10
Loading video...


By Steve Mollman and Dan Gooding
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
The Trump administration has halted construction activity tied to a controversial border-security project in Texas' Big Bend National Park after days of mounting criticism from environmental groups, tribal advocates, local residents and lawmakers.
U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP) Commissioner Rodney Scott announced Monday that all construction activity in the park would be paused while he conducts a personal review of the project and meets with local stakeholders.
"Last night, I put a pause on all activity in that park as far as construction goes until I can get down there and do a personal evaluation, talk to some stakeholders, talk to local law enforcement in that area," Scott said in a video posted to X. "More to follow this week."
Read More on News
Mike Davidson, who works as a tour guide in Big Bend, told Newsweek on Monday: "There's been very little opportunity for public input so this seems promising. But I am not holding my breath for any real changes. Meanwhile caravans of vehicles and machinery have been photographed en route to staging areas."
The decision follows growing controversy over work taking place inside one of America's most iconic national parks, where critics have warned that planned roads, barriers and surveillance infrastructure could damage sensitive desert landscapes, wildlife habitat and culturally significant sites.
"While the Big Bend business community welcomes any pause in construction, our region's entire tourism economy remains at risk until the project is cancelled outright," Sara Ryza, of the Big Bend Tourism Alliance, told Newsweek Monday.
"In addition to the destruction of our national park with bulldozed roads and planned vehicle barriers, even in the remotest stretches of the park headed toward Mariscal Mountain, there are camps in communities like Terlingua and just north of the park entrance. Who wants to vacation in a construction zone? And what will Big Bend National Park look like when they're done?"
Newsweek reached out on Monday to CBP.
Why It Matters
Big Bend spans more than 800,000 acres along the U.S.-Mexico border and is widely regarded as one of the country's most remote and ecologically significant protected areas.
The dispute has become a high-profile test of the Trump administration's effort to expand border-security infrastructure while facing opposition from conservation groups, tribal organizations, tourism advocates and some elected officials. The controversy has also drawn national attention after images of bulldozers and other heavy equipment operating inside the park circulated online and fueled concerns about the project's environmental impact.
The pause comes as tribal and environmental groups pursue legal action seeking to stop the work and as questions persist about how far the government intends to go with planned construction in the region.
Related Story

Texas Businesses Warn Trump’s Border Barriers Threaten Their ‘Livelihoods’
What Was Being Built?
The debate over Big Bend has often been described as a fight over President Donald Trump's border wall agenda, but administration officials maintain they are not building a traditional border wall through the national park.
In a statement provided to Newsweek last week, Scott said CBP was constructing "one new access road," improving existing roads, installing detection technology and placing vehicle barriers in strategic locations.
"We are not building a 30-foot wall or stadium lighting through Big Bend National Park, Big Bend Ranch State Park, or the Black Gap Wildlife Management Area," Scott said.
The commissioner argued that the improvements would help Border Patrol agents detect illegal crossings, respond more quickly in emergencies and secure a remote section of the southern border.
Federal officials have repeatedly said the work is part of a broader border-security strategy that extends well beyond the national park itself.
Bryan Devonshire, the owner and founder of Astro Mucho, a stargazing business in Terlingua, told *Newsweek, "*I feel like I just finished a round of non-consensual torture. I am grateful that the pain has stopped. I'm happy that the habitat gets to rest for at least one day and the native graves are stilled from the vibrations of heavy machinery."

...
Why Critics Are Alarmed
The Trump administration's assurances have not eased concerns among environmental groups and local advocates.
Opponents argue that even road construction and vehicle barriers could fundamentally alter portions of the park's landscape. Critics have pointed to Mariscal Mountain, a rugged limestone ridge overlooking the Rio Grande, as one of the most controversial elements of the project.
Earlier this month, the Center for Biological Diversity warned that road construction across the mountain could require extensive blasting because of the challenging terrain. The group described the work as a threat to one of Texas' most treasured natural areas.
Lawmakers have also raised questions about whether construction could damage sensitive ecosystems, archaeological resources and wildlife habitat.
Former Big Bend wildlife biologist Raymond Skiles said in a July Facebook post that Mariscal Canyon has hosted as many as three nesting pairs of peregrine falcons annually, describing it as "likely Texas' most densely populated Peregrine nesting area" and noting that the birds are highly sensitive to disturbance near their cliffside nesting sites.
The growing backlash has united an unusual coalition that includes environmental advocates, local tourism interests, former National Park Service officials, tribal groups and some Texas elected leaders.
Lawsuit Seeks to Stop Project
The controversy intensified Friday when The People of La Junta for Preservation, a nonprofit associated with members of the Lipan Apache community, and Far Flung Outdoor Center filed a federal lawsuit seeking to halt the project. The suit was also brought by Christina Hernandez, the preservation group's founder and director, and Andrew Austin, whom the complaint describes as a practitioner of Native religion and a lineal descendant of the Lipan Apache people.
The plaintiffs allege that planned construction involving roads, barriers, excavation, lighting, cameras, sensors and related infrastructure threatens archaeological resources, ancestral landscapes, traditional-use areas and places of cultural and potentially religious significance.

...
The complaint argues that damage to those resources could not be undone, stating that "once an archaeological site is excavated by heavy machinery, once the physical context of artifacts is destroyed, or once a sacred or culturally significant landscape is permanently altered, the injury is irreparable."
The lawsuit also alleges that the project could interfere with Indigenous religious practices tied to the Rio Grande and the broader Big Bend landscape, including prayer, gathering ceremonial materials, access to burial places and other traditional religious observances.
Far Flung, a Terlingua-based outdoor recreation business, alleges that roads, barriers, lighting and other infrastructure could impair the visitor experience and hurt tourism demand in a region that depends heavily on recreation and park visitation.
The legal challenge is the latest obstacle facing the border initiative and increases pressure on federal officials to provide more details about what they intend to build and where.
Border Security Versus Conservation
Supporters of the project say the enhancements are necessary because criminal organizations can shift routes and exploit vulnerable stretches of the border.
The administration has pointed to migrant encounters, drug seizures and other enforcement activity in the Big Bend Sector as justification for additional infrastructure. Scott has argued that securing the region is essential even if migration patterns change in the future.
Critics, however, note that unlawful crossings in the sector have fallen sharply during Trump's second term.
CBP data shows Border Patrol recorded 148 migrant encounters in the Big Bend Sector in June 2026, down from 412 in June 2023. During the first nine months of fiscal year 2026, authorities recorded 1,509 encounters compared with 10,291 during the same period in fiscal year 2023, an 85 percent decline.
Terrell County Sheriff Thaddeus Cleveland welcomed Scott's decision to visit the region, saying he had encouraged the commissioner to see the area firsthand for months because he believed the original proposal was flawed.
"I'm glad Commissioner Scott is finally coming out to the Big Bend," Cleveland told Newsweek on Monday. "I've been encouraging him to visit for months because I've believed from the first announcement that the original plan was flawed."
Cleveland, who said he previously worked with Scott as a Border Patrol agent and later served in Scott's office in Washington, D.C., praised the commissioner for scaling back what Cleveland described as an earlier proposal that would have placed a 30-foot barrier across the entire Big Bend Sector. He said Scott had told him he would personally evaluate areas around Big Bend National Park and Big Bend Ranch State Park before deciding how to proceed.

...
Still, Cleveland questioned the need for a road near Mariscal Canyon, arguing that the terrain itself makes the area an unlikely route for smuggling activity.
"I do not believe the road being constructed near Mariscal Canyon is warranted," Cleveland said. "This is a 1,500-foot vertical cliff above the Rio Grande River. This area isn't used by smugglers and if it was, we could certainly deploy technology on the ground and in the air to protect it."
He added that the road would be unlikely to see substantial use because of the area's remoteness and limited manpower assigned to the national park.
What Happens Next
Scott's announcement does not mean the project has been canceled. Instead, it signals that federal officials are temporarily stepping back while the CBP commissioner evaluates conditions on the ground and hears directly from local leaders, law enforcement officials and other stakeholders.
The commissioner indicated additional information could be released later this week following his visit.
For now, construction activity inside Big Bend National Park has been put on hold, leaving the future of one of the Trump administration's most closely watched border-security projects uncertain as legal, environmental and political questions continue to mount.
"I hope this is actually the beginning of communication with CBP. I hope that reason can find a way to permanently stop this destruction," Devonshire said. "But as long as the equipment and crews remain in Big Bend, I am bound in my dungeon, wondering when the pain will resume."
Contact Newsweek editors on this story: Edward T. Cummins.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines