

By Anna Rahmanan
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
In a Truth Social post, Donald Trump looked at French students protesting their schools and said he had identified the real subject—Islam “wanting to take over a once great Country.”
It is a brisk piece of criticism that couldn't fit the Trump brand more. The students are a few weeks into a nationwide movement over crowded classrooms, missing teachers and deteriorating school buildings. On Tuesday, more than 250,000 people rallied for education funding, according to French government figures. Trump’s post offers no evidence connecting the protests to Islam; it simply announces that the protesters are not protesting what they say they are protesting.
How Trumpian.
Read More on Analysis
France is a tempting setting for this kind of drama. Its arguments over Islam, immigration, secularism and national identity are very real and very old. A serious person can worry about Islamist extremism, or argue over how a secular republic should accommodate religious life, without believing that every Muslim is a threat. But Trump is Trump, and he has no time for that distinction. In his version, the plot is simpler. France is in trouble and Islam is to blame. Cue La Marseillaise, call out the gendarmes—the Republic is under siege.
The school protest makes an especially useful prop. The actual complaints—staff shortages, packed classrooms, poor facilities—are politically ordinary, which is to say, difficult to turn into a grand civilizational fable. “Islam is taking over” is more portable. It can travel from Paris to an American campaign rally without the inconvenience of explaining French education policy.
There is something distinctly French about villain of choice, too. The country has spent decades arguing over what the republic is, what it demands of its citizens and whether its promise of universal belonging survives contact with religious difference. Trump does not join that argument. He prefers to turn the protests into a morality play, with France as the fallen hero and Islam as the force advancing through the final act.
Related Story

The Hidden Irony of the Fairford B-1 Retreat
The post’s sleight of hand is not that it raises questions about Islam. Those questions exist and France should start attempting to answer them—perhaps with a little more rigor than Trump’s decision to use one event to answer them all, in unison.
France does have a real problem with political Islam and Islamist extremism. That is all the more reason not to pretend that one school protest proves Islam is taking over the country. If moving in that direction, then the school crisis becomes proof of cultural collapse, the students’ stated demands vanish, and Islam is made to explain the scene without being shown to have caused it. That may be more than we’re getting from the French government about its schools or the migration debate, but it is hardly an answer.
But this is less an analysis of France than a message to Americans.
Look what happens when a country lets Muslims in. The students asked for teachers; Trump told Americans to fear Islam.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines