10

Loading video...

Lars Hanson

By Lars Hanson

Associate News Editor

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


On first choices alone, Alaska's race for its lone U.S. House seat looks like a familiar story. Republican Representative Nick Begich III, who unseated Democrat Mary Peltola in 2024, had 133,707 votes, or 47.71 percent, to independent Bill Hill's 116,932, or 41.72 percent, according to unofficial results from the Alaska Division of Elections as of 7:15 p.m. Eastern on Saturday. Democrat Eric Hafner had 21,815, or 7.78 percent, and Libertarian James C. "Jim" McDermott had 7,384, or 2.63 percent. Write-ins drew 430.

But Alaska does not decide its elections on first choices alone, and the AP lists the race as awaiting ranked-choice results. When Newsweek ran the state's ballot data through tabulation software, the race reached a final round with Begich at 137,235 votes, or 51.5 percent, and Hill at 129,237, or 48.49 percent.

That is Newsweek's estimate, not an official result. Ballots are still being counted, and the AP has not called the race.

Read More on News

How the Count Works

Alaska voters may rank up to four candidates. If no one wins a majority of first choices, the last-place candidate is eliminated, and those ballots move to each voter's next choice still in the race. Candidates are eliminated one at a time until one has a majority of the active ballots. The Alaska Division of Elections will run its official tabulation on November 18 and has set a target of November 25 for certification.

Newsweek's estimate draws on the cast vote record, a file the Division publishes with the rankings on every ballot read by its scanners. It "does not include ballots that were only counted by hand," according to the Division. Newsweek processed the file with RCTab, open-source tabulation software, with settings matching the Division's published rules for write-ins, overvotes and skipped rankings.

Rep. Nick Begich III, left, and Bill Hill, right.

...

Round by Round

The record holds 282,698 ballots. Of those, 2,177 ranked no one in the House race. Another 444 were inactive from the first round: 194 were overvotes, with more than one candidate marked at the same ranking, and 250 were set aside under the state's rules on skipped rankings.

In the first round of Newsweek's tabulation, Begich had 133,602 votes, or 47.7 percent; Hill 116,821, or 41.71 percent; Hafner 21,798, or 7.78 percent; and McDermott 7,427, or 2.65 percent. Write-ins drew 429.

Write-ins go first. Under state regulation, unresolved write-ins are treated as a single group and eliminated. Of those ballots, 85 move to Hill, 39 to Begich, 33 to McDermott and 23 to Hafner, while 249 drop out of the count.

McDermott is next, carrying 7,460 ballots. Hill picks up 2,061 of them, Begich 2,024 and Hafner 916. Another 2,459 stop counting.

Then comes Hafner, the only registered Democrat on the ballot, who is serving a federal prison sentence. State Democrats had lined up behind Hill, a Bristol Bay fisherman and educator. Newsweek examined earlier this month how large a share of the vote Hafner drew anyway. Of the 22,737 ballots counting for him by then, 10,270 move to Hill and 1,570 to Begich. The other 10,897 drop out of the count, nearly all because they ranked neither.

That leaves the final round: Begich 137,235, or 51.5 percent, and Hill 129,237, or 48.49 percent. By then, 266,472 ballots were still active; 14,049 had gone inactive along the way, including the 444 from the first round, while the 2,177 blank ballots never entered the count.

What the Data Can't Say Yet

The first-round totals in Newsweek's tabulation don't match the Division's exactly. The Division says its cast vote record excludes ballots counted only by hand. The two sets of figures differ by 191 votes, and the precise breakdown of that difference has not been established.

Nor is the count finished. The Division reports results from all 401 precincts, but that is not every ballot. As of 8:29 a.m. Eastern on Sunday, the AP estimated that 97 percent of votes had been counted. That suggests several thousand ballots remain, although the precise number has not been established.

In Newsweek's final round, Hill trailed Begich by 7,998 votes. For him to pull ahead, ballots missing from the scanned record would have to favor him by a net 7,999 votes in that round. How many ballots fall outside the record, including those already counted by hand, has not been established, so the tabulation can't show whether that gap could close.

Overseas ballots can still arrive through November 18.

On Wednesday, the Division will run the official ranked-choice count. Until then, the first-choice tally tells only part of the story.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines