FILE – The Supreme Court facade is seen in Washington, Nov. 4, 2020. (AP Photo/J. Scott Applewhite, File)

...

Hollie Silverman

By Hollie Silverman

News Editor

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


U.S. Supreme Court Justices Clarence Thomas and Samuel Alito appeared to side with the state of Alabama during the execution case of Joseph Clifton Smith on Wednesday.

The Supreme Court heard two hours of arguments in Hamm v. Smith, a case that could alter the standard for determining whether someone is too intellectually disabled to be executed. There was no clear outcome following the hearing. The Associated Press (AP) reported that Alito and Thomas appeared poised to side with Alabama and allow executions to continue despite IQ.

Alito argued that setting a new precedent could lead to additional death-row inmates appealing, noting that a ruling for Smith could create a situation “where everything is up for grabs in every case."

Read More on News

Alabama sought to overturn lower federal court rulings that determined Joseph Clifton Smith, 55, met the legal definition of intellectual disability despite never scoring below 70 on any of his five IQ tests, which ranged from 72 to 78. Smith has spent nearly half his life on death row following his conviction for the 1997 killing of Durk Van Dam.

The U.S. Supreme Court facade on November 4, 2020, in Washington. (AP Photo/J. Scott Applewhite, File)

...

Why It Matters

The Supreme Court’s deliberation over Alabama’s appeal to execute Smith goes to the heart of how intellectual disability is defined—and defended—in American death penalty law. Since the Court’s 2002 ruling in Atkins v. Virginia banning execution of intellectually disabled defendants, states and lower courts have grappled with how to apply medical science, especially in cases with borderline IQ scores.

The decision has wide-ranging implications for death-row prisoners across the United States, particularly in states seeking to narrow criteria for disability exemptions. Advocates, medical experts and legal scholars emphasize that the outcome could shift the landscape for individuals with intellectual disabilities facing capital punishment, potentially affecting how courts weigh medical and psychological evidence when a person’s IQ is near the traditional cutoff of 70.

What To Know

After Atkins v. Virginia, the Court in 2014 and 2017 held that states should consider other evidence of disability in borderline cases because of the margin of error in IQ tests, AP reported. Alito and Thomas dissented in both cases.

The central issue in Hamm v. Smith is whether states must look beyond IQ test scores and also consider other developmental and adaptive behaviors when determining intellectual disability.

Lower courts had done just that in Smith’s case, noting his placement in learning-disabled classes, dropping out after seventh grade, and an ability to perform math only at a kindergarten level and read at a fourth-grade level at the time of the crime. Smith was also diagnosed with what was then termed "mental retardation" as a child.

Attorneys for Alabama argued that test scores above 70 should categorically exclude inmates from being considered intellectually disabled. Robert M. Overing, the state’s lawyer, told the justices, “There is no way that he can prove an IQ below 70.”

Smith’s counsel, former U.S. Solicitor General Seth Waxman, urged the Court to support prior rulings that accepted a “holistic” approach—using all available evidence in close cases rather than treating IQ scores as absolute.

Rights organizations for people with disabilities filed supporting briefs warning against reliance on IQ scores alone, emphasizing that such methods “are faulty and invalid.”

The Court’s discussion reflected broader concerns raised by states and disability advocates about evolving science and the consistency of criminal justice.

Smith was sentenced for the murder of Van Dam in Mobile County. Prosecutors said Van Dam was killed with a hammer and robbed of $150, boots and tools.

Smith's co-defendant, Larry Reid, pleaded guilty to murder and received life in prison. A federal judge vacated Smith’s sentence in 2021, calling it “a close case.” Alabama law currently defines intellectual disability as an IQ of 70 or below, with significant adaptive behavior deficits manifesting before age 18.

The legal debate pivots on how clinical standards shift over time, and whether future definitions—some critics argue—could continually move the bar for who qualifies as intellectually disabled and exempt from execution.

What People Are Saying

U.S. Supreme Court Justice Samuel Alito, said on Wednesday that a ruling for Smith would lead to messy court fights for other death row inmates "where everything is up for grabs in every case.”

Robert M. Overing, lawyer for the State of Alabama, in U.S. Supreme Court arguments Wednesday: “There is no way that he can prove an IQ below 70.”

What Happens Next

The Supreme Court is expected to issue its decision in Hamm v. Smith by early summer 2026. Alabama and at least 20 other states have pressed for a standard more reliant on strict test score thresholds, while disability advocates and Smith’s legal team urge a broader consideration of all evidence in close cases. Legal experts anticipate the ruling could impact future death penalty appeals nationwide.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines