plans may sound like simplification, but it could be a double-edged sword," Dr. Shaan Patel, CEO and founder of the standardized test prep and college admissions company Prep Expert, told Newsweek. "The current menu of repayment plans—while admittedly confusing—allows borrowers to match repayment to their financial circumstances."

How Student Loans Could Change Under Trump

...

Student Borrower Protection Center has estimated that the new proposed repayment plan would increase payments by $2,928 a year for a typical student loan borrower enrolled in former President Joe Biden's Saving on a Valuable Education (SAVE) plan, if it is not blocked by the courts.

There is fear this reduced menu of options will also disproportionately impact borrowers whose financial lives don't fit neatly into a predictable mold.

"Many borrowers—particularly first-generation graduates, freelancers, or those entering volatile industries—depend on flexible, income-based options to stay afloat," Patel said. "If not, we'll see higher delinquency and default rates—especially among the borrowers this reform is supposedly meant to help."

Proponents argue that the simplified structure will reduce confusion that often leaves borrowers stuck in punishing repayment plans or facing unexpected interest growth. However, experts say the real issue isn't the number of choices—it's a lack of education about those choices.

"Confusion is a solvable problem with better education and outreach—not fewer choices. Imagine if we tried to fix the complexity of health insurance by only offering two plans. The outcome wouldn't be clarity—it'd be rigidity," Patel said.

The changes could also impact what future would-be students would pursue in higher education, Patel explained.

"Roughly 70 percent of federal borrowers rely on IDRs, especially early in their careers. These are often teachers, social workers, or entrepreneurs—people whose incomes are inconsistent but whose degrees provide immense long-term value," Patel explained. "If the new repayment model doesn't flex with income volatility, we risk punishing ambition and innovation in favor of uniformity."

"I would imagine that the new repayment plans would cover the vast majority of borrower situations," Jack Wang, host of the Smart College Buyer podcast, told Newsweek. "But I think the new rules will impact career choices, such as those entering the arts or fields that tend to have lower starting pay but yet require advanced degrees."

"If the proposed changes go through, my opinion is that higher education will be similar to what it was decades ago—only the kids from rich families can go to college," he continued. "And only those rich kids can go to medical, law, dental, vet school. It's kind of bleak."

The proposed changes are part of a broader budget bill that includes substantial cuts to federal student aid, including the elimination of loan forgiveness options after 20 or 25 years under current IDR plans. The bill also aims to repeal the SAVE plan, one of the Biden administration's centerpiece reforms, which reduced monthly payments for low-income borrowers and shortened the forgiveness timeline for smaller loan balances.

While the bill has passed in the House, it faces an uncertain future in the Senate, where it is expected to encounter stronger opposition.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines