Bookshop

...

James Bickerton

By James Bickerton

News Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


A bill has been introduced to the Texas Legislature that could result in bookstores facing fines and legal costs if they place material deemed "obscene" within access of a minor.

House Bill 1375 was proposed by state Representative Nate Schatzline, a Republican, who said it is needed to keep "harmful material" away from children. Critics argue it would force bookshops to self-censor or risk potentially devastating lawsuits.

Why It Matters

In recent years, a number of Republican-controlled states have passed laws banning school libraries from holding certain books that they regard as inappropriate.

Read More on U.S.

The Texas Legislature in 2023 passed a bill forbidding school libraries from having any book among its stacks that "describes or portrays sexual conduct" in a "patently offensive way" that are not required by the curriculum.

PEN America recorded 3,362 instances of what it classified as book bans across the U.S. in the 2022-23 academic year, a 33 percent rise from the previous year.

What To Know

House Bill 1375 would make commercial enterprises, such as bookstores, liable for "damages arising from the distribution, transmission, or display of harmful material to a minor."

This would include when such material is "readily accessible to minors" or "includes a minor's visual image, audio voice, or participation in any manner."

Any business found to have broken this law could have to pay damages and would be liable for associated court costs and legal fees.

Bookshop

...

The legislation also specifies that a business could face multiple lawsuits over the same piece of material deemed obscene if more than one person decides to launch a case. Such material could be reported by either minors or their parents/guardians.

The bill does contain protections for media organizations including newspapers, magazines and TV stations.

What People Are Saying

Speaking to Newsweek, Schatzline said: "House Bill 1375 gives parents the tools to fight back against the sexualization of their kids. There is a flood of obscene material being spread through cell phones, internet sites, and even booksellers to children.

"This bill ensures that those who knowingly distribute obscene material to children—whether online or in person—can and will be held civilly liable. And to ensure fairness, we are also working on a committee substitute that allows businesses wrongfully targeted with frivolous lawsuits to recover the costs of their defense."

Addressing local television network KTBS, Schatzline said: "This bill also holds commercial entities accountable if they are knowingly distributing, transmitting or displaying harmful material to minors in a way that is readily accessible or includes a minor's image, voice and participation.

"If a business is used to engage in an obscenity for the personal benefit of its owner, those people can be held liable."

Charley Rejsek, who runs BookPeople in Austin, Texas, commented: "HB 1375 threatens to no longer allow those young readers in our bookstores and ultimately could cause some bookstores to close their doors."

In a post on X, the Texas Freedom to Read Project, which campaigns against book bans, said: "HB 1375, authored by Representative Schatzline, makes it easier for book banners and other bad actors to raise frivolous claims against local bookshops, big box stores, and online retailers over books they will falsely claim are 'harmful to minors.'

"The increased risk of lawsuits will make it harder for retailers to do business in our local communities and in Texas as a whole. What school district is going to work with a bookseller accused (falsely or not!) of distributing 'harmful materials to minors?'"

Speaking to news outlet Chron, Texas Freedom to Read Project co-founder Anne Russey said: "We've been told by people trying to ban books, 'don't worry, it's not a book ban, you can buy whatever books you want at a private bookstore.

"This bill is potentially making it harder for private booksellers to shelve and offer the kind of books that we've seen banned or challenged in public schools and libraries."

What Happens Next

The Lone Star State's House Bill 1375 awaits a committee appearance. A similar bill failed to pass during the last legislative session. Texas Governor Greg Abbott is a Republican and the GOP has a strong majority in both chambers of the state Legislature.

Update 5/1/25, 2:33 a.m. ET: This story has been updated with comment from state Rep. Nate Schatzline.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines