A woman holds a placard with an upside down American flag as mourners gather at a makeshift memorial in the area where Alex Pretti was shot dead a day earlier by federal immigration agents in Minneapolis, Minnesota, on January 25, 2026.

...

 Joshua Sammons

By  Joshua Sammons

Community Manager

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


Welcome back to The Conversation, Newsweek’s weekly roundup of reader comments, opinions and debates. We turn our attention this week to the controversy surrounding Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE).

Department of Homeland Security (DHS) Secretary Kristi Noem has faced backlash after federal agents shot and killed 37-year-old U.S. citizen Alex Pretti in Minneapolis, less than two weeks after the killing of another U.S. citizen, Renee Good, by an ICE agent in the same city.

The killings have left both a city and nation in shock, sparking protests across the country. They have put President Donald Trump’s immigration policy under the spotlight, not just in America but across the world.

Read More on News

More than three-quarters of House Democrats have backed a resolution to impeach Noem but, despite Democratic anger, the impeachment effort faces an uphill battle in the GOP-controlled House.

Meanwhile, White House border czar Tom Homan acknowledged shortcomings in federal immigration enforcement operations. During a conference Thursday, he commented "nothing's ever perfect" and pledged to make the mission safer and more efficient.

Here is what Newsweek readers had to say:

On the Backlash ICE Faces Over Minnesota

Original Article: Minneapolis Is Proving ICE’s Undoing

Background: In the aftermath of the killings of Good and Pretti, the government is facing public backlash, protests, and falling ratings for its immigration policy, putting pressure on Trump and his administration over their handling of the anti-immigration drive in Minnesota.

**Original Comment: "**There is a simple, humane solution to this. Provide a pathway to citizenship for those here. If those that apply are non-violent, let them get in line to become legal.

"I am not a Democract. I am not a Progressive. I am a moderate in a swing state and I feel this is the best path forward. I expect those raised with good values agree that what is happening is not the America we can be proud of. I will not be voting for this administration or this GOP going forward while they denigrate our national reputation. We are not barbarians." Christopherfinland

Editor’s Note: This commenter offers a measured critique that resonates with readers focused on moderation and civic responsibility. Framed in non-partisan terms, the comment highlights how the debate over immigration enforcement is prompting broader questions about policy and public trust.

On Reactions to Tom Homan’s Press Conference

Original Article: Tom Homan Reveals New ICE Agreement With Keith Ellison

Background: Homan, speaking in Minneapolis on Thursday morning, said Minnesota Attorney General Keith Ellison had clarified to him that county jails in the state can notify ICE of the release dates of people posing "criminal public safety risks" so they can be taken into custody immediately.

Featured Comment: "Well, Homan at least seems to have his head screwed on straight. Should be, given his past experience with Obama. Too bad so few others working for Trump are fit for the job." T4MePuhlease

Editor’s Note: This commenter offers a cautious recognition of Homan’s experience while noting broader concerns about administration personnel. This reflects a perspective among readers who weigh individual competence alongside overall policy effectiveness.

Original Comment: "Walz folded. He gave Trump exactly what he wanted, and in return Trump agreed to scale back ICE operations in Minnesota. That is how negotiations work. Trump is a deal maker, but a deal only happens when the other side actually gives something up. No freebies. The same thing happened with Mamdani when he won. He went to the White House, cut a deal, and that is precisely why Trump has largely stayed out of NYC for now." IronLedger

Editor’s Note: Taking a different approach, the commenter emphasizes Trump’s willingness to compromise. They focus on the give-and-take of negotiation, highlighting how concessions and reciprocal action shape political outcomes.

On ICE Ending Special Operation in Maine

Original Article: ICE Ends Special Operation in Maine, Senator Confirms

Background: U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) has ended its special operation in Maine, Republican Senator Susan Collins said.

Original Comment: "It is too early to tell but that looks like a good sign that Trump might have learned that treating it like an invasion will not work but treating it like a professional law enforcement operation will." cannibal

Editor’s Note: In response to this story, this commenter offers cautious optimism about a change in approach, framing the development as a possible shift toward more measured enforcement.

On Falling Approval Ratings For ICE, DHS and Noem

Original Article: ICE, DHS and Noem Approval Rating at All-Time Low: 'Disaster for Trump'

Background: The approval ratings of ICE, the DHS and Noem are at an all-time low, according to polling data analyzed by CNN.

Original Comment: "ICE and DHS is a result of Trump's demand for loyalty over competency. It is the most visible, but not the sole problem. In Trump's first failed term, there was a revolving door as he burned through his 'only the best' appointees. He ground them up and tossed them under the bus. The second failed term is firing up the grinders." Mjolnir

Editor’s Note: This commenter connects falling approval ratings to long-standing critiques of leadership and governance style. The response echoes concern among critics that institutional strain and personnel turnover have compounded public distrust in federal immigration enforcement.

Thank you for carrying on The Conversation—make sure to keep an eye out for more highlighted comments over the next few weeks.

In a polarized era, the center is dismissed as bland. At Newsweek, ours is different: The Courageous Center—it's not "both sides," it's sharp, challenging and alive with ideas. We follow facts, not factions. If that sounds like the kind of journalism you want to see thrive, we need you.

When you become a Newsweek Member, you support a mission to keep the center strong and vibrant. Members enjoy: Ad-free browsing, exclusive content and editor conversations. Help keep the center courageous. Join today.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines