Donald Trump

...

Tom Norton

By Tom Norton

Fact Check Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


President Donald Trump used his pre-Superbowl interview to blame foreign nations for America's $36 trillion debt, claiming other countries had taken advantage of the U.S.

Speaking to Fox News' Bret Baier, Trump mentioned Mexico and Canada, which he has held hostage to tariff demands since entering the White House.

"We're not that rich right now. We owe $36 trillion dollars. That's because we let all these nations take advantage of us," Trump said.

Read More on News

Donald Trump

...

"Same thing, like, $200 billion, with Canada, we owe $300 [billion]...we have a deficit with Mexico of $350 billion.

"I'm not going to do that. I'm not going to let that happen."

Earlier this month Canada and Mexico were granted a 30-day reprieve from Trump's 25 percent tariff threats, based on agreements to improve border security, ostensibly related to the import of fentanyl.

Trump did not explain during the Fox interview the relationship between the U.S. national debt and the actions of foreign nations.

Newsweek has contacted a White House media representative via email for comment.

What Has Caused the National Debt?

The national debt is simply how much the government has borrowed to cover its outstanding expenses over time. The debt is held in the form of treasury securities, a debt instrument historically considered safe. They maintain global liquidity and stability and are used widely as collateral in financial transactions.

Most of this is debt held by the public i.e. any person or entity not a U.S. federal government agency in the form of treasury.

The remainder is intragovernmental holdings, meaning debt owed by one part of the federal government to the other. For example, when federal programs such as Social Security or Medicare collect more revenue than they need in a year, they purchase U.S. debt securities, added to trusts used to pay benefits to those who use its programs.

Far from a system of exploitation, other nations buy securities to stabilize their currencies and invest as a "safe haven", given the unlikelihood of the U.S. defaulting on its debt.

Data from the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis shows more than $8.6 trillion of federal debt is held by foreign and international investors. As of November 2024, the three highest holders of U.S. treasury securities were Japan ($1.098 trillion), China ($768.6 billion), and the U.K. ($765.5 billion); the total owned by major foreign holders was $8.6 trillion.

The value of treasury securities sold to foreign nations has increased dramatically in the past 14 years, with around half their total value accumulated between 2010 and 2024.

Under President Trump's last administration, gross national debt rose by $7.8 trillion while foreign nations increased their securities by more than $1 trillion.

What Does This Have To Do With Canada and Mexico?

Trump mentioned sums tied to Canada and Mexico which do not correspond to the debt these countries own. The November 2024 Treasury data showed Canada and Mexico own $374 billion and $100 billion in treasury securities respectively.

Trump may have mixed or confused these figures with trade deficits, which is the difference in dollar amounts between exports and imports of goods and services.

Trump has argued international trade deficits, which collectively reached a record $1.2 trillion in 2024, show the U.S. has been exploited, motivating his desire to impose tariffs.

The U.S. Bureau of Economic Affairs reported that Canada and Mexico's annual trade deficits in 2024 were $63 billion and $171 billion respectively.

What Does This Have To Do With U.S. Debt?

This is not the first time Trump has connected U.S. debt and trade deficits. In 2017, he said: "The United States has trade deficits with many, many countries, and we cannot allow that to continue," adding, "For many, many years the United States has suffered through massive trade deficits; that's why we have $20 trillion in debt."

In response to this claim, the Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget wrote that while a higher budget deficit could, in theory, lead to an increase in foreign debt, adding to the trade deficit, the relationship was "weak." It included examples where budget and trade deficits have run in different directions.

"For instance, in the late 1990s the U.S. had budget surpluses, but still ran a trade deficit," it wrote in 2017.

"Of the 35 OECD countries, only 8 have both types of deficit. About half have a surplus in one and a deficit in the other. Japan, Canada, and Australia, for instance, have trade surpluses but budget deficits."

What Do Other Experts Say?

While some economists have argued that some countries have used unfair practices to exploit trade relationships, evidence that other nations have used the U.S. national debt exploitatively isn't clear.

Experts are not united in concern over the U.S. trade deficit. A 2019 analysis by nonpartisan think tank the Council on Foreign Relations, quoted several economists who said trade deficits may lead to financial bubbles, import-related job losses, or increase the transfer of wealth offshore.

Others claim it is a sign of economic strength, indicating an international desire to sell into America's economy and an abundance of U.S. income.

Speaking to Newsweek earlier this month, Robert Z. Lawrence, professor of International Trade and Investment at Harvard Kennedy School, said: "All a trade deficit tells us is what is the difference between what Americans are spending and what they are earning, i.e., how much they are borrowing from the rest of the world.

"If we are borrowing, it implies little about whether trade is fair or unfair or our tariffs are too high or low. As with all borrowing, the key question is, what are we doing with the money? If we are spending in a way that we will get richer and more able to repay, i.e., are investing more, it's a good thing."

"Higher imports could reflect stronger U.S. growth—a good thing," he added. "But if we are spending more than we tax and are running government deficits or using the borrowing to consume, we need to be more worried about how we can pay it back."

"Imposing tariffs without changing our spending patterns will have very little impact on the trade deficit, i.e., how much we borrow."

Trump's pledge to impose 25 percent duties on all steel and aluminum imports, has led to retaliatory warnings from other countries indicating early signs potential of an international tariff war with the U.S.

During his last presidency, Trump imposed industry-based tariffs including up to 50 percent on solar panels, 25 percent on steel, and 10 percent on aluminum. Despite this, as Newsweek has previously reported, the U.S. trade deficit between 2016 and 2020 grew by almost $200 billion.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines