
...
![]()
By Newsweek Editors
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
It was a slogan that shaped Donald Trump’s first campaign and a sentiment that drove some of the earliest actions of his second administration: Drain the swamp.
Trump built a movement by promising to expose corrupt elites and tame the deep state, Washington’s people-defying permanent government.
And to some extent, he has delivered on that promise, agitating standard D.C. business practices and upending federal bureaucracies.
Read More on Analysis
But after draining one swamp, Trump has set the conditions for another to ferment.
MAGA is starting to smell the mire’s stench again.
Draining the Swamp
The second Trump administration focused on draining the swamp right away.
DOGE, originally spearheaded by the frenetic billionaire Elon Musk, has said it has saved an estimated $215 billion by cutting waste and fraud in government spending.
It cut thousands from the federal workforce and shuttered USAID entirely.
The merits of all its cuts are hotly disputed, with some calling it excessive and putting people’s lives at risk.
Alongside cuts to things like “white privilege” training for teachers and money for a Colombian opera about a transgender woman were slashes to areas like HIV research.
But to the MAGA eye, DOGE slashed and burned the deep state bureaucracy and leeches who fed off it.
But the swamp drainage didn’t stop at DOGE.
The DOJ and FBI have purged swathes of officials tied to legal and investigative campaigns against Trump and his supporters, targeting those who MAGA says led politically-motivated witch hunts against them.
Similar activity is happening at the Pentagon, which has sought to root out dissenters, leakers, and anyone linked to liberal priorities like DEI.
Swamp Drained. Or Is It?
Purging a “deep state” bureaucracy is one thing. Building a trustworthy government in the eyes of MAGA is another.
The administration’s own rhetoric promised a leaner state that would work for citizens rather than insiders.
But a series of actions by the Trump administration has left MAGA smelling a familiar rot.
It started with the still unresolved debacle over the release of the Jeffrey Epstein files.
The Epstein fight touched the moral core of the Trump coalition, appearing to confirm all their worst fears about predatory elites and establishment cover-ups.
Yet, despite promising full exposure during the campaign, the Trump administration fumbled the files’ release.
It sparked confusion over a supposed “client list.” A minute was missing from the prison tape of Epstein’s cell at the time he killed himself.
There was a persistent lack of commitment to the exact timing of material releases.
Delays and uncertainty, broken promises, mixed messaging, and Trump’s reluctance to engage with the Epstein issue given his own connections to the late pedophile, led Congress to compel the Justice Department to publish them.
Still, it wasn’t enough. Deadlines were missed. Information was shoddily redacted.
Worse still, Trump’s name and photos appeared within the files, often in headline-grabbing circumstances.
It fueled the suspicion that the administration was blocking their release to protect him.
By April this year, the Justice Department watchdog was reviewing whether the department properly handled collection, redaction, and disclosure after complaints.
That whole sequence is politically lethal because it reverses Trump’s favorite posture.
The insurgent who accused others of hiding the truth now owns the machinery of concealment, disclosure, redaction, error, and blame.
Trump had trained his voters to treat opacity as proof of corruption. And now his administration was being opaque.
Iran, MAHA, and Marijuana
But the swamp isn’t only in the Epstein files.
Just look at Iran. Trump had explicitly railed against taking America into more wars.
A warmongering deep state was behind the forever wars of the past, and Trump was changing the game. No more neocon nightmares. This was all about America First.
Or so MAGA thought.
Now, the U.S. is at war with Iran, oil is over $100 a barrel, and Americans are paying for and dying in another Middle Eastern conflict with no clear end in sight.
It’s a foreign policy move that has divided MAGA, most dramatically seen in the attacks by Tucker Carlson on Trump for what’s going on with Iran.
Back home again, Trump has also dismayed his Make America Healthy Again supporters, or MAHA.
He cut across their agenda with an executive order pushing the use of agricultural chemicals that MAHA says are linked to cancers.
That may be defensible as agricultural realism, but it is not the clean-food revolt many MAHA voters thought they were buying with Trump.
It looked like another win for old-style swamp lobbying.
Trump’s move to reclassify marijuana in Schedule III risks the same MAGA whiplash, even though it keeps broader federal controls in place.
The policy can be defended as a pragmatic recognition of medical use, and it could reduce research barriers and allow cannabis businesses to claim tax deductions under federal rules.
It may also help win over some of the MAGA-adjacent podcast bros, like Joe Rogan.
But when Trump floated the idea in 2025, MAGA influencers were upset by a perceived softening on drugs, which is often viewed as a blight on American communities.
"America deserves better, our kids deserve better, I don't want to have to be smelling weed anytime I take my kids anywhere in a city or a national park," MAGA podcaster Jack Posobiec said at the time.
An America First coalition can absorb tactical disagreement and has done so many times.
But it cannot indefinitely reconcile anti-war populists, hawkish nationalists, health insurgents, agribusiness allies, drug-war conservatives, cannabis libertarians, and conspiracy-driven transparency absolutists.
MAGA Mire
The result is a MAGA mire. Or a swamp, if you will.
The old Washington swamp was supposed to be a place: agencies, lobbyists, lawyers, contractors, and career officials.
Trump’s new mire is a method. It treats loyalty as competence, disruption as proof of reform, and backlash as a substitute for accountability.
The White House can plausibly say it has reduced bureaucracy through DOGE, released millions of Epstein-related pages through DOJ, recognized medical cannabis through rescheduling, and acted against Iran in the name of national security.
Those aren’t imaginary accomplishments. Yet the test Trump set for himself was never mere activity.
It was whether he could make government less corrupt, less captured, and more legible to the citizens who distrusted it.
The Epstein audit, the MAHA pesticide retreat, the cannabis reversal, and the Iran rupture all point to the same verdict: Trump drained enough of the old swamp to expose its mud, then filled the basin with his own.
The next phase of his presidency will depend on whether his MAGA supporters decide that the mire was the plan all along.
Hey gang, Carlo Versano here. I hope you enjoyed this article. As Newsweek's Director of Politics and Culture and editor of the 1600 newsletter, I'm keen to hear what you think. Now, Newsweek is offering a new service to allow you to communicate directly with me in the form of a text message chat. You can sign up and get a direct line to me, as well as the reporters who work for me. You can shape our coverage.
As a Newsweek member, we're offering this service to you for free. You can sign up below, or read more about how it works here. Let's talk!
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines