10

Loading video...

Jesus Mesa

By Jesus Mesa

Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


Senator Flávio Bolsonaro, a close ally of President Donald Trump, finished ahead of President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva in Brazil's first-round presidential election Sunday, sending the race to an October 25 runoff after neither candidate secured the majority needed to win outright.

With 97 percent of ballots counted, Bolsonaro led with 47.45 percent of valid votes to Lula's 44.66 percent, according to Brazil's Superior Electoral Court, a result that defied most major polls that had projected the incumbent in first place.

Why the U.S. Is Watching Latin America's Biggest Prize

Brazil is Latin America's largest country and economy, and Sunday's vote has become the biggest test yet of Trump's effort to line up friendly governments across the hemisphere, following wins by Trump-endorsed candidates in Honduras last year and Colombia in June. The Trump administration has spent the past year pressuring Lula's government with tariffs, sanctions on a Supreme Court justice, terrorist designations for Brazil's largest gangs and a diplomatic standoff over visas.

Read More on World

A Bolsonaro win would bring Brazil into Trump's regional security coalition and mark the return of the Brazilian right less than four years after Jair Bolsonaro left office. Jair Bolsonaro is serving a 27-year sentence for plotting a coup after his 2022 loss to Lula and is barred from running.

Related Story

Why a Blood Feud Will Test Trump’s Donroe Doctrine

Why a Blood Feud Will Test Trump’s Donroe Doctrine

This combination of file pictures created on September 29 shows Brazil's President Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva at the Planalto Palace in Brasilia on September 8; and Brazil's senator and presidential candidate Flavio Bolsonaro in Rio de Janeiro on September 25. (Photo by Mauro PIMENTEL and Sergio LIMA / AFP via Getty Images)

...

How Polls Missed Bolsonaro's First-Round Lead

Most major polls published before Sunday's vote showed Lula finishing first, though generally short of the majority needed to avoid a runoff. Instead, Bolsonaro emerged with a lead of nearly three percentage points, echoing 2022 when his father, former President Jair Bolsonaro, significantly outperformed pre-election surveys.

Head-to-head, three of the four major polls had the race within the margin of error.

Datafolha, among Brazil's most closely watched pollsters, put Lula at 45 percent of valid votes to Bolsonaro's 42 percent in the first round. Its runoff numbers tightened to 47 percent to 46 percent, down from a three-point Lula edge in its previous survey. Datafolha interviewed 4,006 people on October 2 and 3, with a margin of error of 2 percentage points.

Quaest, surveying 3,702 people over the same two days, found the first round nearly level, with Lula at 46 percent and Bolsonaro at 45 percent, and gave Bolsonaro a 44 percent to 42 percent lead in a runoff. It was the only one of the four to show the senator ahead head-to-head.

AtlasIntel's final poll for Bloomberg, which surveyed 4,945 people from September 27 to October 2, had Lula at 47 percent to Bolsonaro's 44.1 percent in the first round. The runoff was a dead heat: 47.6 percent to 47.4 percent, well inside the poll's 1-point margin of error.

The CNT/MDA poll was the most favorable to the president, showing him at 47.8 percent to Bolsonaro's 42.1 percent in the first round and ahead 47.3 percent to 43.1 percent in a runoff. MDA surveyed 2,007 people from September 30 to October 2, with a margin of error of 2.2 points.

Writer and psychiatrist Augusto Cury, Renan Santos of the Missão party, former Goiás Governor Ronaldo Caiado and former Minas Gerais Governor Romeu Zema are each stuck in single digits, with Santos reaching as high as 4.6 percent in the AtlasIntel survey. How their voters break in a second round could decide the presidency.

Recent Datafolha surveys found roughly 46 percent of voters say they would never vote for Lula, and about the same share say so of Bolsonaro.

Some analysts warn that polls may again understate the right.

"In the 2022 election, Jair Bolsonaro, Flávio's father, outperformed the polls, the surveys by almost 10 percent," Christopher Sabatini, a senior fellow for Latin America at Chatham House, told Newsweek. "So there could be a surprise on Sunday."

Datafolha's final 2022 poll had Jair Bolsonaro at 36 percent of valid votes in the first round; he finished with about 43 percent.

Brazil Election

...

Brazil Election

...

Brazil Election

...

Brazil Election

...

1 of 4

How the Runoff Works

Brazil's presidential race will now move to a second round on October 25 after neither candidate surpassed the 50 percent threshold required for an outright victory.

The runoff will pit Lula, who is seeking a fourth term, against Bolsonaro, who exceeded expectations and enters the final stretch with momentum after finishing first in the opening round.

Attention is expected to turn to supporters of the candidates eliminated Sunday, particularly voters who backed centrist and right-of-center contenders such as Augusto Cury, Ronaldo Caiado and Romeu Zema.

Their endorsements, along with turnout among undecided and anti-incumbent voters, could prove decisive in the three-week campaign.

The winner takes office on January 5, 2027, the first inauguration held on that date under a 2021 constitutional amendment that moved the ceremony from January 1.

Crime and Domestic Concerns Will Decide the Race, Experts Say

"Elections are always local affairs," Patricio Navia, a clinical professor of liberal studies at New York University, told Newsweek. Voters who think Brazil is headed in the wrong direction will punish Lula on Sunday, he added, and those who approve of his government will reelect him. "I know President Trump thinks that he is on the ballot in Brazil, but he is not."

Security sits at the top of voters' concerns. "In Brazil, the number one issue for voters is security," Gimena Sánchez, director for the Andes at the Washington Office on Latin America, told Newsweek. "There is a perception that security has worsened, but this is not the case."

Sánchez is skeptical of the hardline crackdowns that have become popular across the region. "In our view, the mano dura approach will not diminish violence and crime in a sustainable manner," she said, arguing inequality and a lack of access to land, markets and opportunity have to be addressed. She also warned that the Amazon has become a hub for criminal groups pushed deeper into the forest.

Whoever wins will need Congress, which is elected the same day. "Congress's composition will be decisive in determining how much of Lula's or Flávio's agenda can move forward," Sánchez said, adding that evangelical influence over lawmakers will also matter. One plausible outcome, in her view, is a Lula victory paired with an opposition-controlled Congress.

President Donald Trump speaks with Brazilian President Jair Bolsonaro during a dinner at Mar-a-Lago in Palm Beach, Florida, on March 7, 2020. (Photo by JIM WATSON / AFP) (Photo by JIM WATSON/AFP via Getty Images)

...

What the Result Could Mean for Trump

Washington's pressure campaign has hung over the entire race. Sánchez said the Bolsonaro family's lobbying in Washington "backfired with the trade tariffs that are very unpopular in Brazil," which "forced Flávio to step back on that issue." The U.S. terrorist designations of the Primeiro Comando da Capital (PCC) and Comando Vermelho (CV), she added, are seen by many Brazilians as a possible prelude to American strikes and "a huge infringement on the country's sovereignty."

Navia sees a more mixed effect.

"Trump's actions have hurt the Brazilian economy, and that indirectly damages Lula's chances of reelection, but Lula has made sure to campaign underlining Flávio's proximity to Trump and thus, the net impact of Trump policies is probably not going to matter that much," he said.

If Flávio wins, Sánchez expects Brazil to join the Shield of the Americas and pursue a sweeping crackdown on the newly designated gangs, possibly including joint operations with U.S. forces. On trade, she said Flávio "may be able to negotiate a decrease by giving the U.S. access to Brazil's rare minerals."

Related Story

What Is ‘Shield of the Americas’? What We Know About Kristi Noem’s New Role

What Is ‘Shield of the Americas’? What We Know About Kristi Noem’s New Role

Pulling Brazil away from China is another matter. Washington "will seek to restrict China's expansion in Brazil but it is unlikely to achieve this," Sánchez said, pointing to Argentina, which tried but could not quit Beijing economically.

Navia doubts Flávio's loyalty to Washington would buy Brazil much.

"Being close allies of the U.S. does not automatically mean getting a much better treatment," he said. "If Trump treats Flávio with disrespect, as he has treated other allied governments, there will be bumps in bilateral relations. After all, leftwing and rightwing Brazilians believe their country deserves respect as the largest and most important economy in Latin America."

A Lula win would leave Brazil among a shrinking group of holdouts.

"If he loses, only Mexico and Uruguay will be the bigger countries not in the coalition," Sánchez said, who predicted that Shield governments would keep up the pressure, including "efforts to paint Lula as inept, corrupt, and unable to address violent crime."

She also said the first task for a fourth Lula term would be repairing a relationship so frayed that Washington revoked the visa of Brazil's ambassador.

For Navia, the broader risk for the White House is China.

"If the U.S. does not lower trade barriers to Latin American exports, China will continue to make gains," he said. "Latin Americans want to have stronger and better relations with the U.S., but President Trump does not have a good track record making friends abroad."

Newsweek’s reporters and editors used Martyn, our AI assistant, to produce this story. Learn more about Martyn here. Contact Newsweek editors for this story: Jason Lemon and Anthony Murray.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines