
...

By Dan Gooding
Associate News Editor
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
President Donald Trump's plan to untangle the bureaucratic thicket of the EB-5 "investor's visa" and replace it with a "Gold Card" has the potential to work, but the cheaper existing program already struggles to attract applicants, experts have told Newsweek.
Trump's proposed $5 million Gold Card visa is designed to attract wealthy foreign investors to the U.S. with a pathway to citizenship, something the EB-5 does already with a lower investment minimum of $800,000.
However, with lengthy backlogs and uncertainty over whether applications will even be approved, the current system is failing to attract enough applicants as it is.
Read More on U.S.
"The difficulty is tying up a very significant amount of money for a very long time through this process and there's not a big rate of return on this investment and so there's hesitancy from investors in getting involved in this," David Bier, director of immigration studies at the Cato Institute, told Newsweek Friday.
"So, there's been some difficulty in getting investors into it when they know there's this cap and that's such a long process to get your money back. There's more investment opportunities right now than there are investors to fill those opportunities."

...
Details Unclear on Gold Card Program
Trump announced the Gold Card during a press conference in the Oval Office Tuesday, claiming it could attract millions of wealthy, talented people to the U.S. The president said the visas would be sold, which is not how current visa programs work.
With a timeline of around two weeks given by Trump and Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick on Tuesday to get the Gold Card up and running, details remained vague by the end of the week.
When Newsweek reached out to the United States Citizenship and Immigration Service (USCIS) for comment, as the agency which administers visa applications, it declined to offer more information and deferred to the White House, which is yet to comment.
One immigration attorney told Newsweek that replacing a visa marred with complaints of "fraud and delays" was necessary. Over 20,000 people were either waiting for their EB-5 application or green card to be approved at last count.
"This morning alone, I received about five calls and emails regarding what was out there about the gold card. Primarily those calls and emails came from investors, individuals that may have the money and are interested," Hector A. Chichoni, a partner at the law firm Greenspoon Marder in Florida, told Newsweek the morning after Trump's announcement.
Will the Gold Card 'Sell'?
Chichoni said he was skeptical whether companies would want to spend money on employees to get a Gold Card, as the president suggested, as there were already far cheaper options, including other EB categories and visas like the H1-B.
Bier also said investors may be put off by the Gold Card's proposed $5 million fee, which would go directly to the U.S. federal government with no obvious return aside from permanent residency. The current system involves some fees for USCIS, but the $800,000 to $1 million investment requirement is money applicants should see a return on.

...
"You're basically eliminating the vast majority of the current EB-5 participants from getting involved in this new program," he said. "I don't really see a large a huge demand for this."
During his announcement Tuesday, Trump said he believed he could "sell" anywhere between one and 10 million Gold Cards.
Andrew Arthur, from the non-partisan Center for Immigration Studies, told Newsweek that he would need more details from the Trump administration before being able to give a full assessment of the program, but said the current thresholds for investment under EB-5 could be pushed up.
"Once you quintuple those figures," he said of the $5 million fee, "it gives USCIS more money and resources to root out fraud and abuse."
USCIS is funded by the application fees and other costs it charges applicants, from those applying for temporary visas, Green Cards and citizenship. Its officers are then responsible for vetting applicants, who can be denied their visa and lose the money they spent.
It was not made clear if the Gold Card's fee would go into the agency, however, with Lutnick stating it would help offset the country's deficit. Bier said that if the Gold Card is implemented, but applications don't pour in, then provisions could be made for a sliding-scale of fees to generate the funds the government wants to see.
On the issue of vetting, which Trump said would be thorough, both Chichoni and Bier raised concerns about security and whether successful business people in countries the U.S. has strained relationships with, like China or Russia, would even want to apply.
"What I would like to get is clarity. We lawyers always thrive on clarity," the attorney said. "It seems like something interesting and new, but we would like to know what rules [are], how it's going to be governed. I think there will be opposition, it might be challenged in court."
The Gold Card would need to be passed via legislation in Congress that approves the change and create the new category.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines