10

Loading video...

Daniel OrtonDan Gooding

By Daniel Orton and Dan Gooding

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


The Trump administration has proposed charging universities $70,000 for each international student they recommend for work authorization in the U.S. after graduation, a sweeping change that could sharply restrict access to a program used by hundreds of thousands of foreign students.

The announcement Wednesday is the latest in a series of changes the Department of Homeland Security has sought to make to the legal immigration system, arguing that increased fees are necessary to combat fraud, fund the agency delivering immigration benefits, and ensure the growth of the U.S. economy.

Critics of the F-1 student visa have long argued it is used as a backdoor to allow thousands of immigrants to remain in the U.S. well beyond their original purpose for entering: to study. Immigration advocates have argued the Optional Practical Training program, which allows students to remain in the country temporarily to work in their field of study, is a vital bridge that allows American companies to hire young talent.

Read More on News

"Optional Practical Training was never meant to be a back door into the American workforce, a subsidy for cheap labor, or a prize for those who game the system," a DHS Spokesperson said in a press release Wednesday. "DHS is upskilling OPT to require foreign students to justify their worth to employers. American workers should not have to compete against a program that has been turned into a pipeline for cheap foreign labor."

New F-1 OPT Fees: What Could Change

Under the proposed new rule, schools certified to enroll foreign students would pay $70,000 for a student’s first OPT recommendation and $30,000 for each subsequent recommendation, including eligible extensions.

Under current rules, eligible F-1 students may receive up to 12 months of temporary employment authorization for work related to their field of study. Graduates with qualifying STEM degrees may be eligible for an additional 24-month extension.

Schools would not be able to recommend OPT until a payment is made, the proposal said, and U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) could deny the temporary work authorization if a payment isn't made.

In the proposal, DHS specifically states it is seeking to reduce participation in the program, so that students do not use OPT as a work pathway.

"DHS believes that this proposed fee would incentivize schools to only recommend the most promising students to engage in OPT after a thorough review and payment of the required fee," the plan read. "Limiting the pool of OPT participants to talented students who are in genuine educational programs and placed in training programs that directly relate to their major area of study would protect the interests and jobs of American workers in the long run."

While schools are expected to be the payers of the application fees, the impact may be that fees are passed on to students themselves. Schools may also become more selective in who they sponsor for OPT.

"Imposing this new fee structure on Optional Practical Training is the latest in a series of developments that creates deep uncertainty for international students," Fanta Aw, PhD, executive director and CEO of NAFSA: Association of International Educators, told Newsweek in a statement.

Zuzana C. Wootson, the deputy director of federal policy for The Presidents' Alliance on Higher Education and Immigration, agreed, telling Newsweek that the new fees would push potential international students to look elsewhere.

“The proposed rule would create a substantial financial barrier to obtaining access to practical training," Wootson said in a statement. "As a result, employers would lose access to U.S.-educated graduates who help meet workforce needs in STEM, healthcare, research, and other fields. Restricting these opportunities would prevent international graduates from contributing the skills they gained at U.S. institutions to our economy, slowing innovation and weakening economic growth.”

Students of Harvard University gather for their graduation ceremonies on Commencement Day.

...

The Trump Admin's Fraud, US Worker Concerns

The Department of Homeland Security (DHS) said the proposed charges were intended to combat fraud, encourage universities to scrutinize applications more closely and protect American workers.

Nearly 20 pages of the proposal released Wednesday discuss the view that OPT has become vulnerable to fraud and has harmed U.S. workers.

The document includes examples, including a 2020 visa fraud case involving a businesswoman who provided fraudulent employment documents to at least 2,693 foreign nationals, mostly Chinese OPT participants. Another 2020 operation involved ICE arresting 15 students accused of fraudulently using OPT to remain in the U.S.

DHS also outlined how investigators have allegedly found 10,000 OPT participants working for "highly suspect employers," with residential homes listed as business locations, multiple companies using the same addresses, and missing employment records.

The plan also reflects ongoing concerns of foreign workers replacing U.S. citizens in the labor market, pointing to almost 200,000 students participating in OPT in 2024 alone, pushing out American workers in part because they are cheaper.

Aw pushed back against the department's reasoning, telling Newsweek in her statement that OPT helps to fill labor shortages in high-demand STEM fields.

"The research is clear: international students don’t take opportunities from Americans, they create them," Aw said. "Driving away the talents, perspectives, and aspirations of international students will only hurt American innovation, economic growth, workforce development, and global leadership."

When Will the New Fees Be Implemented?

If finalized, the fees would take effect 60 days after publication of that final rule and would apply prospectively to new recommendations.

There is the chance that legal challenges will follow, as has been the case when the Trump administration has sought to impose other new or drastically increased visa fees, such as the $100,000 H-1B application fee.

Related Story

New H-1B Bill Would Hit Employers With $250,000 Fines

New H-1B Bill Would Hit Employers With $250,000 Fines

One issue which could spark legal challenges is where the money would be sent after it is collected from schools or foreign students.

"DHS claims that they don't have enough resources to deal with fraud, but then admits that not a penny of these fees would go toward fraud prevention -- instead, the Treasury Department would get the money," Doug Rand, a former DHS official, told Newsweek. "Why? This is a direct quote: 'because the statute does not provide legal authority for ICE to retain the funds collected.'

"In other words, this is an unlawful tax," Rand said. "When we educate international students at our universities, and they want to work and apply their talents here after graduating, of course we should we embrace them -- not use an exorbitant fee as a pretext to send them packing."

Newsweek’s reporters and editors used Martyn, our AI assistant, to produce this story. Learn more about Martyn here.

Contact Newsweek editors on this story: Daniel Orton and Gray R. Thomas

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines