
...

By Katherine Fung
Senior Writer
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
The peculiar and mostly dormant American political phenomenon of ticket-splitting has made something of a resurgence in the era of Donald Trump, as several senate and gubernatorial candidates he has endorsed are trailing their Democratic rivals in states where he maintains a lead.
Trump supporters are the most likely to split their tickets, which is when voters cast ballots for candidates of opposing parties in the same election. In a hyper-partisan climate, it's become increasingly rare for voters to support different parties for their member of Congress and the presidency.
Yet, an average of 7 percent of likely voters in states with competitive Senate races say they would back former President Donald Trump while also voting for a Democratic Senate candidate, the latest New York Times/Siena College poll shows. The surveys was conducted among voters in five battleground states between September 21 to 26, with a margin of error of about 4 percentage points.
Read More on Politics
"Ticket splitting has been in decline for decades and it's unlikely it will exist in a major, widespread fashion in 2024," political pundit Steve Schier told Newsweek. "But in very tight Senate and House races, it could spell the difference between victory and defeat."

...
How Ticket-Splitting Became An Endangered Practice
Ticket-splitting peaked between 1972 and 1992, according to an analysis from the University of Virginia's Center for Politics. In 1984, 17 states elected a Senate candidate from one party while also backing a presidential candidate from another. That year, 16 states that re-elected Republican President Ronald Reagan also voted for a Democratic senator.
For instance, Democrat Walter Mondale carried Minnesota — the only state he won that year — while Minnesotans also voted to send incumbent Senator Rudy Boschwitz, a Republican, back to Congress.
By 1996, the phenomenon had begun to decline. There were still seven states who split their vote in the 2008 election and eight states who voted for different parties for the presidency and Senate in 2012. But by 2016, not a single state split its ticket. In 2020, only one state, Maine, supported a presidential candidate and a Senate candidate from opposing parties. President Joe Biden carried Maine by 9 percentage points. The state also reelected Republican Senator Susan Collins by a similar margin.
Which States Could Split Their Ballots in 2024?
- Arizona has the highest share of ticket-splitters, with 10 percent of Trump supporters signaling that they would back Representative Ruben Gallego over for the state's open Senate seat, according the Times/Siena poll. The former president has thrown his support behind MAGA acolyte and one-time rising star Kari Lake in the race. Gallego currently leads Lake by six points, while Trump has a two-point edge over Vice President Kamala Harris in Arizona.
- Ohiois the most likely of the poll's five competitive states to back Trump. The former president easily won it in both 2016 and 2020, but incumbent Democratic Senator Sherrod Brown is leading in the close race against Trump's candidate, Bernie Moreno. Brown has a four-point advantage over Moreno among likely voters in the Buckeye State, while Trump is leading Harris by six points.Kathleen Eagen, a voter from Cincinnati who plans to support both Brown and Trump, told the Times, "We are a rare group, but I know quite a few people in Ohio who fall into this camp."
- In Pennsylvania, the biggest swing state in play with 19 electoral votes, Senator Bob Casey is leading his GOP opponent, Trump-backed David McCormick, by nine points. Harris has a slight edge in the Keystone State, but its less than one percentage point over Trump.
- Representative Elissa Slotkin is leading Mike Rogers, who has been endorsed by Trump, by 5 points in the Michigan Senate race. Harris has a one-point advantage over Trump, but that lead is within the poll's margin of error.
- A similar picture is emerging in Wisconsin, where Senator Tammy Baldwin leads her Republican rival by seven points and Harris has a two-point edge over Trump.
- North Carolina's gubernatorial race, which has been mired in controversy for the embattled Republican nominee Mark Robinson, is also looking promising for Democrat Josh Stein. A new Washington Post poll released Tuesday shows Stein up by 16 points. But that same survey also found Trump leading Harris by 2 points in the state.
Republicans Could Flip A Seat in Deep-Blue Maryland
Maryland's Senate race has been surprisingly competitive. The popular former Republican governor, Larry Hogan, is looking to flip the seat in a state that has not voted for a GOP presidential candidate since 1988. And Democrats have taken notice.
A PCA linked to Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer is launching a $1.2 million ad campaign to help Angela Alsobrooks defend the Democratic seat. Alsobrooks is up seven points over Hogan, according to FiveThirtyEight's polling average, but Republicans have touted internal surveys that they say shows a closer race.
Maryland is yet another example of what could be a ticket-splitting vote.
Colin Pascal, a voter from Annapolis, Maryland, told PBS News, "I'm a registered Democrat. I have been a Democrat my entire life, and I'm voting for Larry Hogan, who's the Maryland Republican candidate for Senate."
"Hogan is that one-off politician who's viewed favorably by Democrats, Republicans, and independents," longtime Maryland pollster Patrick Gonzales wrote for the Maryland Reporter last month. "But he's up against an opponent who is herself exceptionally popular within her party base. And in Maryland, a unified election day voice from registered Democrats is a very difficult dynamic to overcome."
According to Gonzales' own survey, Hogan is widely popular among voters. Half of Maryland voters have a favorable opinion of the former governor, while less than a fifth have an unfavorable opinion. Hogan benefits from an even higher share of GOP support, earning 82 percent of the Republican vote, a figure two-points higher than Trump's standing.
"For a Republican to win statewide in Maryland it always comes down to basic mathematics...can Hogan snatch away 30% of the Democratic vote to secure victory on Nov. 5?" Gonzales asked.
A Potential Bright Spot for Democrats: Montana
Although voters may be willing to split their vote to elect Trump, there is some good news for the Democratic Party in Montana.
The Center for Politics' analysis found that even though Big Sky Country is solidly red, it is the state that has split its ticket most frequently in the postwar period, and almost always to the benefit of Senate Democrats. Montana split its vote in the 1952, 1960, 1972, 1976, 1984, 1996, 2008 and 2012 elections, each time casting a ballot for a Republican presidential candidate and a Democratic Senate candidate.
"This is good news for [Senator Jon] Tester, who, as we have alluded to earlier is in a Toss-up race to keep his seat in a state that Trump will likely carry by double-digits," J. Miles Coleman, the associate editor of the Center for Politics' newsletter "Sabato's Crystal Ball," wrote in February.
Still, Tester, a centrist Democrat who has served as senator since 2006, is trailing Republican Tim Sheehy by 3.7 percentage points, according to FiveThirtyEight. Trump, who has endorsed Sheehy, is leading in Montana by nearly 17 percentage points.
What Does All of This Mean for Trump and Harris?
Schier said control of Congress will be "vital" for both Trump or Harris. Whoever wins November's election will want their party to lead both the House and Senate "because polarization is so intense that major bipartisan legislation is impossible, except perhaps to keep the government functioning through continuing resolutions."
"Top-down coattails could have a big impact on future governance," he said. "Watch the close Senate races -- Wisconsin, Pennsylvania, Nevada, Montana, Ohio, Florida and maybe Maryland and Texas -- that's where top-down coattails could make a major difference."
Who Are The Ticket-Splitters?
The voters indicating that they'll back a Democratic candidate while voting for a second Trump term are largely Republican-leaning, although they tend to hold more moderate views, according to the Times/Siena poll.
The majority, 62 percent, said they supported Trump in the last election. They are also typically younger voters with less education. More than two-thirds said they wanted abortion to be legal, which helps explain why Trump has taken a more moderate view on the hot-button issue despite overseeing the Supreme Court's rightward shift that led to Roe v. Wade being overturned.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines