
...

By Shane Croucher
Senior Editor
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
President Donald Trump said he sees the ceasefire with Iran as "over," calling Tehran's leaders "scum" and "liars" after a series of attacks on ships passing through the Strait of Hormuz triggered waves of retaliatory strikes.
Trump's declaration leaves big questions about what happens next in a war that was supposed to be over, one that has shaken energy markets and sent global commodity prices spiraling, including oil, and threatened to envelop the entire Middle East in conflict.
Iran has also created fresh rifts between Trump and NATO allies over their reluctance to support the U.S.; divided his MAGA base, which is deeply skeptical of foreign adventurism; and threatened to derail Republican efforts to keep majority control of Congress by driving up the cost of living, especially gas prices.
Read More on Analysis
"To me, I think it's over. I don't want to deal with them anymore. They're scum," Trump replied when asked if the ceasefire and the memorandum of understanding that underpins it is dead at the NATO summit in Ankara. "They're sick people," Trump continued. "They're led by sick people, and they're vicious, violent people, and if they had a nuclear weapon they'd use it."
Trump said he would speak to his negotiators, who can continue talks, but it is a "waste of time" dealing with the Iranians.
Scenario 1: Limited War Returns First
The most obvious assumption is that the ceasefire ends and so the war resumes. But a more likely early phase is narrower.
U.S. and Iranian forces trade blows around shipping, bases and coastal military assets while each side tries to avoid the political cost of looking passive.
The latest escalation already fits that pattern. The U.S. strikes followed Iranian attacks on three commercial vessels near the Strait of Hormuz.
U.S. strikes hit Iranian air defense systems, port facilities, coastal surveillance systems and anti-ship missile and drone launch sites around Hormuz. Iran then launched missile and drone attacks on U.S. military facilities in Bahrain and Kuwait
That is dangerous, but it is also bounded, and the targets are limited to vessels, bases, launch sites, air defenses, and ports.
Washington can claim it is restoring deterrence, while Tehran can claim it answered force with force. And, crucially, both can keep some room for the next move.
The risk is that limited does not mean stable. Oil prices rose after the strikes, with Brent crude reported near $78 a barrel in early trading, up 6 percent and a sign of the return of market volatility from earlier in the war.
So the ceasefire breaks, both sides retaliate, and each says the other started it. The war returns, but first as a contest over deterrence at sea.
Scenario 2: The Breakdown Becomes Leverage for Another Deal
Another possibility is that Trump’s "over" does not kill diplomacy. In fact, it may become the pressure campaign diplomacy needs to meaningfully restart.
Trump’s statement was blunt, but he is allowing talks to continue despite his skepticism about negotiations.
If the president wanted to close every diplomatic channel, he could say so. Leaving negotiators room while declaring personal disgust is a familiar Trump posture: loud public rupture, quiet private optionality.
He has strong incentives for a renewed pause in the fighting, not least that the insecurity of shipping through the strait raises oil prices, causing political pain back home ahead of the midterms. More fighting also exposes U.S. forces to further attacks.
Iran has its own reasons to posture and bargain at the same time, the big carrot of much-needed economic relief dangling in front of its nose.
Tehran condemned the U.S. strikes as a violation of the agreement and responded militarily, but those moves do not preclude indirect talks. They may define the opening bid.
Iranian attacks on U.S. facilities make any new concession politically toxic in Washington. U.S. strikes make any Iranian concession politically toxic in Tehran.
Still, diplomacy often resumes because each side dislikes the alternative. The ceasefire may be dead as a document, but the bargain behind it—security at Hormuz in exchange for limits, relief or recognition—may survive as a necessity.
Scenario 3: A Wider Regional War Starts by Accident
The worst scenario is less a grand decision than a chain reaction.
A proxy attack hits the wrong target. A U.S. strike kills more people than expected. A ship is sunk instead of being damaged. A Gulf state demands protection. Israel acts on its own timeline, as it so often does.
And thus the region widens the war faster than Washington or Tehran can narrow it. The current map already contains too many entry points for fresh conflict.
Iran struck U.S. facilities in Bahrain and Kuwait, which will consider their own responses. Qatar angrily condemned an attack on a Qatari LNG tanker.
And NATO’s 2026 summit was taking place in Ankara, putting the crisis directly in front of U.S. allies as the strikes unfolded.
Allies may be tempted to repair relations with Trump and get behind him fully on Iran, focused especially on the safety of the strait, where disruption is hurting everyone.

...
The broader danger is command and control. Iran can influence its allied militant groups, but influence is not the same as a brake pedal stopping them from sparking something much bigger, especially with Israel.
The U.S. can strike Iranian targets, but it cannot guarantee every follow-on response stays proportional. Gulf states can host U.S. forces, but that makes them targets when Iran wants to answer Washington without striking the U.S. homeland.
This is the scenario markets, militaries, and diplomats fear most of all because it can start while leaders insist they are avoiding it.
Mercifully, an uncontrolled regional war is not yet underway. But the ingredients are all there, and the end of the ceasefire brings them closer together: maritime attacks, U.S. retaliation, Iranian strikes on U.S.-linked bases, Gulf-state exposure and a disputed ceasefire framework.
A wider war would become more likely if attacks spread beyond Hormuz and U.S. facilities, if Israel launches a major independent operation, or if a mass-casualty strike forces a response neither side can calibrate.
Scenario 4: Oil Markets Force a Faster Climbdown
The first outside pressure on diplomats may come from energy traders. Oil prices jumped immediately after Trump's comments.
The Strait of Hormuz is the reason this crisis travels so quickly around the world. The ceasefire framework centered partly on reopening and securing shipping through the waterway on which we all rely. Yet ships are still under attack in a dispute over control of the route.
Neither Washington nor Tehran wants to look conciliatory, but both face serious economic pressure to stop the spiral.
Trump can absorb hawkish applause more easily than he can a sustained oil shock that hits voters in the pocket.
Iran can claim defiance more easily than it can manage a prolonged squeeze on shipping, sanctions, and regional trade that empties its coffers and leaves it unable to fund salaries or subsidies.
This path would not look like peace. It would look like a grudging, deniable pause that included fewer strikes, more intermediaries, sharper public insults, and quiet efforts to restore passage through Hormuz.
In other words, markets could become the ceasefire’s substitute referee—and reset the game to where it was before.
Scenario 5: Trump Turns the Crisis Into an Alliance Test
As mentioned in scenario three, NATO allies may consider this an opportunity to reset relations with Trump over Iran.
Trump might force them to regardless, using the ceasefire’s collapse to really test who follows Washington, in NATO and beyond.
A renewed crisis with Iran lets Trump frame support for U.S. strikes as another loyalty test for allies, Gulf partners and domestic Republicans.
The military question becomes a political one: who backs Washington when deterrence is on the line?
This scenario may not produce the biggest war, but it could result in the biggest diplomatic split.
European governments may support maritime security while resisting open-ended escalation. Gulf states may want U.S. protection without becoming front-line targets. Republicans who support Trump’s pressure campaign may still divide over another Middle East war.
The ceasefire’s collapse would then become more than an Iran story. It would become a test of Trump’s second-term foreign policy: America First, but with everyone else asked to fall in line. Will they this time?
The Real Test: Control
Presidential language can change incentives, but it cannot, by itself, determine how this crisis ends.
The next phase will be decided by target selection, back-channel diplomacy, oil-market pressure, allied restraint, and whether Iran sees escalation as leverage or survival.
None of these five scenarios is mutually exclusive. The conflict could begin with limited strikes, trigger another diplomatic push, rattle global energy markets, and test Western alliances before either side decides whether to escalate further.
The ceasefire's collapse should be seen as a fork in the road, where tough choices will determine outcomes, rather than the start of a predetermined war.
Ceasefires rarely die all at once. They lose authority first, then credibility, then usefulness. Trump has declared this one over. The next few days will show whether that was the end of a pause—or the beginning of a more stable one.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines