10
Loading video...

By Daniel R. DePetris
Fellow, Defense Priorities
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
On January 22, the third day of the Trump administration's second term, President Donald Trump re-designated the Houthis a foreign terrorist organization, a label former President Joe Biden lifted during his tenure due to concerns about its humanitarian impact on the Yemeni population. The group, acting as the de-facto government in Yemen ever since it captured Sana'a, the capital, in 2014, has been menacing international shipping lanes in the Bab el-Mandeb and Red Sea since Israel began its retaliatory war against Hamas in Gaza in October 2023.
Trump's re-labeling was a prelude to a weeks-long air campaign against the Houthis, with U.S. strikes hitting the militia's military infrastructure nearly every day since mid-March. According to the Pentagon, the first round of U.S. strikes hit 30 targets in what U.S. defense officials say will be an unending war until the Houthis stop launching cruise missiles and attack drones into the region's waters. Trump hasn't been shy in elevating the campaign on social media; last weekend, the president posted a video, purportedly of several dozen Houthi militants assembling at an undisclosed location, getting hit by U.S. bombs.

...
Read More on Opinion
The war isn't letting up anytime soon. Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth ordered a second U.S. aircraft carrier to the Middle East, in addition to more fighter jets and another Terminal High-Altitude Missile Defense System. About a third of Washington's B-2 bomber fleet is now deployed to the Diego Garcia airbase in the Indian Ocean.
The Trump administration has taken pains to argue that the current air campaign is nothing like what Biden did in 2024, which National Security Adviser Mike Waltz categorized as "feckless attacks" that did little to defend freedom of navigation in the Red Sea or deter the Houthis from further belligerence. He's right in one respect—the strike packages the United States is working with today encompass a broader array of targets, including Houthi leadership, in areas like city neighborhoods that were once off-limits. Operationally speaking, there's no doubt Houthi leaders are looking over their heads and taking more precautious than were previously.
Trump's strategy, however, is pretty much identical to Biden's working around the same assumption—with enough military pressure, the United States can either degrade the Houthis' military capacity to a minor irritant or coerce the group into stopping the attacks altogether.
Yet that assumption was wrong before and continues to be wrong today.
First, the Houthi attacks are already a minor irritant. This might be a shocking thing to hear given the statements from U.S. officials, but it's true. While shipping traffic through the Red Sea is down compared to pre-October 2023, international carriers have long since adapted to the situation by using a longer alternative route around Africa. Worries that Houthi actions in the region will result in supply-chain bottlenecks, spiraling prices for consumers, or an increase in inflation haven't been proven true. Shippers are content with using the longer route even if it costs more, and many of them have simply protected their bottom-lines by charging more for the journey. In fact, the only country truly hurting is Egypt, which has seen revenue from transit fees through the Suez Canal decline by around $7 billion last year.
Second, the Houthis have demonstrated resiliency throughout its entire existence as an armed movement. In 2014, Saudi Arabia, the country with the largest defense budget in the Middle East, thought it would easily vanquish the Houthis from Sana'a after a few weeks. Yet eight years and tens of thousands of airstrikes later, the Saudis signed a ceasefire with the Houthis after the entire war became a public relations fiasco for the kingdom. Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman concluded the Houthis couldn't be pushed out of the capital by airpower alone. And the Saudis had no appetite to send tens of thousands of their own troops into Yemen to do the job, relying instead on militias that were often as interested in fighting each other as they are in fighting the Houthis. To think the U.S. can follow in Saudi Arabia's footsteps and achieve a different result is a bit like buying a Power Ball ticket after 20 straight losses and thinking you'll win the jackpot. It almost defies reason.
Finally, one needs to remember that the only time the Houthis have ceased fire was when Israel paused military operations in Gaza. The Yemeni group has tied its own actions in the Red Sea to what's happening in Gaza, and their message has been consistent throughout: We will stop sending missiles and drones off the Yemeni coast when Israel agrees to a permanent halt in hostilities against Hamas and withdraws its troops from the enclave. The cheapest and most efficient way to manage the Houthis, then, is to lean on Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu to follow through on what he agreed to do last January—trading an end of the conflict for the remaining hostages. Diplomacy is more likely to work than a war of attrition in the air.
Biden's policy on the Houthis was a failure. Trump's is at risk of meeting the same result.
Daniel R. DePetris is a fellow at Defense Priorities and a syndicated foreign affairs columnist at the Chicago Tribune*.*
The views expressed in this article are the writer's own.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines