Donald Trump

...

Tom Norton

By Tom Norton

Fact Check Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


President Donald Trump's 2024 campaign promise to bring down the price of groceries—rallying against the cost of living under former President Joe Biden—shows early signs of faltering thanks to one fragile staple: eggs.

Trump, buoyed by polling that showed greater public trust to handle the economy, regularly attacked Biden and former Vice President and Democratic nominee Kamala Harris over the cost of eggs, and he vowed to bring drown prices quickly.

Speaking to NBC's Meet the Press in December 2024, Trump said, "When you buy apples, when you buy bacon, when you buy eggs, they would double and triple the price over a short period of time, and I won an election based on that.

Read More on News

"We're going to bring those prices way down."

Donald Trump

...

The message broke through with Trump seemingly convincing voters he understood the perception if not the reality of price rises, undercutting the factual if more abstract evidence presented by Democrats that the U.S. economy was growing.

However, Trump's critics are now pointing to astonishing rises in the price of eggs as proof that the president may not be able to control costs.

Some have claimed that reducing the cost of groceries, or eggs more specifically, was a "Day One" pledge, referring to promises Trump said he would deliver on his first day in office. Some of these, like imposing 25 percent tariffs on Mexico and Canada, have not materialized.

On X, formerly Twitter, a post by user Alex Cole, viewed 106,000 times, wrote: "Donald Trump lied, he did not bring down the price of eggs on day one. It went up by almost 40%. It was much lower under Biden."

Newsweek could not find that Trump pledged to lower prices on day one in office; while Trump made commitments to lower prices, he hadn't tied it to a get-go guarantee, admitting before he was inaugurated it would be "hard" to lower prices.

Asked in Time's "2024 Person of the Year" interview whether his presidency would be a "failure" if he didn't bring down grocery costs, Trump replied: "I don't think so."

"Look, they got them up. I'd like to bring them down," he continued. "It's hard to bring things down once they're up. You know, it's very hard."

However, the Trump campaign would have had some information indicating promises about eggs could have been dangerous. The price has continued rising since October, with the national average in December hitting $4.14, the highest average since February 2023. It was reported earlier this month that the cost of eggs in California had jumped 70 percent, reaching $8.97 a dozen.

This has been driven by the spread of the H5N1 bird flu virus in poultry farms across the U.S. Updates from the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention virus tracker have detailed its spread since March 2024 when it was detected among goat kids in Minnesota that had shared the same pasture and water source as infected ducks and chickens.

That same month it was reported among dairy cows in Kansas and Texas. In April, the first cow-to-human spread of bird flu was reported; three more followed between April and July.

The U.S. Department of Agriculture has said some 20 million egg-laying hens have died, shortening direct consumer and food manufacturer supply and driving up prices.

"Commodity egg volume is likely to continue to decline four to five percent per year going forward and could level out at around 50 percent of the volume, down from 80 percent not too long ago," Tom Flocco, CEO at humane egg supplier Pete & Gerry's told Newsweek in January 2025, adding that "pasture-raised and free-range eggs are about the same price they were last year."

"The egg shortage is impacting far more than just the retail egg market. Manufacturers, restaurants, ingredient producers and companies that manufacture products that use, feature or contain eggs will be feeling the squeeze," he said.

"This issue can also expose some already big cracks in the fragile food supply chain."

Where Does This Leave Trump?

Experts have said fixing prices caused by bird flu will not happen overnight; flocks will require replenishment, with no timetable date to meet that goal.

As reported by Newsweek on Wednesday, a Chicago farm lost 3,000 of its hens to the disease this week alone.

The reality of a virus that will impact supply chains, farmers and manufacturers is an unwieldy opponent for any politicians to face, least of all one who has promised to lower grocery costs.

Trump's plans for lowering grocery costs are broad, relying on bringing energy prices down through domestic increases in fossil fuel extraction.

In the same Time magazine interview where he admitted how difficult it would be to bring down prices, Trump said: "I think that energy is going to bring them down. I think a better supply chain is going to bring them down.

"You know, the supply chain is still broken. It's broken."

The idea is not unsupported. In October 2024, the World Bank predicted that leaps in oil production would lead to a fall in petrol and food prices over the next two years, as reported by The Guardian.

However, that analysis was based on falling oil prices mitigated by increased production, falling demand in China and clean energy transitions. The latter of those Trump has stymied this week by ordering the suspension of new federal offshore wind leasing, favoring oil, gas and coal.

Other Trump policies such as plans to levy tariffs on Mexico, China and Canada could also counteract his strategy. The tariffs threaten to raise inflation by increasing the cost of imports, before costs caused by any retaliatory trade war that might result. Global economic and international crises impacting inflation and prices, such as the war in Ukraine, are matters that all leaders, not just Trump, will also struggle to shepherd.

It is too early to dismiss Trump's pledge. Commentary that he made an explicit "Day One" guarantee to bring down prices, despite seemingly no evidence of such, arguably sours thoughtful, apolitical scrutiny. However, instabilities beyond his complete control and new trade policies that could hamper price drops, suggest that Trump might still struggle to crack this election-winning promise.

Newsweek has contacted a Trump media representative via email for comment.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines