By Robert Mardini
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
On January 1 this year, shortly before 5 a.m., the phone rang at Geneva University Hospital (HUG).
A few hours earlier, in the Swiss resort of Crans-Montana, fire had swept through a crowded bar during New Year celebrations. Forty people died. More than a hundred were injured, many of them very young and severely burned. No single hospital, and not even a single country, could care for them all. Within hours, patients were flown to burn centers in Lausanne and Zurich, and on to Paris, Milan and Stuttgart. For a few days, hospitals in several countries acted as one system.
Nobody had a plan for that particular night. Nobody could have.
Read More on Community Forum
That is the uncomfortable truth every health leader now faces: The next crisis will not look like the last one. It may be a mass-casualty event, extreme heat, a cyberattack, a broken supply chain or a new virus. It may be several at once.
So what should we prepare for? My answer is simple: we should prepare to move.
For almost three decades with the International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC), including four years serving as its director-general, I worked in places where the unexpected was the norm. For the past two years, I have served as CEO of one of Europe's largest university hospitals. Those two very different worlds taught me one shared lesson: Resilience is not a plan; It is a way of governing.
We usually judge health systems by their preparedness. Do they have an emergency plan? Enough beds? Critical supplies? These are necessary questions. But they tell us little about how an organization will actually behave when reality departs from the plan. And reality always does.
What matters is whether a system can do five things under pressure: anticipate, decide, mobilize, adapt and learn.

...
Anticipate. Anticipation is not prediction. It is the discipline of asking, before the pressure arrives, what could happen, what would be at stake and what we would need.
When G7 leaders met in Evian, France, this June, just across Lake Geneva, nobody knew whether the large demonstrations would turn violent. We hoped nothing would happen. We prepared as if something might. We opened some 40 additional beds and cut planned surgery by a fifth for a week. We put up tents outside the emergency department for people exposed to tear gas. And because thousands of our nurses and doctors live in France, we issued more than 5,000 cross-border passes so they could reach work easily.
In the end, the summit passed without a major influx of casualties. Was the effort wasted? No. We clarified who decides what, tested our relationships and found gaps we did not know we had. Preparation itself creates capability, and that capability stays long after the risk has passed.
Decide. In a crisis, information arrives fragmented and contradictory, and it changes by the hour. Waiting for certainty is itself a decision, and usually the wrong one.
At the ICRC, a head of delegation in a remote area often could not wait for instructions from Geneva. What headquarters gave them was not a procedure for every situation; It was clear intent, firm principles and trust. Hospitals are not so different. That is why we are working with our department heads to make explicit what is delegated, what is decided centrally and to confront what is still ambiguous. The ambiguous zone is exactly where a crisis will find you.
Good leadership does not eliminate uncertainty; It makes sound decisions in spite of it.
Mobilize. Technology, infrastructure and plans matter. But people and trust make a system move.
In humanitarian work, there is a simple rule: You better not negotiate access at the checkpoint. You earn it months before, through countless conversations with everyone who has a say. Trust cannot be built in the middle of a crisis; It is built beforehand.
No hospital is an island. On the night of the Crans-Montana fire, our hospital received five patients, but it also sent medicines to colleagues in Lausanne and ambulances to the mountains. Our dependencies now extend to other hospitals, suppliers, energy, digital platforms and global supply chains. Governing for resilience means understanding the vulnerabilities of that whole ecosystem – not only our own.
Adapt. Even an excellent plan eventually meets reality. This summer, Geneva endured intense heat. We had a heat plan, and we applied it. But in some of our older buildings, patient rooms rose above 86 degrees Fahrenheit. A nurse wrote to me, not only to say what was not working but to propose concrete fixes. Her letter told me more than many of our indicators did.
The plan was not wrong. It was incomplete, and the people who knew it best were not in the crisis room. They were on the ward. A plan that sits unchanged in a drawer for five years may be reassuring. It may also be completely wrong.
Learn. This is where resilience becomes something more. In 2017, a critical storage system at the heart of our hospital's IT failed. Its twin, designed to take over in exactly that situation, did not. The lesson was humbling: Redundancy on paper is not redundancy in reality. We did not simply repair the machine, we built round-the-clock security monitoring, paper-based procedures so wards can keep caring for patients and regular tests of all of it. A back-up that has never been tested is a hope, not a plan.
The test of learning is not whether we held a debrief; It is whether something is different afterward.

...
At its best, that learning can change the world. Some 30 years ago, Professor Didier Pittet and his teams in HUG took on a problem every hospital lived with: infections carried from patient to patient on caregivers' hands. Their answer was alcohol-based hand rub at the bedside, and a culture to go with it. Rather than keep it, the hospital shared it freely. Through the World Health Organization (WHO), it has since been adopted by hospitals worldwide. That is experience turned into capability, and capability turned into a public good.
Nassim Nicholas Taleb calls this antifragility: growing stronger because of shocks, not merely surviving them. I prefer a more hopeful name: adaptive growth.
For leaders, this points to five questions that belong on the agenda of executive teams and boards, in ordinary times rather than only in a crisis:
- Who decides at 5 a.m., and do they know it?
- Which dependency would stop us tomorrow, and have we actually tested the back-up?
- Who will we call, and have we worked with them before we need them?
- When did we last change a plan because someone on the front line told us it was wrong?
- What is different today because of our last crisis?
None of the answers that mattered on New Year's morning were improvised that night. They had been built, patiently, on ordinary days.
The future will surprise us. Our responsibility is not to eliminate surprise; It is to make sure that when it comes, our organizations are ready to move and emerge better equipped for what follows. Not only withstanding shocks. Growing because of them.
Robert Mardini is director-general of Geneva University Hospital (HUG) and a member of the Newsweek CEO Circle. He was previously director-general of the International Committee of the Red Cross (2020–2024). The views expressed in this article are the writer's own.
Robert Mardini is a member of the Newsweek CEO Circle, an invite-only executive community of subscribers.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines