Trump immigration legal challenges

...

Dan Gooding

By Dan Gooding

Associate News Editor

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


On Tuesday, a federal judge blocked the Trump administration's shutdown of the refugee program, the latest legal challenge to the president's sweeping immigration orders.

Advocacy groups like the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) and the International Refugee Assistance Project (IRAP) vowed to fight the promised changes from day one and, so far, at least three policies have been halted or paused completely, while exceptions have been granted elsewhere.

"I don't know that anybody could've anticipated 10 immigration executive orders in the first week of the Trump presidency," Kevin Johnson, professor at UC Davis School of Law, told Newsweek Wednesday. "I do think it's fair to say that the people in the Trump White House are much more prepared and organized than they appeared to be in the first term.

Read More on U.S.

"Different groups are jockeying for position, and I don't want to say it's a free-for-all, but it certainly is something of a legal gun fight."

Newsweek reached out to the White House for comment via email Wednesday morning.

Trump immigration legal challenges

...

Birthright Citizenship

The President's declaration to end birthright citizenship for children born in the United States to non-citizen parents was challenged almost immediately. Those in favor of the long-standing custom view Trump's move as unconstitutional, arguing the 14th Amendment protects the right.

Three lawsuits were filed:

Trump Birthright Ctizenship

...

"I think that one of the reasons were seeing so many of the birthright citizenship lawsuits is because it's very much low hanging fruit and it looks bad for the administration to have lost three times in three different courts across the country, including before a judge who was appointed by Ronald Reagan," Johnson said.

Status of Trump's birthright citizenship plan: Unenforceable, pending appeals by the administration. After the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals declined to lift the injunction, the stage has been set for a potential Supreme Court review.

Refugee Resettlement Program

Along with restrictions on asylum, Trump ordered the suspension of the Refugee Resettlement Program on January 20 for at least 90 days, while officials weighed the benefits of allowing refugees into the U.S.

A lawsuit in Seattle, Pacito v. Trump, was filed by the International Refugee Assistance Project (IRAP) on behalf of Church World Service (CWS), HIAS, Lutheran Community Services Northwest (LCSNW), and nine impacted individuals.

On Tuesday, a federal judge ruled that the order likely violates two immigration laws and the Fifth Amendment's due process clause.

Refugee Resettlement lawsuit

...

"The United States has resettled refugees under Congress's Refugee Act for nearly 50 years and communities across the country have welcomed and embraced them," Deepa Alagesan, Senior Supervising Attorney, Litigation with IRAP, said in a press release. "Last week alone, the Attorney General of Washington, along with 18 other state attorneys general, filed an amicus brief in support of our case, arguing among other things that refugees benefit their states.

"Today's message is clear: The actions of this government do not represent the will of Congress or, crucially, the will of the people."

Status of Trump's refugee program suspension: Inactive pending legal proceedings.

Asylum Ban at Southwest Border

US Mexico border

...

With the scrapping of the CBP One app, and the proclamation of an "invasion" at the U.S.-Mexico border, President Trump effectively ended what remained of asylum processing.

The move was challenged by the ACLU and multiple other advocacy groups, which argued that Trump was ignoring protections put in place by Congress for migrants.

Status of asylum ban: Active. Legal challenge in process.

Immigration Enforcement in Sensitive Locations

Two lawsuits were filed after the Trump administration said it would give Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agents more powers to enter schools, churches and other sensitive locations. The move sparked fear among immigrants without legal status, with reports of a drop in attendance at places of worship and schools as a result.

Five Quaker congregations from Maryland, Massachusetts, Pennsylvania and Virginia sued DHS and its secretary, Kristi Noem, on January 27, less than a week after the new policy was announced. A similar suit, from more than two dozen Christian and Jewish groups, was filed in Washington state.

ICE sensitive locations

...

On Monday, a judge issued a temporary injunction in the Maryland case, which only applies to the plaintiffs.

Christie Duncan-Tessmer, general secretary for Philadelphia Yearly Meeting, one of the plaintiffs, said in a statement to Newsweek: "Our country is strengthened by people of faith who love their neighbors, no exceptions. Today's ruling returns some of us to safely holding open the doors to houses of worship to all seekers, as our constitution guarantees. Philadelphia Yearly Meeting looks forward to the next step of removing the barrier of fear for all congregations."

Status of the DHS policy change on sensitive locations: Partially suspended, pending further legal proceedings.

Holding Deportees at Guantanamo Bay

At the end of January, Trump said ICE detention would be expanded with the creation of 30,000 beds at the U.S. military facility in Guantanamo Bay, Cuba. The first flights left the U.S. a few days later.

At least two lawsuits have been filed against the policy so far, with a court blocking the movement of three Venezuelans destined for removal on February 9. Another complaint, filed by the ACLU and others, accused the Trump administration of blocking deportees from access to legal counsel and contact with their families.

Between 170 and 200 people have been transferred to the site so far, the majority Venezuelan, with 177 since deported to their home country via Honduras. Around 17 new inmates were moved to the site on Sunday, the New York Times reported.

Along with legal challenges, logistical issues may affect the detention expansion, with CNN reporting that tents may not be used due to a lack of electricity or air conditioning.

Status of Guantanamo Bay ICE Detention: Active, with legal challenges pending.

Challenging Sanctuary Cities

Pam Bondi NY lawsuit

...

The Trump administration began with intentions to end sanctuary policies in cities, counties and states across the U.S.

So far, civil lawsuits have been filed by the DOJ against Illinois and Chicago, as well as New York state. The administration argues that the policies in these areas prevent ICE agents from effectively carrying out their work. The parties being challenged have all vowed to fight these suits.

Meanwhile, the cities of Chelsea and Somerville in Massachusetts have filed a lawsuit against the Trump administration, arguing that withholding funds for sanctuary cities is unconstitutional.

More legal challenges likely

As the administration's immigration orders keep coming, more challenges are likely to pile up in the coming weeks and months.

"We are filing lawsuits where we think the administration has overstepped its legal authority but will also be engaging in other advocacy because litigation cannot be the whole strategy," Lee Gelernt, ACLU lawyer who argued many of the highest profile cases during the first Trump administration, told Newsweek in a statement.

Johnson also said that he expects some more legislation to eventually be passed in Congress, where Republicans have the majority in both the House and the Senate.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines