SYDNEY, AUSTRALIA – DECEMBER 15: Members of the public lay flowers at a memorial at Bondi Pavilion in the wake of a mass shooting at Bondi Beach yesterday, on December 15, 2025 in Sydney, Australia. Police say at least 16 people, including one suspected gunman, were killed and more than 40 others injured when two attackers opened fire near a Hanukkah celebration at the world-famous Bondi Beach, in what authorities have declared a terrorist incident. (Photo by George Chan/Getty Images)

...

Aviva Klompas

By Aviva Klompas

Co-Founder of Boundless

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


It was inevitable. The warning signs were unmistakable. The Jewish families who gathered at Bondi Beach in Sydney to celebrate Hanukkah were targeted for doing exactly what the holiday represents: showing up openly as Jews.

To be clear, they were not caught in a geopolitical dispute. This was not the result of a policy disagreement or a misunderstanding about Israel. It was the endpoint of a worldview that denies Jewish legitimacy, strips Jews of moral standing and treats Jewish presence itself as provocation.

Members of the public lay flowers at a memorial at Bondi Pavilion in the wake of a mass shooting at Bondi Beach, on December 15, 2025 in Sydney, Australia. (Photo by George Chan/Getty Images)

...

Read More on Opinion

The attack was also not sudden or inexplicable. It was the foreseeable result of a sustained failure to take antisemitism seriously before it turned lethal.

For years, Jewish communities in Australia and across the West warned that antisemitism was no longer confined to the fringes. They pointed to rhetoric calling for “intifada” and “resistance,” to protests outside synagogues, to vandalism and arson, to harassment of Jewish students on campus and to marches through Jewish neighborhoods. These were not isolated incidents, but a pattern of escalation.

Earlier this year in Washington, that pattern turned lethal. The murder of two Israeli embassy employees occurred against a backdrop of normalized antisemitic incitement and a persistent failure to take its dangers seriously.

Again and again, Jewish communities were told this was protest. It was framed as anger about Israel. Antisemitism was contextualized or minimized, treated as speech that might be uncomfortable but did not warrant intervention. That judgment was a grave mistake.

Protest has boundaries. It challenges policies, not people. It targets governments, not religious gatherings. It does not follow families to holiday celebrations or frame ethnic or religious identity as a political offense. When a movement insists that Jewish presence itself is provocative, it has left the realm of politics and entered the territory of hate.

That line was crossed long ago. Authorities failed to enforce it.

We now know that Israel’s intelligence services reportedly warned Australia about threats to its Jewish community. Jewish leaders raised concerns with law enforcement and government officials, urging that escalating threats be taken seriously and that harassment be addressed before it became something worse. The problem was not a lack of information. It was a lack of resolve.

This is the failure at the heart of the Sydney attack.

When societies hesitate to confront hatred directly, they normalize it. When intimidation is tolerated, those inclined toward violence learn that escalation carries little cost. When calls for violence are reframed as political expression, the barrier between rhetoric and action erodes.

The distinction between protest and hate is not semantic. It is a matter of public safety. Once identity is treated as ideology, once Jews are held collectively responsible for the actions of a foreign government, once Jewish spaces are framed as legitimate targets, violence becomes easier to justify for those already predisposed to it.

This is not about Jewish fragility. It is about the integrity of democratic societies.

Democracies have a responsibility to protect minority communities before tragedy strikes, not after. That means listening when communities raise alarms instead of dismissing them as overwrought. It means enforcing the line between lawful protest and intimidation. And it means recognizing that antisemitism often arrives cloaked in political language, but behaves like every other form of bigotry when left unchecked.

Hanukkah is often described as a festival of light, but its origins offer a stark reminder for our times. The holiday commemorates a moment when Jews were persecuted for their identity and forced to fight for the right to live openly as Jews. It does not promise safety. It marks continuity: the refusal to disappear, even when visibility carries risk.

That is what the victims in Sydney were doing. They were living openly as Jews. They were trusting that the institutions around them would uphold their responsibility to keep them safe. They were failed.

The lesson of this attack is not that antisemitism exists. That has never been in doubt. The lesson is that ignoring it, excusing it, or reframing it as politics carries deadly consequences.

Leaders from Australia to the United States now face a choice. They can continue to blur the line between protest and hate until it disappears altogether. Or they can draw it clearly, enforce it consistently, and act on warnings before the next tragedy is declared inevitable.

Sydney should have been a wake-up call. The question is whether anyone will answer it.

Aviva Klompas is CEO and cofounder of Boundless Israel, a nonprofit dedicated to fighting antisemitism*. She is also the host of the* Boundless Insights podcast.

The views expressed in this article are the writer's own.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines