Donald Trump

...

Kate Plummer

By Kate Plummer

Senior US News Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


President Donald Trump's intention to accept a $400 million plane as a gift from Qatar's royal family has met criticism from across the political spectrum and could end up in the Supreme Court, according to a former district attorney.

On Sunday, reports emerged that Trump was to accept the Boeing 747-8, which will be retrofitted with state-of-the-art security and communications to serve as Air Force One.

Qatari officials said the $400 million plane was being given by the Qatari Ministry of Defense to the Pentagon. However, Trump said the Boeing 747-8 jet will be used as the official presidential plane, and, according to multiple reports, after he leaves office, it will be transferred to the Trump Presidential Library Foundation.

Read More on U.S.

Trump called the gift "a great gesture."

"I appreciate it very much. I would never be one to turn down that kind of an offer," he added.

Donald Trump

...

But critics warned against accepting it, noting that Qatar has faced criticism for its human rights record. Others warned that the unprecedented foreign gift amounts to foreign influence and may require congressional approval.

Now, experts have suggested Trump could face legal challenges if he accepts the present, challenges that could even reach the Supreme Court.

Constitutional clause says Congress must consent

The legal concerns all stem from a clause in the constitution called the emoluments clause. This restricts receiving foreign gifts over corruption concerns.

This clause states: "And no Person holding any Office of Profit or Trust under them, shall, without the Consent of the Congress, accept of any present, Emolument, Office, or Title, of any kind whatever, from any King, Prince, or foreign State."

Because of these terms, Matthew Mangino, a former district attorney in Lawrence County, Pennsylvania told Newsweek the plane would be considered a gift and that the matter would lead to legal challenges that "will likely end up before the Supreme Court."

Cases reach the Supreme Court when lower federal court decisions are appealed. Trump is a litigious individual who has previously involved this court in challenges to his administration's agenda.

On Monday, he asked the Supreme Court for permission to deport a group of nearly 200 Venezuelan migrants being detained in Texas.

The Trump administration has also asked the Supreme Court to intervene on three consolidated cases that challenge Trump's executive order to end birthright citizenship for U.S.-born children of people in the country illegally.

If there are legal challenges to the plane, a similar escalation could take place.

'Gift breaks the law'

"This 'gift' is a clear violation of law," Mangino added. "The emoluments clause provides any gift from a King or Prince must be approved by Congress.

"Even though the Supreme Court expanded presidential immunity the President, at least for now, is not a King.

"This matter will be challenged if it moves forward, and will likely end up before the Supreme Court. The High Court will have an opportunity to reign in this President."

Richard Painter, a chief ethics lawyer under former President George W. Bush, said accepting the plane "could lead to a Congressional investigation."

"If Trump accepts the plane without consent of Congress this could lead to a Congressional investigation because it is illegal under the Emoluments Clause of the Constitution," he told Newsweek.

He added: "Also, there could be litigation at a later date. Surely a future administration could claim that the plane is the property of the U.S. government and should be handed over to the Department of Defense. That would mean a lawsuit against Trump's presidential library."

'Presidency could be undermined'

Engaging in multiple legal issues is costly and could serve as an unwelcome distraction to the Trump administration's policy agenda, undermining his presidency. The potential for legal action will weigh on his decision to accept the plane.

After all, judges have already blocked or suspended Trump policies including efforts to ban transgender people from the military, abolish the U.S. Agency for International Development (USAID) and to place restrictions on birthright citizenship.

Attorney Bradley P. Moss said that accepting the gift was "illegal."

"Let's be clear: it is illegal. Full stop," he told Newsweek. "The President cannot accept a personal gift from a foreign government. If the Qatari Government wants to donate a jet, it immediately becomes the property of the U.S. Government and remains that way after Mr. Trump leaves office, unless he agrees to personally reimburse the U.S. Government the full market value of the jet. Designating it for his 'presidential library' is not a special loophole to this constitutional limitation. And this is without even touching on the obvious national security risk of having a foreign jet used as Air Force One.

However, he said a private lawsuit would be "rather tricky" and noted that Trump faced other emoluments clause lawsuits during his fist term, none of which were fully resolved.

'Boeing could sue for breach of contract'

Nevertheless, he said a further legal issue could emerge with Boeing. Boeing was contracted to deliver a replacement for Air Force One in July 2018, with a deadline of last year. However, the company said it has experienced delays because of factors including the bankruptcy of a key supplier, staff turnover, and the COVID-19 pandemic.

Moss added that Boeing could sue the administration over breach of contract, in what would be a further potential legal headache for the President.

Despite the backlash, Trump has remained defensive, calling Democratic critics "world class losers" on social media, and comparing the gift to America receiving the Statue of Liberty.

Meanwhile, the White House said gifts would be accepted "in full compliance" with rules and that the administration "is committed to full transparency."

The jet is currently sitting at San Antonio International Airport, according to tracking data, as reported by NBC News.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines